
Killian Fruechte – Left Field/Designated Hitter – Omaha Hawks – 98.4% First Ballot
Killian Fruechte was a 6’6’’, 200 pound left-handed left fielder from Rowland Heights, California; a city of 48,000 people in Los Angeles County. At his peak, many scouts graded Fruechte as a perfect 10/10 for contact, power and eye. He was absolutely obscene facing right-handed pitching with a career 1.084 OPS and 213wRC+. Facing lefties, Fruechte still had a quite good .781 OPS and 132 wRC+. Few players ever in any world league could mash righties quite like Fruechte.
Fruechte’s power was heavily concentrated on homers with 48 per his 162 game average compared to only 16 doubles and 5 triples. He only had 20+ doubles in three seasons, but had 40+ homers 10 times and 50+ dingers thrice. Unlike many power hitters, Fruechte was excellent at avoiding strikeouts with a career 7.2% K rate. He’s one of only five Hall of Famers in baseball history to have 700+ career homers with fewer than 1000 career strikeouts.
Despite Fruechte’s long frame, he was very quick on the basepaths, although his baserunning instincts were subpar. In the front end of his career, Fruechte played left field and was a below average but serviceable defender. He was primarily a designated hitter and occasional outfielder once he moved to the American Association. Fruechte had about 2/3 of his career starts in left. His durability was decent over a 19-year career, but he did miss games here and there to smaller injuries.
Certainly with that impressive bat, Fruechte quickly became one of baseball’s biggest superstars. However, he wasn’t a five-star prospect in his early days. Fruechte played collegiately at East Carolina and was very underwhelming. As a three-year starter, he had 144 games, 119 hits, 63 runs, 12 doubles, 5 triples, 15 home runs, 63 RBI, .228/.300/.357 slash, 105 wRC+, and 2.8 WAR. At that point, most scouts pegged Fruechte as a fringe major leaguer.
In the 2004 MLB Draft, Fruechte was a fifth round selection by Omaha, 245th overall. Only three players in MLB history were drafted later and made MLB’s HOF. In minor league Lincoln, Fruechte had a decent showing as a part-time starter in 2005. He made his Hawks debut in 2006 with 77 games, .827 OPS, and 1.5 WAR.
That winter, he got eye surgery to improve his vision. That along with focused training and an improved diet and workout routine, Fruechte seemingly transformed overnight into a stud. He went from a guy scouts rated a two-star prospect out of college to a five-star talent. Fruechte was a full-time starter in 2007 and won his first Silver Slugger with his first of eight straight seasons worth 8+ WAR. 2008 would start a ten-year streak of seasons with an OPS above one.
In 2009, Fruechte won his first MVP and second Slugger, leading the National Association in hits (213), runs (125), home runs (53), total bases (400), triple slash (.356/.430/.668), OPS (1.098), wRC+ (226), and WAR (10.7). This year had his career best in average and hits. Fruechte won another Slugger in 2010 and was third in MVP voting, leading again in OBP. That winter, Omaha signed him to an eight-year, $121,400,000 contract extension. He seemed like the hope for the Hawks to end a playoff drought dating back to 1986.
Fruechte won another Slugger and was third again in 2011’s MVP voting. Then in 2012, he won his second MVP and a Slugger with one of the all-time great seasons. Fruechte became the new single-season home run king in MLB with 67, a mark that wouldn’t be passed until 2028. He also had only the seventh-ever Triple Crown season by an MLB batter.
He had league bests in runs (133), homers (67), RBI (138), total bases (426), triple slash (.340/.432/.747), OPS (1.179), wRC+ (268), and WAR (13.0). The WAR mark set a MLB record and Fruechte remains the only MLB player as of 2037 to have 13+ WAR in a season. The effort was the third-best qualifying OPS in MLB at the time and ranks seventhas of 2037. Still, Omaha was a mere 82-80 for the season.
Fruechte was second in 2013’s MVP voting and won his sixth Slugger, leading again in OBP, slugging, OPS, wRC+, and WAR. The tallies were slightly lower having missed a month to back spasms in the spring. Omaha finally broke through this year for a division title at 94-68. The Hawks made the NACS, but was defeated by Philadelphia. Fruechte held up his end in his only playoff trip with Omaha, posting 0.9 WAR and 1.070 OPS over 13 starts.
Although he rarely got the chance to play the big games in MLB, Fruechte delivered plenty in the World Baseball Championship for the United States. He won MVP in 2010 with 32 hits, 23 runs, 11 homers, 29 RBI, and 2.1 WAR over 23 starts. Fruechte was second in MVP voting in 2017 and was part of world title winning American teams in 2007, 08, 10, 11, 14, 17, and 20.
