
For only the second time in Major League Baseball history, the Hall of Fame had a class of five players. Unlike the star-studded 1934 class, the 1960 edition didn’t have any inner-circle level guys despite adding five. Still, all five players were first ballot selections. SP Henry Lopez and 2B J.R. Osborn were the stars at 88.9% and 88.3%, respectively. SP Millard Barkley received 75.0%, SP Carter Hicks got 72.8%, and CL Victor Porter secured 68.0%. Three others made it above 50%. No one in the 1960 ballot was dropped after a tenth try.

Henry Lopez – Starting Pitcher – Philadelphia Phillies – 88.9% First Ballot
Henry Lopez was a 6’3’’, 195 pound right-handed pitcher from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. He was a very hard-throwing pitcher with 98-100 mph velocity, mixing great stuff with good movement and respectable control. Lopez’s fastball was outstanding, mixed with a good curveball and good changeup. He attended Ohio University in college and wasn’t incredibly highly touted, picked in the third round, 125th overall, by Philadelphia in the 1939 MLB Draft.
Lopez immediately proved he belonged though, earning the National Association Rookie of the Year in 1940 with 5.0 WAR and a 2.37 ERA in only 25 starts. Injuries meant he only made 27 starts in his second year, but he still was stellar enough to earn the Pitcher of the Year with a 2.35 ERA, 16-3 record, 202 strikeouts, and 6.0 WAR. This year was the first of the Phillies dynasty and Lopez had a great postseason, going 3-1 with a 2.15 ERA over 29.1 playoff innings.
A hamstring strain, followed by bone chips in his elbow, put Lopez out for a big chunk of 1942. He missed the postseason, but Philadelphia rolled to back-to-back World Series rings. The Phillies would win the National Association title in seven straight seasons from 1941-47, winning the World Series in 41, 42, 43, 44, and 47. In his Philadelphia playoff career, Lopez had a 10-6 record, 3.34 ERA over 148 innings, 109 strikeouts, and 2.8 WAR. 1945 and 1946 were Lopez’s top seasons by WAR, posting 7.5 in both. He was also the league leader in wins (23, 22) in those seasons, earning Pitcher of the Year in 1945. In total in Philly, he had a 162-78 record, 2.87 ERA over 2259 innings, 1994 strikeouts, and 56.2 WAR. His #3 uniform would be retired at the end of his career.
At age 31, Lopez entered free agency and signed a five-year, $241,000 contract with San Diego. He wasn’t an elite pitcher with the Seals, but gave them four seasons of respectable production. In his fifth year in SD at age 35, disaster struck in April with a ruptured UCL. Lopez opted to retire due to this injury at age 36.
The final stats for Lopez: 231-117, 3.16 ERA, 3234.2 innings, 2661 strikeouts, 269/416 quality starts, 165 complete games, a FIP- of 82, and 73.0 WAR. His grand totals are a bit lower than some other pitchers in the Hall, but he had solid production and was a big playoff performer in MLB’s most impressive dynasty. This earns Lopez the first ballot nod at 88.9%.

J.R. Osborn – Second Baseman – San Francisco Gold Rush – 88.3% First Ballot
J.R. Osborn was a 5’10’’, 200 pound right handed second baseman from Merced, California; a smaller city in the central part of the state. Osborn was an excellent contact hitter and an ironman who avoided major injury until the very end of his career. He was also a team captain, known as a terrific leader and hard worker. Osborn had respectable gap power and speed and was great at avoid strikeouts, although he was below average at drawing walks. He made starts at six positions in his career, but spent the bulk at second base and was considered a solid and reliable glove.
He attended Eastern Michigan University and was the NCAA Silver Slugger winner at 2B in 1933. That winter, San Francisco picked him 16th overall in the MLB Draft. Osborn spent nearly his entire career with the Gold Rush and he was instantly excellent, earning a Silver Slugger in his rookie year and taking second in Rookie of the Year voting. He won four Silver Sluggers in total, also taking the award in 1939, 43, and 44.
Osborn was never in the top three in MVP voting, as he lacked the sexy power numbers and was only a league-leader once (43 doubles in 1945), But he consistently posted 4+ WAR in 13 consecutive seasons, averaging around 30 doubles and 20 home runs per year. He was a reliable leader in an era where San Francisco was usually above or around .500, but unable to make it into the postseason.
He finally got to the playoffs at age 37 in 1950 as the Gold Rush went on a run and won it all. By this point, he was more of an elder statesmen and less of a major contributor, including a bench role in the 1950 and 1951 World Baseball Championship tournaments for the US team. Age started to catch up to Osborn as he struggled in 1951, then missed most of 1952 with a torn calf muscle. Early in the 1953 season, Osborn was released but on good terms, as he’d return to the Bay to have his jersey#27 retired in 1955. San Antonio signed him for the 1953 season and with the Oilers, he picked up the 3500 career hit and 1500 career RBI milestones. He went to Tampa for his final season in 1954, going unsigned in 1955 and retiring at age 43.
Osborn’s final stats: 3703 hits, 1847 runs, 601 doubles, 210 triples, 335 home runs, 1582 RBI, 727 stolen bases, a .308/.353/.476 slash and 88.7 WAR. At retirement, he was second all-time in hits to Stan Provost. Jess Lewis would pass him in 1959, but Osborn would remain third all-time as of 2037. He was fourth in runs scored at retirement and second in doubles. Osborn’s longevity and reliability make him an easy first ballot pick at 88.3%.

