
Abdullah Al-Tamtami – Starting Pitcher – Casablanca Bruins – 99.1% First Ballot
Abdullah Al-Tamtami was a 6’2’’, 205 pound right-handed pitcher from Muscat, the capital of Oman. Al-Tamtami was a hard thrower with excellent stuff, but he also had terrific control and good movement. His strongest offering was a 98-100 mph cutter, but he also had a rock solid slider and curveball in the arsenal along with a rarely used changeup. Al-Tamtami was also great at holding runners and a respectable defender.
The heat of the Arab League meant pitchers don’t go the distance nearly as often as in other leagues. Al-Tamtami though had great stamina and had more innings annually than most. He had pretty good durability in his 20s, but did run into issues in his early 30s. Al-Tamtami was a scrappy sparkplug type, known for his adaptability, work ethic, and intelligence.
Al-Tamtami was also one of the best pure athletes to be a full-time pitcher. He had incredible baserunning speed and stealing instincts, although his Casablanca coaches were adamently against any two-way use. With ALB having a universal DH, Al-Tamtami didn’t get a chance to flash his bat from the pitcher slot either. Dubai gave him a smattering of plate appearances late in his career with decent results. Some scouts still think that Al-Tamtami could’ve been a solid starting infielder in a two-way role had he gotten the chance in his prime.
His overall package of skills drew Casablanca’s attention for a developmental deal signed in February 1998. They had him focus on pitching and debuted Al-Tamtami in 2001 with four relief appearances at age 20. He also had one relief appearance in the playoffs as the Bruins won the Western Conference title, but lost the ALB Championship to Mosul. Al-Tamtami was split between full time relief and starting in 2002 with okay results. He got the go-ahead to be a full-time starter in 2003.
In his first full season, Al-Tamtami won Pitcher of the Year honors with 6.5 WAR, a 21-11 record, 2.92 ERA, and 268 strikeouts. He had a stellar postseason for the 108-54 Bruins with a 1.66 ERA and 29 strikeouts over 21.2 innings, helping Casablanca win the ALB title against Dubai. Forearm inflammation kept him out a chunk of 2004 and the Bruins surprisingly fell to 78-84, only their second losing season in franchise history to that point.
2005 was a banner year with Al-Tamtami’s second Pitcher of the Year win, leading the conference in strikeouts (364), K/BB (12.6), complete games (9), shutouts (4), and WAR (10.6). He tossed ALB’s third-ever perfect game on July 12, striking out 15 against Alexandria. Casablanca won another conference title, but dropped the ALB finale to Medina. Al-Tamtami again had a good playoff showing with a 2.37 ERA and 41 strikeouts over 30.1 innings.
Casablanca knew they had their ace, giving Al-Tamtami a seven-year, $12,180,000 extension in May 2005. He would go onto lead the conference four more times in WAR and strikeouts, twice more in WHIP and quality starts, and twice in both wins and ERA. He had seven total seasons worth 7+ WAR. Al-Tamtami was third in 2006’s Pitcher of the Year voting and second in 2007. The Bruins missed the 2006 playoffs, then had a conference finals loss in 2007.
2008 was Al-Tamtami’s third Pitcher of the Year win and saw his most dominant postseason run. He went 3-0 over 24.2 innings with a 0.73 ERA with 35 strikeouts and 1 walk. Casablanca won another conference title, but couldn’t beat 109-win Basra in the ALB final. Salaries had started to go up in the growing league and Al-Tamtami opted out of his extension with the goal of signing a new bigger one. Casablanca acquiesced with a seven-year, $24,640,000 extension.
With Pitcher of the Year wins in 2009 and 2010, Al-Tamtami pulled off the three-peat and joined Rashid Tariq as the only five-time winners to that point. He won back-to-back ERA titles and posted his finest season in 2012 with career bests in wins (22-5), ERA (2.02), strikeouts (367), WHIP (0.83), and WAR (11.6). Amman’s Tarek Samy denied his Triple Crown bid by only four strikeouts.
Casablanca had three more division titles from 2009-11, but lost in the conference final each year. They fell to a fledgling Aviators dynasty in 2009-10, then had a stunning upset to 81-81 Alexandria in 2011. Al-Tamtami was a bit shakier in these playoff starts, but still finished his career with excellent playoff numbers. In 122 innings, he had an 8-3 record, 2.58 ERA, 166 strikeouts, 21 walks, 145 ERA+, and 3.6 WAR. As of 2037, he is 8th in playoff WAR and 3rd in strikeouts.