In 226 WBC games, Fruechte had 219 hits, 171 runs, 29 doubles, 6 triples, 65 home runs, 153 RBI, 149 walks, 92 steals, .289/.409/.600 slash, 186 wRC+, and 11.9 WAR. As of 2037, Fruechte ranks 13th in runs, 18th in hits, 36th in homers, 19th in RBI, 8th in walks, and 15th in WAR among position players. Fruechte’s efforts here helped make him a beloved American baseball superstar despite rarely seeing the national stage with Omaha or beyond.
After their 2013 NACS defeat, Omaha fell one game short of the wild card in 2014 at 91-71. Fruechte again won a Slugger and was second in MVP voting, posting his third 10+ WAR season. He was halfway through his Hawks deal, but decided to opt out and leave for free agency at age 30. It was dejecting in Nebraska, as Omaha fans realized that almost certainly meant the end of any competitive hopes.
Still, Fruechte remained a beloved figure in Omaha for many years to come. He played 1283 games for the Hawks with 1476 hits, 878 runs, 147 doubles, 381 home runs, 892 RBI, 693 walks, 226 steals, .328/.418/.634 slash, 222 wRC+, and 77.6 WAR. Fruechte’s #14 uniform would be retired at the end of his career. His departure certainly paid off financially with a seven-year, $179,400,000 deal with San Diego.
Fruechte ran into some trouble initially with a torn labrum costing him the second half of 2015. He bounced back in 2016 with his third MVP, leading the American Association with 55 homers, .621 OPS, and a career-best 138 runs. This was also his lone Silver Slugger as a DH. Fruechte picked up one more in LF in 2019 to have nine for his career.
He led in OBP and wRC+ in 2017 and remained strong, but Fruechte never reached his Omaha peaks again. Various injuries played a role in this, especially with his back. Although San Diego would have an all-time dynasty run in the 2020s, Fruechte’s tenure was during a downturn for the franchise. Although rarely outright terrible, the Seals missed the playoffs from 2011-22, averaging 80 wins per season.
With San Diego in seven seasons, Fruechte played 822 games with 945 hits, 653 runs, 72 doubles, 275 home runs, 590 RBI, .307/.395/.618 slash, 176 wRC+, and 40.2 WAR. The deal expired heading towards his age 38 season of 2022. Fruechte still had buyers and signed a three-year, $69 million deal with New Orleans. The Mudcats had won the 2021 World Series with an all-time team at 112-50. New Orleans wanted some depth and Fruechte hoped he could finally get some playoff appearances.
Fruechte stayed healthy with the Mudcats, but was merely a good starter in his first two years. They missed the playoffs in 2022 and 2024 and suffered a second round exit in 2023. Despite Fruechte’s brilliance, he played 16 career playoff games in two seasons. In 2023, Fruechte became the 7th member of the 700 home run club. He and Isaac Cox joined the club about a month apart with many wondering if they both would pass the all-time top mark of 758 owned by Cody Lim.
Cox blew by that mark, but Fruechte fell off sharply in 2024. He was reduced to a part-time role with only 9 homers, 0.3 WAR, and .671 OPS in 71 games. Fruechte retired that winter at age 40 and finished in New Orleans with 376 games, 315 hits, 213 runs, 29 doubles, 83 home runs, 185 RBI, .245/.349/.471 slash, 129 wRC+, and 6.7 WAR.
Fruechte finished with 2481 games, 2736 hits, 1744 runs, 248 doubles, 82 triples, 739 home runs, 1667 RBI, 1340 walks, 739 strikeouts, 419 steals, .309/.400/.605 slash, 1.005 OPS, 192 wRC+, and 124.5 WAR. As of 2037, Fruechte ranks 10th in homers, 38th in runs, 48th in total bases (5365), 68th in RBI, 31st in walks, and 14th in WAR among position players.
His OPS ranks 10th among all batters with 3000+ plate appearances in MLB as of 2037, although Fruechte is the only retired player to be above 1.000. He also ranks 12th in OBP and 18th in slugging. Fruechte didn’t have the longevity to make the world leaderboards in the counting stats, but he’s among the most efficient bats ever.
Fruechte’s 192 wRC+ is 21st among all world Hall of Famers as of 2037. He also ranks 38th in OPS and 38th in OBP among that group. It is a short list of those with a career OPS above 1.000 and OBP above .400. Fruechte’s stats against RHP specifically are nearly unfathomable and he has to be in the conversation for best batters ever against righties.
