UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • brownjesus10
    Rookie
    • Jul 2020
    • 15

    #16
    Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

    Originally posted by Phillyboi207
    I agree with everything you said so I double checked Ngannou's rating

    His 89 Takedown is in error. It should be 85. I'll also look into having that corrected.
    Thank you! I’m a huge stat/AI nerd so it is ****ing awesome to have feedback this quickly. If I see anything else I’ll pass it along

    Comment

    • Phillyboi207
      Banned
      • Apr 2012
      • 3159

      #17
      Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

      Originally posted by mcm12345
      Thank you for putting high quality thought into your answer.

      Faber bloodied Brad Pickett with GNP elbows in his third most recent fight and also the last fight where he spent prolonged periods on top. You could see the damage Faber's GNP had done to his face. Brad got dropped with a punch but he was cut open with Ground and Pound. He got a 10-8 round in some of the judges scorecards for that fight and they typically don't give 10-8s to guys who are inactive while on top. Faber did enough damage to convince them. And he continued to hurt Brad on top through the rest of the fight

      For older examples, there's the fight with Brian Bowles (former WEC champion) where he delivered multiple damaging shots on top that caused Bowles to give up his back for the choke. I'm sure there's more

      For a comparison within the division, TJ Dillashaw has a 91 in ground and pound. TJ in recent times doesn't use his top game very often to land strikes. The only time in recent memory he used GNP was against John Lineker. And he didn't do any real damage to Lineker. He outclassed him but he never truely hurt him. He didn't do the damage that Faber has shown.

      The only other time TJ showed ground strikes was against Cody Garbrandt but that was a ''FINISH THE FIGHT'' style of strike has opposed to the GNP technique (posturing up and stuff on an opponent who isn't already on queer street). If that is included, then Faber's win in 2019 in under a minute which was finished with FINISH THE FIGHT style of strikes should be included too.

      TJ hasn't spent a lot of time on top of an opponent excluding the Lineker Fight (where he didn't do much in terms of true damage) in over 5 years. Since winning the title, he spends most of the fight on his feet therefore you have to go a long way back to see him effectively using GNP.

      I get that Faber hasn't beaten top opposition in a long time. That said, I feel like there's no reason to assume that his GNP isn't strong relative to the rest of the division. I do feel like a 90 in his GNP is reasonable.
      This is more than reasonable.

      Now guys keep in mind, I'm not a developer so I don't actually put the ratings into the game myself. I can listen to your feedback and try to make the roster as accurate as possible but I cant guarantee this will all be put in ASAP. I know the usual is waiting until someone fights.

      I'm going to try to get in a decent amount added hopefully for launch but I can't promise anything.

      Comment

      • mcm12345
        Rookie
        • Aug 2017
        • 23

        #18
        Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

        Originally posted by Phillyboi207
        This is more than reasonable.

        Now guys keep in mind, I'm not a developer so I don't actually put the ratings into the game myself. I can listen to your feedback and try to make the roster as accurate as possible but I cant guarantee this will all be put in ASAP. I know the usual is waiting until someone fights.

        I'm going to try to get in a decent amount added hopefully for launch but I can't promise anything.
        Thank you so much mate it's cool to have someone around here. And one last one but this shouldn't be too much of an issue is Jon Jones' takedown defence stat. Yes he's already very highly rated and has a high defence stat of 95 but at the same time the game should be realistic as possible. Jones' takedown defence should really be up at the absolute best in the game. A 98 is reasonable imo.


        That's the same as Woodley who has a 90% irl and 1 lower than Aldo (99 in game) who's also at 90% irl. Jones is at 95% IRL. He's only been taken down twice in his whole career. Aldo has been taken down twice in his last 2 and Woodley twice in his last fight. Jones should be up there. He hasn't faced strong wrestlers in recent times but there's no reason to assume his Takedown Defence isn't up there as the best in the whole UFC. His Takedown defence stat should be higher than Cormier's takedown stat (96) seeing how Jones has stuffed all but one of DC's takedowns. In their second fight, DC went 0-3 in takedowns.