Al-Tamtami was third in 2011’s Pitcher of the Year voting. He wasn’t a finalist in 2012 but he again had 7+ WAR and 300+ strikeouts. However, Casablanca fell below .500 and seemed to be possibly entering a rebuild. Al-Tamtami decided to opt out of his remaining contract, becoming a free agent for the first time heading into his age 32 season.
For Casablanca, Al-Tamtami had a 176-92 record, 2.68 ERA, 2539.2 innings, 3309 strikeouts, 407 walks, 56 complete games, 23 shutouts, 140 ERA+, and 83.9 WAR. His dominance made him one of the franchise’s most popular figures and got his #3 uniform eventually retired. It was hard though to turn down the six-year, $81,400,000 deal Al-Tamtami got from Dubai, which more than tripled his best year’s salary with the Bruins.
He didn’t live up to the price tag, although a chunk of that wasn’t his fault. On June 1, 2013, Al-Tamtami suffered a torn rotator cuff that put him out an entire calendar year. He was still effective when he returned in summer 2014, but the injury greatly damaged his movement and he started to have trouble allowing home runs. Al-Tamtami still posted a solid 5.4 WAR season in 2015, but his ERA was above three for the first time in a full season starting.
Despite his efforts, Dubai remained stuck in the middle tier as well. In 2016, Al-Tamtami was awful with a 5.79 ERA and conference-worst 37 homers allowed. The year did at least allow him to pass Rashid Tariq’s 4008 to become ALB’s career strikeouts leader. Al-Tamtami retired the winter at age 35 with his final Diamonds numbers seeing a 37-31 record, 3.89 ERA, 634.1 innings, 726 strikeouts, 103 ERA+, and 12.4 WAR.
Al-Tamtami ended at a 213-123 record, 2.92 ERA, 3174 innings, 4035 strikeouts, 508 walks, 307/429 quality starts, 72 complete games, 26 shutouts, 131 ERA+, and 96.3 WAR. He held the strikeout king crown for 11 years and still ranks 5th as of 2037. Al-Tamtami also ranks 12th in wins, 12th in innings, and 6th in pitching WAR.
Among all pitchers with 1000+ innings, Al-Tamtami is 24th in ERA and his 0.99 WHIP is 11th. His .632 opponent’s OPS ranks 25th, his 1.44 BB/9 is 42nd, his 7.45 H/9 is 33rd, and his 11.44 K/9 is 27th. Al-Tamtami’s opponent slash line was .223/.258/.374, which ranks 32nd/7th/54th.
Without the rotator cuff injury and quick decline, Al-Tamtami probably gets more consideration for ALB’s GOAT pitcher. He still makes most scholar’s top ten lists and cracks the top five for some. Few guys were strong enough to co-headline a Hall of Fame class with a legend like Mohammed Mohamed, but Al-Tamtami fit the bill. He and Mohamed both had 99.1% atop an impressive three-player Arab League Baseball 2022 class.

Ivan “Cushion” Smirnov – Second/First Base/Designated Hitter – Baghdad Brown Bears – 75.7% First Ballot
Ivan Smirnov was a 5’11’’, 185 pound right-handed infielder from Tel Aviv-Yafo, Israel’s most populous city. The nickname “Cushion” came from his ample posterior. Smirnov was an excellent contact hitter with solid home run and gap power. He had a decent eye for drawing walks, but was overall subpar at avoiding strikeouts. Smirnov wasn’t one to be a league leader, but he got you 32 home runs, 29 doubles, and 8 triples per his 162 game average. He did also have tremendous baserunning chops and very good speed, a definite threat anytime he was on base.
That baserunning speed didn’t translate to defensive range unfortunately. Smirnov made around 2/5 of his starts at second base and was a putrid defender. He spent four seasons in his early 30s at first base and was serviceable there. Around 1/3 of Smirnov’s career starts came as a designated hitter. His durability was great, playing 145+ games in 16 different seasons. Smirnov was also a team captain, garnering great respect for his leadership, work ethic, loyalty, and intelligence. This helped him achieve significant popularity in a career that spanned three continents.
Smirnov was noticed by a scout from Baghdad who brought him to Iraq on a developmental deal in March 1999. He spent three years in their academy, then debuted at age 19 in 2002 with 55 games and 19 starts. Smirnov was a full-time starter the next year and held a spot in the lineup for the next eight years. He was good in his first two full seasons, but became elite by his third year.