Millard Barkley – Starting Pitcher – New York Yankees – 75.0% First Ballot
Millard Barkley was a 6’0’’, 190 pound right-handed starting pitcher from Hamburg, New York; a town just south of Buffalo. Barkley was known for having very good movement over a diverse pitch arsenal with decent control. His velocity on his fastball peaked at 95-97 mph, but Barkley mixed in a slider, changeup, splitter, and knuckle curve. The knuckle curve was viewed as his best pitch and he was known to earn ground balls often. Perhaps his most important attribute was durability as an ironman who made 31+ starts in all but the first and final season of his 22 year professional career.
Barkley attended Georgia Tech and was drafted close to home in the 1930 MLB Draft, selected in the second round, 86th overall, by Buffalo. He spent his first three pro seasons largely in minor league Rochester, making his MLB debut with a few relief appearances in 1933. He entered the rotation the next year and spent three seasons with the Blue Sox with respectable, but unremarkable results. He had a 45-39 record, 3.62 ERA, and 12.3 WAR over 711.1 innings with Buffalo.
At age 27, Barkley was traded to the other side of the state to the New York Yankees. He became best known as a Yankee and was inducted in the pinstripes, although his main run there only lasted five seasons. There was well, he was reliable and respectable, but nothing outstanding. At age 32, Barkley was traded before the 1942 season to Charlotte. In his four seasons with the Canaries, he had his first chance at the playoffs. He had a 60-57 record, 3.79 ERA, and 15.7 WAR while there.
Barkley was again traded, this time to the Philadelphia dynasty before the 1946 season. The now 36-year old Barkley had his best season in his Phillies debut, taking third in Pitcher of the Year voting with a career-best 2.14 ERA, 20-10 record, and 7.1 WAR. He had a solid run in the 1946 and 47 postseasons with a 5-3 record, 3.06 ERA, 67.2 innings, and 0.9 WAR. The Phillies won the National Association title in 1946 and the World Series in 1947, giving a ring to Barkley.
He became a free agent after the 1947 and showed no signs of aging at this point. He bounced around for the next six seasons, but posted 31.4 WAR with statistically the most impressive run of his career despite moving into his 40s. Barkley played with Phoenix in 1948, Jacksonville in 1949, the Yankees in 1950 and 51, Philadelphia again in 1952, and Columbus in 1953. In 1954 with Tampa, he finally fell off significantly and retired at the year’s end at age 44.
The final stats for Barkley: 293-267, 3.54 ERA, 5191.2 innings, 3536 strikeouts, 1634 walks, 417/685 quality starts, 224 complete games, and 90.9 WAR. His 685 starts were only two behind Angelo Leblanc’s all-time mark. He’s a test case in the argument between the voters that feel peak dominance is the most important and those who more value longevity. Barkley was never dominant or a league leader or viewed as the most elite guy. But he provided reliable production over three decades and remarkably had his best success in his late 30s and early 40s when most others are out of the game. Thus, Barkley picked up 75.0% on his debut to earn his place among the legends of the game.