        I know you said not to compare between divisions but I feel like in Jones case, he's a candidate for best takedown defence in the entire UFC so it's valid to point out. And DC's takedown defence is a 94 yet he's been taken down 5 times at Light Heavyweight to Jones' once. I feel like the gap should be bigger than 1 point to truely showcase how elite Jones' takedown defence is.


        This will be my last request for now.

        Once again, thank you very much for being here for us. Feel free to sticky another thread once the game launches so you have more control. You're doing an awesome job man
        Last edited by mcm12345; 08-08-2020, 06:21 PM.

        Comment

        • TheSierraNevada
          Rookie
          • Jul 2020
          • 53

          #19
          Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

          This relates to the post above.

          Let’s talk about that Woodley takedown defense. 98 is ridiculous after he just got mauled by Usman. The man barely stopped anything.

          Before you say it’s because Usman is just that good at wrestling(true) I’d like to counter with the fact Woodley has not came up against really good wrestlers before this that actually wanted to wrestle.

          The only good wrestler he came up against was Koscheck but he was in love with his right hand and was not wrestling much at the point they fought.

          As for Maia he has decent takedowns but it’s nowhere the caliber of a Usman or Colby.

          I think Woodley has been a beneficiary of facing all strikers on his title fights till he got to Usman.

          That being said I think with how easy Usman made it look the man should only have a 93 takedown defense.

          When he gets wrecked by Covington maybe drop it even lower.
          Last edited by TheSierraNevada; 08-08-2020, 06:25 PM.

          Comment

          • rebel8pig
            Rookie
            • Nov 2017
            • 135

            #20
            Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

            Jack Hermansson is listed as a kickboxer, should be jiu jitsu/wrestler. Top moves lacks his killer leglocks.

            Comment

            • ragreynolds
              Rookie
              • Sep 2017
              • 264

              #21
              Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

              I haven’t looked into the ratings too much yet since I’ve only been playing career mode, but I did notice two things

              1. Ngannou’s grappling stats seemed way too high.

              2. Chael Sonnen should have better cardio than what he has. He has 91, which is decent I guess, but Chael has legend status and should be his prime self, and I don’t recall ever seeing Chael gas in a fight. He’s got fantastic cardio irl.

              On the subject of Chael, I noticed they didn’t add him to LHW. He was in MW and LHW in UFC 3. Strange that he’s not at LHW in UFC 4.

              I do think it certainly seems like some of the guys who are high in the rankings irl seem to have a few inflated stats in the areas where they’re not quite as good. It’s like how in the past they’d inflate certain stats to raise a popular fighters OVR. I feel like they’re back to doing that now with the overall star rating. I much preferred how in UFC 3 they only showed OVR ratings for each category rather than overall for the fighter.

              It would be way better if they removed the overall star rating from every fighter, and just kept it to showing the stars for striking, grappling, and health. I feel like doing that would make it less likely for guys to have inflated stats.

              Comment

              • tomitomitomi
                Pro
                • Mar 2018
                • 987

                #22
                Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

                I found the Faber discussion a bit funny since OP suggested that some of Faber's stats should be upgraded from mere 89 to at least 90.

                Props to Philly for being responsive! If I were you I'd keep a document of suggested changes that you like so you can bring them up whenever it's relevant. Also try not to take some people's whining to heart.

                I was bored so I went through way too much time to skim through the male roster so I have lots of small miscellaneous thoughts.

                I didn't check women but IIRC Jessica Andrade had a relatively low head movement rating (89?) which I think could be higher based on her last fight with Thug Rose. I won't give any suggestions for stats because I'm bad at that but instead present their current stat and hopefully give a comprehensive reasoning why I think it should be changed.

                Flyweight

                Spoiler


                BW

                Spoiler


                FW

                Spoiler


                LW
                Spoiler


                WW
                Spoiler


                MW
                Spoiler


                LHW
                Spoiler


                HW
                Spoiler
                ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

                Comment

                • Phillyboi207
                  Banned
                  • Apr 2012
                  • 3159

                  #23
                  Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

                  A couple things

                  Jon Jones has the highest TDD in the division at 95 to Cormier's 94 in game.

                  I'm not opposed to it being even higher but the biggest difference between him and Woodley/Aldo is that they've held off multiple guys trying to take them down the entire fight.

