
Sultan Riaz – First Base – Mecca Marksmen – 70.9% Third Ballot
Sultan Riaz was a 6’2’’, 205 pound left-handed hitting first baseman from Sanaa, the capital of Yemen. Riaz was a great contact hitter with reliably strong home run and gap power. His 162 game average got you 34 homers, 32 doubles, and 13 triples. Riaz was a bit below average at drawing walks and avoiding strikeouts. He was notably much better facing right-handed pitching (1.014 OPS, 172 wRC+) compared to lefties (.708 OPS, 95 wRC+).
Despite his power profile, Riaz had excellent speed and baserunning ability. He was far more nimble than you’d expect from a career first baseman. Riaz was very good defensively as well, winning five Gold Gloves. He did see sporadic starts in left and right field, struggling in both spots. Riaz had good durability and was a team captain. Few in the game were considered better people with Riaz showing excellent leadership, loyalty, and work ethic.
Riaz was one of the first big baseball superstars to come out of Yemen. The country had a limited infrastructure and wouldn’t get a pro team until Sanaa joined in a 2024 expansion. Still, Riaz’s talent got noticed in neighboring Saudi Arabia. Mecca signed him in September 1995 to a developmental deal as a teenager. He spent most of five years in the academy, officially debuting in 2000 at age 21 with 15 games and 5 starts. Riaz became a full-time starter the next year and earned 2001 Rookie of the Year honors.
From 2002-07, Riaz posted 5.9 WAR or better each year for Mecca. He won four Gold Gloves from 2004-07 and Silver Sluggers in 2004, 2006, and 2007. Riaz was second in MVP voting in both 2004 and 2007, but never won the top honor. However, 2006 was his best effort by many metrics with a batting title (.369) and conference-best 230 hits. Those were career highs, as was Riaz’s 1.101 OPS, 199 wRC+, and 10.1 WAR. Riaz’s most powerful season with 2007 with career bests in homers (53), RBI (130), and runs (124).
Despite his efforts, Mecca was stuck in mediocrity, averaging 76.25 wins per season with no playoff berths in Riaz’s tenure. He was going to be eligible for free agency after the 2008 season. With one year left under team control, the Marksmen felt they weren’t going to be able to afford to keep him around. Thus, Riaz was traded to Beirut for two prospects.
With Mecca, Riaz had 1408 hits, 741 runs, 259 doubles, 292 home runs, 796 RBI, 514 stolen bases, a .329/.369/.630 slash, 169 wRC+, and 49.9 WAR. He was a beloved superstar in the Holy City and saw his #11 uniform as the first retired by the franchise. Riaz was also a star back home in Yemen, representing his county from 2002-2015 in the World Baseball Championship. In 97 WBC games, Riaz had 75 hits, 41 runs, 11 doubles, 5 triples, 15 home runs, 34 RBI, a .221/.286/.416 slash, 101 wRC+, and 0.9 WAR.
His one year in Beirut was plagued by a fractured finger and oblique strain, although he still got 3.6 WAR over 97 games. The Bluebirds fell just short of the playoffs and Riaz became a free agent heading towards age 30. This ended his run in the still relatively new Arab League, as he received worldwide interest. Riaz made the big move to Australia, getting a seven-year, $42,700,000 deal with Adelaide of the Oceania Baseball Association.
Riaz had an impressive debut for the Aardvarks, leading the Australasia League in 2009 in batting average (.355), stolen bases (61), and OPS (1.037). He won a Silver Slugger and took third in MVP voting. Riaz couldn’t match that in his later years with Adelaide, although he was still a nice starter. His power numbers dropped, as he didn’t hit 30+ homers apart from the debut season. Riaz did notably earn a Gold Glove in 2013.
Adelaide was below average during his tenure, leaving Riaz without a playoff appearance for his whole career. In 2014, he lost half of the season to a fractured ankle. Riaz was reduced to a platoon role in 2015 with only 0.9 WAR for the season. In total with Adelaide, he had 1057 hits, 507 runs, 159 doubles, 85 triples, 148 home runs, 520 RBI, 312 stolen bases, a .302/.342/.522 slash, 134 wRC+, and 20.8 WAR. Riaz was unsigned in 2016 and retired that winter at age 37.
For his combined pro career, Riaz had 2580 hits, 1308 runs, 436 doubles, 170 triples, 465 home runs, 1379 RBI, 510 walks, 861 stolen bases, a .316/.356/.582 slash, 153 wRC+, and 74.2 WAR. However, his Arab League Hall of Fame candidacy was based on only seven and a half seasons worth of play with Mecca and Beirut. In ALB, Riaz had 1523 hits, 801 runs, 277 doubles, 85 triples, 317 home runs, 859 RBI, 549 stolen bases, a .326/.367/.626 slash, 168 wRC+, and 53.4 WAR.
The small sample size keeps him out of the top 100 in basically every counting stat, although he is 77th in WAR among position players as of 2037. Notably, his .993 OPS ranks 25th among all batters with 3000+ plate appearances, even against the inflated offense guys of the 2020s and 2030s. Riaz also ranks 33rd in batting average, 51st in on-base percentage, and 24th in slugging. Still, there would be voters who dinged him for low totals and for being on forgettable Mecca teams.
