
Right fielder Vicente Cristan was the lone addition into the Beisbol Sudamerica Hall of Fame for 2029, earning first ballot honors with 78.6%. The next closest to the 66% threshold was 2B Franklin Chapman debuting at 59.2%. Three returners were above 50% with CL Samuel Andrade at 57.5% for his second ballot, 3B Pedro Gutierrez with 55.8% on his third try, and SP Rodrigo Quiroz at 55.4% on his second go. No players were removed from the ballot after ten failed attempts.

Vicente “Cubby” Cristan – Right Field – Montevideo Venom – 78.6% First Ballot
Vicente Cristan was a 6’1’’, 200 pound left-handed right fielder from Asuncion, the capital of Paraguay. Nicknamed “Cubby,” Cristan was an excellent contact hitter with a very good pop in his bat. While never a league leader, he got plenty of extra bases with a 162 game average of 31 doubles, 9 triples, and 34 home runs. Cristan had four seasons with 40+ homers and once topped 50. He was respectable at avoiding strikeouts, but was average at best drawing walks.
Cristan was good against both sides, but was more dangerous facing right-handed pitching (1.003 OPS, 172 wRC+) compared to lefties (.839 OPS, 134 wRC+). While caught stealing more than he succeeded, Cristan overall had above average to good speed and baserunning skills. However, that speed didn’t translate to range in the outfield.
He played left field in his first full season, then switched to right field for the remainder of his Beisbol Sudamerica run. Cristan had a strong arm, but his glove work and instincts were terrible and he graded quite poorly. His final seasons saw a move to designated hitter. Cristan’s durability was mostly good for a 19-year career. He had a strong ethic and stayed loyal to Montevideo, making him a true fan favorite.
Cristan was picked young by the Venom with the sixth pick of the 2006 BSA Draft. He did officially debut in 2007 at age 19 with one game, but he spent his early years in their academy. Cristan played 51 games and started two in his first three seasons in Uruguay. He saw 117 games in 2010 and 107 in 2011, but only started 42 between them. Cristan looked solid though in the small sample size and earned the full-time gig for 2012. His earlier games meant this didn’t count as a rookie season.
However, Cristan had one of the all-time great full-time debuts, winning 2012 MVP and a Silver Slugger in LF. He became only the third in BSA history to that point to bat above .400 and was the fourth to get 250+ hits. Cristan led the Southern Cone League with a .404/.435/.755 triple slash, 1.190 OPS, 239 wRC+, 252 hits, 143 RBI, and 471 total bases. Those would all be career highs, as would his 118 runs, 13 triples, 53 home runs, and 9.8 WAR. Cristan also hit for the cycle against his hometown Asuncion in June.
Cristan never had a season that incredible again, but remained quite strong, posting seven more seasons with 5+ WAR and seven more with an OPS above one for Montevideo. Cristan also scored 100+ runs with 40+ homers in both 2014 and 2015, while smacking 49 dingers in 2020. He won additional Silver Sluggers in 2017, 2018, and 2020 with the Venom, who gave Cristan an eight-year, $74,700,000 extension in June 2015.
Montevideo had been a historically mediocre franchise, although with Cristan they were generally competitive. The Venom averaged 84.6 wins per season when he was a full-time starter, but weren’t often in the playoff hunt. Montevideo did have a first round exit in 2014, followed by a franchise record 104-58 in 2015. That got them the top seed, but they were ousted in the LCS by Recife. Montevideo’s only other playoff trip with Cristan was a first round exit in 2021. In 15 playoff starts, he had a .236/.276/.582 slash, 127 wRC+, and 0.3 WAR.
While he became a favorite in Uruguay, Cristan did return home regularly to represent Paraguay in the World Baseball Championship. From 2010-27, he played 136 games and started 120 with 131 hits, 66 runs, 30 doubles, 10 triples, 23 homers, 62 RBI, 30 steals, .274/.327/.523 slash, 145 wRC+, and 4.4 WAR. In 2025, Paraguay notably earned its second-ever division title.
Cristan remained steady into his early 30s, but his value started to wane in his later years. His batting average was still good, but now regularly below .300. Combined with Cristan’s worsening defense and he only was worth a combined 4.2 WAR in his final three years. Montevideo was appreciative of their long-time star, but opted not to sign him after his deal expired with the 2023 season. Thus, Cristan was now a free agent for the first time at age 36. The Venom did honor him a few years later by retiring his #21 uniform.
South American teams generally thought Cristan was cooked and he had to expand his search worldwide. He found an unlikely home in Turkey with a three-year, $13,600,000 with Bursa of the Asian Baseball Federation. The Blue Claws moved him to DH, where he found a bit of a second life. In 2025, Cristan led the league with 133 RBI, earning a Silver Slugger and a third place in MVP voting. Bursa had the West League’s top seed in 2024 at 105-57, but fell in the WLCS to Baku. The Blue Claws had a first round exit in 2025 and missed the playoffs in 2026.
With Bursa, Cristan had 391 games, 495 hits, 259 runs, 106 doubles, 24 triples, 77 home runs, 306 RBI, .334/.371/.593 slash, 155 wRC+, and 12.9 WAR. He stayed in ABF and moved to Iran on a three-year, $37,700,000 deal with Tehran. Cristan struggled hard though in 2027 for the Tarpons with -0.9 WAR and .680 OPS over 135 games. Tehran did win the pennant and lost the ABF Championship facing Hyderabad. Cristan in 9 playoff games was terrible with .259 OPS and -0.4 WAR. He retired from the game that winter at age 40.
For his combined pro career, Cristan had 2589 games, 2990 hits, 1506 runs, 491 doubles, 145 triples, 539 home runs, 1653 RBI, 539 walks, 533 steals, .331/.369/.597 slash, 164 wRC+, and 73.2 WAR. Just in BSA with Montevideo, Cristan had 2063 games, 2381 hits, 1188 runs, 351 doubles, 120 triples, 448 home runs, 1291 RBI, 424 walks, 942 strikeouts, 443 steals, .337/.375/.611 slash, 171 wRC+, and 61.1 WAR.
As of 2037, Cristan ranks 46th in batting average among those with 3000+ plate appearances. He also is 63rd in on-base percentage and 27th in slugging. Cristan’s OPS of .985 places him 24th among qualifiers, a very impressive mark. However, Cristan is outside of the top 100 in all of the counting stats, which hurt him with some voters. Apart from his incredible MVP season, Cristan also wasn’t ever a BSA league leader.
That said, he had an MVP win, four Silver Sluggers, and a .400 hitting season. The metrics showed Cristan was an elite hitter, although poor defense tanked his WAR tally. Most voters also appreciated his loyalty to Montevideo, where he was the face of the franchise for 15 years. Beisbol Sudamerica’s 2029 Hall of Fame ballot was a quiet one as well without many other impactful debuts, helping Cristan’s resume to stand out. He received 78.6% for the first ballot nod as the lone 2029 addition.
Comment