                  Be careful comparing across divisions. Everything is relative to their own division. If I say someone is a 99 at something it just means they're as good as I've seen within that division, not the entire UFC.

                  As far as Woodley's TDD goes

                  Usman went 2-6
                  Kosheck went 7-17
                  Jake Shields went 0-18
                  Demian Maia went 0-21

                  If anything I'd argue Jon hasn't had as many shut down performances like that against someone actively looking to take him down. His first fight against Cormier being the one exception with Cormier going 1-8.

                  Not disputing Jones' amazing TDD, just stating that Aldo/Woodley have put their's on display more often. I really try to reward consistency.

                  Hopefully that helps y'all understand some of the choices made with the ratings.

                  Comment

                  • mcm12345
                    Rookie
                    • Aug 2017
                    • 23

                    #24
                    Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

                    Originally posted by tomitomitomi
                    I found the Faber discussion a bit funny since OP suggested that some of Faber's stats should be upgraded from mere 89 to at least 90.

                    Props to Philly for being responsive! If I were you I'd keep a document of suggested changes that you like so you can bring them up whenever it's relevant. Also try not to take some people's whining to heart.

                    I was bored so I went through way too much time to skim through the male roster so I have lots of small miscellaneous thoughts.

                    I didn't check women but IIRC Jessica Andrade had a relatively low head movement rating (89?) which I think could be higher based on her last fight with Thug Rose. I won't give any suggestions for stats because I'm bad at that but instead present their current stat and hopefully give a comprehensive reasoning why I think it should be changed.

                    Flyweight

                    Spoiler


                    BW

                    Spoiler


                    FW

                    Spoiler


                    LW
                    Spoiler


                    WW
                    Spoiler


                    MW
                    Spoiler


                    LHW
                    Spoiler


                    HW
                    Spoiler

                    In regards to the point on Ferguson's WW power, his sole UFC Pro fight in the Welterweight division was a first round KO. Based off of the limited sample size, a 90 is reasonable enough.

                    Comment

                    • mcm12345
                      Rookie
                      • Aug 2017
                      • 23

                      #25
                      Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

                      Originally posted by Phillyboi207
                      A couple things

                      Jon Jones has the highest TDD in the division at 95 to Cormier's 94 in game.

                      I'm not opposed to it being even higher but the biggest difference between him and Woodley/Aldo is that they've held off multiple guys trying to take them down the entire fight.

                      Be careful comparing across divisions. Everything is relative to their own division. If I say someone is a 99 at something it just means they're as good as I've seen within that division, not the entire UFC.

                      As far as Woodley's TDD goes

                      Usman went 2-6
                      Kosheck went 7-17
                      Jake Shields went 0-18
                      Demian Maia went 0-21

                      If anything I'd argue Jon hasn't had as many shut down performances like that against someone actively looking to take him down. His first fight against Cormier being the one exception with Cormier going 1-8.

                      Not disputing Jones' amazing TDD, just stating that Aldo/Woodley have put their's on display more often. I really try to reward consistency.

                      Hopefully that helps y'all understand some of the choices made with the ratings.
                      That makes perfect sense. Consistency is a valid way of determining it.

                      Comment

                      • brownjesus10
                        Rookie
                        • Jul 2020
                        • 15

                        #26
                        Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

                        Originally posted by tomitomitomi
                        I found the Faber discussion a bit funny since OP suggested that some of Faber's stats should be upgraded from mere 89 to at least 90.

                        Props to Philly for being responsive! If I were you I'd keep a document of suggested changes that you like so you can bring them up whenever it's relevant. Also try not to take some people's whining to heart.

                        I was bored so I went through way too much time to skim through the male roster so I have lots of small miscellaneous thoughts.

                        I didn't check women but IIRC Jessica Andrade had a relatively low head movement rating (89?) which I think could be higher based on her last fight with Thug Rose. I won't give any suggestions for stats because I'm bad at that but instead present their current stat and hopefully give a comprehensive reasoning why I think it should be changed.