From 2005-09, Smirnov had five consecutive seasons worth 8+ WAR. He also scored 100+ runs with 200+ hits and 30+ homers each year of that run and four times had an OPS above one. Smirnov won Silver Sluggers each year with the first two as a DH and the next three at second base. He was third in 2005 and 2007’s MVP voting and took second in 2006. It was tough to get noticed though as Baghdad was terrible during this time despite his efforts. The Brown Bears never had a winning season during Smirnov’s tenure, averaging 70.67 wins per season.
Smirnov wasn’t a conference leader apart from his 2007 season, which saw a batting title at .360 along with the best WAR (10.0) and wRC+ (194). The average and WAR were single-season bests for Smirnov along with his 219 hits and 130 RBI. In 2006, he had his career best for home runs (54), OPS (1.081), and wRC+ (197). Smirnov’s best runs mark was 121 in 2009 while 2005 saw his high marks in doubles (45) and stolen bases (102). 2003 saw only the sixth six-hit game in ALB history to that point against Abu Dhabi.
With Baghdad’s struggles, they weren’t going to be able to match the free market offers for Smirnov. He left for free agency after the 2010 season at only age 28, which ended his Arab League run. For the Brown Bears, Smirnov had 1597 hits, 894 runs, 284 doubles, 56 triples, 327 home runs, 859 RBI, 654 stolen bases, a .324/.369/.604 slash, 165 wRC+, and 59.2 WAR. He was remembered fondly in the Iraqi capital as a great player in a lousy era, getting his #14 uniform eventually retired.
It made for a tricky Hall of Fame candidacy as Smirnov’s short run meant low accumulations. As of 2037, he’s outside the top 100 in counting stats apart from being 62nd in stolen bases and 63rd in WAR for position players. Smirnov’s rate stats though are strong as his .974 OPS is 32nd amongst ALB batters with 3000+ plate appearances. His triple slash ranks 39th/46th/38th.
Smirnov would play another decade of solid baseball elsewhere with many voters giving him at least partial credit for non-ALB stats. Supporters figured he’d have been prominently ranked on the leaderboards had he stayed. Plus, he was a well-respected and well-liked captain, which goes a long way. Even with the lower ALB specific totals, Smirnov received 75.7% in his ballot debut to cap off an impressive three-player 2022 Hall of Fame class for the Arab League.
Most of the time, international free agents didn’t come onto the market until their 30s. With Smirnov only at age 28, many MLB teams had strong interest. He ended up moving to Kentucky on a seven-year, $112 million deal with Louisville, becoming one of baseball’s highest paid players. Smirnov’s debut season was excellent with a Silver Slugger at second base, posting 7.7 WAR, 37 homers, and a .900 OPS.
Smirnov didn’t reach those highs again, but he was a reliably strong hitter over the life of the deal. Yet again, he’d be cursed by being on bad teams. The Lynx were around .500 when he arrived, but had fallen to the bottom by the time he was done. Sadly for Smirnov, he never played a single playoff game in his career. He only made a few World Baseball Championship appearances either for his native Israel in his final years, ending up as one of the better players to lack big game opportunities.
With Louisville, Smirnov had 1231 hits, 599 runs, 166 doubles, 47 triples, 182 homers, 595 RBI, 295 steals, a .294/.333/.487 slash, 150 wRC+, and 35.9 WAR. He was a free agent again in 2018 at age 35, but MLB teams at this point were searching for younger and cheaper talent. Smirnov would find his next him in Australia on a three-year, $25,200,000 deal with Melbourne of the Oceania Baseball Association.
Smirnov would fall off significantly with the Mets, leading the Australasia League in strikeouts in both 2018 and 2019. This was Melbourne’s rebuild following their early 2000s dynasty run. Smirnov was benched eventually in 2020 after struggling, finishing his three Mets years with 419 hits, 205 runs, 65 doubles, 61 home runs, 173 RBI, 133 steals, a .248/.281/.435 slash and 0.9 WAR. After going unsigned in 2021, Smirnov retired at age 39.
For his combined pro career, Smirnov had 3247 hits, 1698 runs, 515 doubles, 137 triples, 570 home runs, 1627 RBI, 673 walks, 1082 stolen bases, a .301/.342/.532 slash, 148 wRC+, and 96.1 WAR. Certainly getting to 3000+ hits, 1500+ runs, 500+ doubles, 500+ homers, 1500+ RBI, 1000+ steals, and holding a .301 batting average shows Smirnov was a Hall of Fame level talent. He was in ALB just long enough and strong enough to get the HOF nod there despite only playing nine seasons with bad Baghdad teams. Smirnov also was arguably the best-ever Israeli born pro, posting the most career WAR from the nation.
Comment