However, Riaz was incredibly effective in his brief run. He was one of the most well respected and well liked guys in the game. Plus, he and Hall of Fame classmate Ali Al-Shakal both played a huge role in growing the game in Yemen and bringing an expansion team to Sanaa. Riaz just missed the cut in his first two ballots at 59.2% and 61.3%. On his third try in 2019, he got to 70.9% to secure his spot into ALB’s HOF.

Ali Al-Shakal – Starting Pitcher – Doha Dash – 70.5% Seventh Ballot
Ali Al-Shakal was a 6’3’’, 200 pound right-handed pitcher from Sanaa, the capital of Yemen. Al-Shakal was a well-rounded pitcher with good to great stuff, movement, and control. His 95-97 mph sinker was his strongest pitch, but his forkball, changeup, and splitter were each viable options. Early in his career, Al-Shakal also had excellent stamina and durability. He struggled holding runners, but was otherwise a good defender. Al-Shakal was adaptable to his situation and considered a team leader.
Al-Shakal thrived in his amateur career, becoming arguably the top prospect for the 1996 ALB Draft. He was picked second overall by Doha and was a full-time starter right away. Al-Shakal tossed 240+ innings in each of his first nine seasons for the Dash, including a 6.1 WAR rookie season that got him second in Rookie of the Year voting. This helped Doha pull off one of the all-time great turnarounds in pro baseball history.
The Dash was abysmal in their first seven seasons and never won more than 65 games. They went 58-104 the year they picked Al-Shakal, but saw an amazing turnaround in 1997 at 95-67, winning their first Gulf Division title. Doha upset Mosul in the Eastern Conference Championship and beat Khartoum for the Arab League title. In 21.2 playoff innings, Al-Shakal had a 2.91 ERA and 21 strikeouts.
Al-Shakal won Pitcher of the Year in his second season, leading the conference in wins (20-13), WHIP (0.90), complete games (14), and shutouts (6). These were career bests, as was his 2.40 ERA and 158 ERA+. Doha got back to the conference final, but fell in a rematch with Mosul. Al-Shakal had a 1.76 ERA over his two starts, striking out 14 in 15.1 innings. The Dash would be mid-tier the next few years, then fell back into mediocrity, not making the playoffs again until 2018.
You couldn’t blame Al-Shakal for that though. He had a career and conference-best 9.3 WAR in 1999, but surprisingly wasn’t a POTY finalist. Al-Shakal finished second in 2001 with 9.1 WAR and a career-best 328 strikeouts. After the 2002 season, he signed a five-year, $7,620,000 contract. Al-Shakal kept rolling, but did see his first setback as a torn meniscus cost him the front end of the 2006 season. That was his final year in Qatar, as he declined the contract option and entered free agency heading towards age 33.
That also ended his time in the Arab League, as his next stop was in Nigeria. Al-Shakal signed a five-year, $16,040,000 with Port Harcourt of West Africa Baseball. The Hillcats were mostly below average in his run, as was he. Al-Shakal did lead in innings in 2009, but otherwise was an average innings eater there. He had a 48-41 record over 922.1 innings, 4.00 ERA, 924 strikeouts, 102 ERA+, and 14.1 WAR.
Like his Hall of Fame classmate Sultan Riaz, Al-Shakal did return home to Yemen for the World Baseball Championship. From 2002-11, he had a 6-9 record, 4.49 ERA, 118.1 innings, 118 strikeouts, 57 walks, 81 ERA+, and 1.0 WAR. Al-Shakal was unsigned in 2012 and retired that winter at age 38. Doha did bring him back to retire his #17 uniform. As of 2037, he’s the only player from the Dash with his number retired and the only Hall of Famer in their purple and orange.
For his combined career, Al-Shakal had a 200-166 record, 3.35 ERA, 3418 innings, 3634 strikeouts, 748 walks, 281/454 quality starts, 112 complete games, 24 shutouts, 116 ERA+, and 75.2 WAR. His ALB accumulations were hurt by leaving for WAB for his final five seasons. With Doha, Al-Shakal had a 152-125 record, 3.11 ERA, 2495.2 innings, 2710 strikeouts, 496 walks, 99 complete games, 21 shutouts, 122 ERA+, and 61.1 WAR.
As of 2037, Al-Shakal ranks 41st in wins, 41st in strikeouts, 26th in WAR among pitchers, 39th in innings, third in complete games, and eighth in shutouts. Among all pitchers with 1000+ innings, Al-Shakal’s ERA is 43rd, his 1.05 WHIP is 39th, and his opponent’s OPS of .637 ranks 31st. However, many voters thought he didn’t have enough longevity or raw dominance to deserve the nod. Supporters noted his POTY win and key role in Doha’s incredible turnaround title run in 1997.
Al-Shakal debuted at only 42.6% in 2013 and fell to 34.3% the next year, making it look like he might be doomed to the Hall of Pretty Good. However, his next four ballots were all above 50%, peaking at 57.5% in 2018. Al-Shakal got another look in 2019 and made it across the 66% requirement at 70.5%. With that, he earned a seventh ballot induction and along with Riaz, became the first Yemenis into the Arab League Hall of Fame.
Comment