He was an obvious inner-circle Hall of Famer and co-headliner for Major League Baseball’s 2030 class at 98.4%. Fruechte’s exact spot in the all-time rankings is tough to sort out though for MLB scholars. His hitting efficiency was certainly upper-echelon, but Fruechte didn’t have team successes. Spending notable time as a DH and subpar fielding keeps him out of some top 10 lists even if he was a top ten bat. Fruechte is certainly one of MLB’s immortals and beloved stars in any event.

Sunny Williams – Starting Pitcher – Orlando Orcas – 77.8% First Ballot
Sunny Williams was a 6’2’’, 195 pound left-handed pitcher from Wake Forest, North Carolina; a town of 47,000 people best known as the original home of the eponymous university. Williams had very strong stuff and control along with average movement. His velocity peaked in the 97-99 mph range with a three-pitch arsenal of curveball, cutter, and splitter. Williams’ ability to change speeds made him one of the better strikeout pitchers of his era.
For most of his career, Williams had rock solid stamina and durability. He tossed 260+ innings each year from 2009-19. Williams was good at holding runners, but graded as weak defensively otherwise. He provided very steady production and was perhaps one of the more overlooked aces of his era in MLB.
Williams thrived in three years of college for Vanderbilt with a 21-14 record, 2.30 ERA, 300.2 innings, 314 strikeouts, 73 walks, 139 ERA+, and 10.7 WAR. In the 2007 MLB Draft, Williams went 17th overall to Orlando. He was a full-timer immediately and had 5+ WAR in each of his first eight seasons. Williams wasn’t overwhelmingly dominant though and never was a Pitcher of the Year finalist. Being on mostly mid Orcas teams didn’t get him attention either, as they never made the playoffs during his tenure.
The biggest highlights included leading the American Association with 259 strikeouts in 2012, a career high. 2013 was Williams’ best by WAR (7.8) and saw him lead in innings with 283.2. His best ERA was 2.95 in his second season of 2009. Williams had signed a six-year, $68 million extension with Orlando after the 2011 season.
In total for Orlando, Williams had a 152-128 record, 3.11 ERA, 2595.1 innings, 2198 strikeouts, 608 walks, 121 ERA+, and 59.9 WAR. He was there close to a full decade and got his #27 uniform retired by the Orcas at the end of his career. Williams’ deal was coming due in 2017 with Orlando being stuck around .500. In mid July 2017, the Orcas traded Williams to Salt Lake City for prospects LF Pat Heisey and C Kevin Vargas. Both did start for a few years for the Orcas with Hesiey putting up passable stats over a decade.
The Loons wanted Williams long-term and only nine days after the trade gave him a seven-year, $108,600,000 extension. SLC was trying to dethrone Seattle in the Northwest Division and just missed the cut in 2017. The Loons couldn’t get a division title, but did earn wild cards from 2018-20. They never got further than the second round. In his 35.1 career playoff innings, Williams had a solid 2.80 ERA, 2-1 record, 43 strikeouts, and 1.9 WAR.
Williams’ overall production with SLC wasn’t as strong as his Orlando peaks, but he still was a solid part of the rotation and thrice had 5+ WAR seasons. 2021 had Williams’ first injury issues as a herniated disc kept him out for the first half of the year. Additional back spasms kept Williams out for about two months in 2023. Still, that year Williams became the 28th pitcher in MLB history to reach 3500 career strikeouts.
In 2024, Williams became the 46th MLB pitcher to reach 250 wins. By this point, Salt Lake City had settled into the middle of the standings. Williams was still a reliable innings eater in the last year of his contract, but disaster struck with a torn rotator cuff in the final week of the season. Doctors gave him a 13 month recovery time, meaning he’d miss all of 2025 in a best case scenario.
With the Loons, Williams had a 101-81 record, 3.67 ERA, 1666.1 innings, 1501 strikeouts, 302 walks, 106 ERA+, and 35.9 WAR. Williams wanted to pick again and rehabbed throughout 2025. Winnipeg signed him to a deal in August 2025, but he never saw the field. Williams opted to retire that winter at age 38.
Williams ended with a 253-209 record, 3.33 ERA, 4261.2 innings, 3699 strikeouts, 910 walks, 331/524 quality starts, 271 complete games, 42 shutouts, 114 ERA+, 83 FIP-, and 95.8 WAR. As of 2037, Williams ranks 43rd in wins, 50th in innings, 15th in complete games, 62nd in shutouts, 20th in strikeouts, and 36th in WAR among pitchers.
He was never viewed as a top three pitcher in his career, but Williams quietly had remarkably steady innings and production. Many Hall of Fame voters were somewhat surprised to find Williams accumulations were so high. He hit plenty of benchmarks even without the big awards or playoff success. Williams received 77.8% for a first ballot nod to cap off a three-player 2030 class for Major League Baseball.
Comment