Carter “Hawkeye” Hicks – Starting Pitcher – Brooklyn Dodgers – 72.8% First Ballot
Carter Hicks was a 5’11’’, 185 pound left-handed starting pitcher from New York City. Hicks was a hard thrower with 99-101 mph velocity, often overpowering batters. His key pitch was a slider, mixed with a cutter, splitter, and a changeup. His movement and control were considered average to above average, but the power of those pitches made up for any deficiencies. Hicks was very durable and reliable in his 20s, although his personality didn’t make him any friends. He was often criticized for a lack of hustle and loyalty, but his talent kept him around.
Hicks attended Rutgers University and returned back to NYC to start his MLB career, picked seventh overall in the 1939 MLB Draft by Brooklyn. He made a solid debut in 1940 and would be a full-time starter for the Dodgers from 1940 through the summer of 1948. In his second season, Hicks led the National Association in WAR. He’d do it twice more with 8.7 in 1944 and 8.9 in 1945. Hicks also led the NA in strikeouts in 43, 44, and 45. In 1944, Hicks won his lone Pitcher of the Year with a league and career best 2.40 ERA over 273.1 innings with 283 strikeouts. He finished third for the award in 1945.
Hicks was a bright spot for Brooklyn and the Dodgers had some solid seasons, but were never able to make the playoffs in his tenure. He signed a massive seven-year, $307,200 deal before the 1946 season, but the team began to struggle and rebuild at the end of the 1940s. Brooklyn traded the now 29-year old Hicks midway through the 1948 season to St. Louis. He gave some solid production over the next four seasons for a struggling Cardinals squad.
In 1951, Hicks had his first injury issues with forearm tendinitis and inflammation. He was healthy the next year, but saw his production fall to league-average levels. His contract expired after the 1952 season and he signed a five-year, $305,000 deal with San Francisco. In late April 1953, the 34-year old Hicks suffered a torn labrum, putting him out for the year. The Gold Rush cut him in the offseason and he signed for 1954 with Ottawa. This would be Hicks’ final season at age 35 and he’d get his first opportunity at the postseason with the Elks. After the season, Brooklyn reached out and opted to retire Hicks’ #45 uniform for his time there.
The final stats for Hicks: 208-162, 2.96 ERA, 3525.2 innings, 3116 strikeouts, 845 walks, 336/461 quality starts, 139 complete games, and 79.2 WAR. He was more of a short-burst career, but had enough dominance in his peak to get a look despite a prickly personality and spending his career on weak franchises. Hicks picked up a first ballot induction at 72.8%.

Victor “Skates” Porter – Closer – San Diego Seals – 68.0% First Ballot
Victor Porter was a 6’4’’, 200 pound right-handed closer from Waterford, California; a small town in the central part of the state not far from Modesto. Porter had dual American/Mexican citizenship with an American father and Mexican mother. He was one of the hardest throwing pitchers of the era with a stellar 99-101 mph fastball. He combined this with excellent movement on a curveball and solid control. Porter went south to Mississippi State for college and took second in NCAA Pitcher of the Year voting in his sophomore season. This earned him the 42nd overall pick in the 1937 MLB Draft by San Diego.
After nine innings in 1938, Porter became the closer for the Seals in 1939 and held that role for the next decade. He won Reliever of the Year three times; in 1942, 43, and 46. Porter was second in Reliever of the Year in both 1939, 41, and 47; consistently viewed as an elite closer during his San Diego tenure. He led the American Association in saves in 1941 and 43, posting eight seasons of 4+ WAR. The Seals made it to the AACS in 1945 and 46 with Porter posting a 0.59 ERA in 15.1 playoff innings. In total with San Diego, Porter had 289 saves, a 1.68 ERA over 652 innings, 1141 strikeouts, and 44.8 WAR. The Seals would retire his #3 uniform once his career was done.
Porter’s career peaked in San Diego as he would bounce around between seven teams over his final six seasons. Oddly enough, his role and use would become significantly diminished despite never suffering any significant injury or really seeing a steep drop in productivity. He had some success in limited use, but apart for a brief stretch in 1952 as Seattle’s closer, he was a rarely used arm in his 30s. Porter signed with Cleveland in 1949 at age 32 and was traded to Oakland mid-season. He signed with Jacksonville in 1950 and was traded to Chicago in mid 1951. Porter went to Seattle in 1952 and was traded to Indianapolis midseason. He stayed with the Racers in 1953, then signed with Hartford in 1954. The Huskies released him in the summer and he was picked up by Houston’s minor league affiliate for the rest of the year, retiring at season’s end at age 37.
The final stats: 309 saves, 1.97 ERA, 819 innings, 1351 strikeouts, 239 walks, 355 shutdowns, FIP- of 34 and 50.5 WAR. His save total was lower than more that got the nod previously, but he was dominant enough in his peak to post 50+ WAR. At the time, only two other relievers had gotten above 50 WAR in their career. That peak dominance with the Seals earned him just enough to crack the 66% threshold at 68.0%, putting Porter into the Hall on the first ballot.
Comment