                        Flyweight

                        Spoiler


                        BW

                        Spoiler


                        FW

                        Spoiler


                        LW
                        Spoiler


                        WW
                        Spoiler


                        MW
                        Spoiler


                        LHW
                        Spoiler


                        HW
                        Spoiler
                        On the topic of Henry’s chin, he showed an iron chin and great resilience in the Marlon fight. I think that performance earned him that rating, along with the fact that he has yet to be knocked out

                        Comment

                        • tomitomitomi
                          Pro
                          • Mar 2018
                          • 987

                          #27
                          Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

                          Originally posted by mcm12345
                          In regards to the point on Ferguson's WW power, his sole UFC Pro fight in the Welterweight division was a first round KO. Based off of the limited sample size, a 90 is reasonable enough.
                          It was against Ramsey Nijem who is chinny and also moved down to LW after the tournament so in all intents and purposes it was a lightweight fight. I believe it was Alberto who also explained a lot of times in the UFC 3 thread that performances against unranked opponents increase ratings less.
                          ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

                          Comment

                          • Phillyboi207
                            Banned
                            • Apr 2012
                            • 3159

                            #28
                            Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

                            Originally posted by ragreynolds
                            I haven’t looked into the ratings too much yet since I’ve only been playing career mode, but I did notice two things

                            1. Ngannou’s grappling stats seemed way too high.

                            2. Chael Sonnen should have better cardio than what he has. He has 91, which is decent I guess, but Chael has legend status and should be his prime self, and I don’t recall ever seeing Chael gas in a fight. He’s got fantastic cardio irl.

                            On the subject of Chael, I noticed they didn’t add him to LHW. He was in MW and LHW in UFC 3. Strange that he’s not at LHW in UFC 4.

                            I do think it certainly seems like some of the guys who are high in the rankings irl seem to have a few inflated stats in the areas where they’re not quite as good. It’s like how in the past they’d inflate certain stats to raise a popular fighters OVR. I feel like they’re back to doing that now with the overall star rating. I much preferred how in UFC 3 they only showed OVR ratings for each category rather than overall for the fighter.

                            It would be way better if they removed the overall star rating from every fighter, and just kept it to showing the stars for striking, grappling, and health. I feel like doing that would make it less likely for guys to have inflated stats.
                            Who do you think has inflated stats? I went out of my way to avoid artificially inflating stats. If someone has high stats it should be tied to their performance (except Punk lol)

                            Tomitomitomi:

                            Thank you! That is a lot and I won't be able to go through all of it at the moment. Keep in mind the roster isn't completely up to date yet. The past 3-4 events arent included so some of the stuff you asked for will likely be in for launch.

                            Some of the multiple weight class stuff is tough because it's mostly speculation. Hard to know exactly how a guy will perform in a different weight class unless they were there recently.

                            The Vitor kick speed thing is just about Vitor being faster relative to LHWs compared to MWs. Not necessarily that he's a better kicker at LHW. Hopefully that makes sense.

                            As far as really high durability, it's based on guys that have spent a lot of time in the cage with great fighters and barely if ever got hurt. It does have to do with intelligent defense but the fact that they're able to come away clean in a lot of those exchanges is also a testament to their durability.

                            Just to clarify as well. I don't ONLY go by stats. Actual fight film comes first, stats can just provide a basis for an argument especially if supported by film.

                            Edit: Please forgive typos and grammar. I’m often on mobile and multitasking. Not usually double checking what I type
                            Last edited by Phillyboi207; 08-08-2020, 07:51 PM.

                            Comment

                            • mcm12345
                              Rookie
                              • Aug 2017
                              • 23

                              #29
                              Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

                              Gilbert Burns' stand up stats are a little lacking. One area where I think he definitely needs a buff is his punch speed. It's an 89 right now and I think at the very least it should be a 90. In his last fight, he dominated Woodley. In the first exchange of the fight, he floored Woodley with his quick hands.

                              Given that Burns was able trade hands with and keep up with the speed of someone in the 90s with their punch speed, I definitely feel that his punch speed should be on the better side of the weightclass. At least a 90 is deserved given that he outstruck and landed a knockdown in the first exchange of the fight with one of the best in the division.

                              Comment

                              • rebel8pig
                                Rookie
                                • Nov 2017
                                • 135

                                #30
                                Re: UFC EA 4 Fighter Stats Adjustment Thread

                                Please make Machida legendary. If not then his head movement is way too low.

                                Comment

                                Working...