Major League Baseball had an impressive four player Hall of Fame class with the 1984 voting. The top three guys were all first ballot picks with two absolute no-doubters in starting pitcher Julius Jordan at 98.6% and closer Carson Hanford at 98.0%. 2B Grayson Angeline also got the first ballot recognition at 81.7%. The fourth player in the group was 3B Benton Gibney, who narrowly crossed the 66% threshold with 69.3% on his fifth ballot. RF Bo Salinas was close but just short with 63.0% on his fourth attempt. Also above 50% were 3B Jim Booth at 56.2% for his second go and 1B Braylen Nelson with 54.4% in his seventh attempt.

Dropped after ten tries was closer Wes Kihm, who had a 17-year career primarily with Oakland. He debuted at 51.4%, but was down to 21.2% by the end. He won Reliever of the Year once and had 255 saves with 310 shutdowns, a 2.16 ERA, 1155 strikeouts over 792.2 innings and 35.9 WAR. Kihn lacked the dominance that some other closers had though, keeping him out.
Three others were dropped after ten ballots with each finishing in the single digits. SP Logan Davis had a 16-year career primarily with Ottawa and won 1966 Pitcher of the Year, putting up a 207-172 record, 3.10 ERA, 2819 strikeouts over 3691 innings and 77.1 WAR. He peaked at 32.2% in his debut. Closer Tyrone Brown won Reliever of the Year twice and peaked at 43.3%. In 17 years almost exclusively in San Francisco, Brown had 227 saves and 287 shutdowns, a 1.92 ERA, 990 strikeouts over 712 innings and 35.0 WAR. 1B Krispen Bell played 16 years with four teams and peaked at 24.8%. He had a solid 575 career home runs, but only 48.5 WAR along with 2157 hits, 1290 runs, 1490 RBI, and a .268/.322/.531 slash. Nice careers for those three, but they lacked the big accumulations or accolades to get much traction.

Julius Jordan – Starting Pitcher – Houston Hornets – 98.6% First Ballot
Julius Jordan was a 6’3’’, 200 pound right-handed pitcher from Lyons, Oregon; a tiny town of around 1,000 people located about 70 miles south of Portland. Jordan was known for incredible 10/10 stuff with 97-99 mph peak velocity. His movement was merely average with his control becoming solid later in his career. Jordan had three pitches; fastball, changeup, and cutter; and was a master at changing speeds. Jordan was also an ironman who never missed a start to injury and had very good stamina. His main flaw was being poor at defense and holding runners.
Jordan played college baseball at East Carolina and was relatively unheralded compared to other eventual Hall of Famers. His home state team Portland would pick him late in the second round, 110th overall, in the 1958 Major League Baseball Draft. Jordan was split between the rotation and bullpen, then was a full-time starter with 33+ starts each year for the next 18 seasons. He had some issues allowing home runs in his early years and although he ate innings, his advanced stats had Jordan as an average-at-best pitcher in his first seasons with the Pacifics. They made the playoffs thrice while Jordan was there, but never got out of the second round.
Jordan started to improve and get more notice towards the end of his Portland tenure, leading the American Association in strikeouts in both 1965 and 1966. He led in WHIP in 65, but saw his ERA skyrocket in 66. Jordan was decent to start 1967, but a rebuilding Pacifics squad opted to move the now 29-year old Jordan with it being a contract year. He was traded in a six-player deal to San Francisco at the deadline and finished out the year with the Gold Rush, who were eliminated in the second round of the playoffs. In total with Portland, Jordan had a 128-130 record, 3.82 ERA, 2250.1 innings, 2251 strikeouts, and 41.7 WAR.
Jordan had established himself if nothing else as someone who got you a lot of innings, although his 107 ERA+ with the Pacifics marked him as an above average at best arm. Regardless, he had suitors in free agency and signed a seven year, $1,722,000 deal with Houston. Jordan had a strong debut season with the Hornets and led in strikeouts, but his ERA jumped above four in the next two seasons. Improving his control, Jordan became considered elite for the first time in 1971. He had a career best 2.61 ERA and led the AA in strikeouts, innings, quality starts, and WAR, earning his lone Pitcher of the Year.
Jordan’s 1972 set career highs in WAR (10.2) and strikeouts (330), although he’d surprisingly not be a PotY finalist. Houston had been middling in his tenure, then fell off a major cliff with only 57 wins in 1973. Jordan’s productivity dropped a bit and that summer, they moved Jordan for prospects to Seattle. He finished 1973 and pitched a solid 1974 with the Grizzlies, taking second in 1974’s Pitcher of the Year voting. Jordan had a 2.90 ERA in 40.1 playoff innings for Seattle, who fell in the AACS in 1974.
Jordan wouldn’t resign with the Grizzlies and became a free agent at age 37. Houston signed him again and he posted very solid efforts in 1975 and 76, taking third in PotY in the former. The Hornets made the AACS in 1976 but were denied with Jordan ultimately never making it to a World Series. He was okay in 1977, then struggled in 1978 and wasn’t used in their playoff run. Still, that year he became the seventh pitcher to 300 career wins and ended up just short of 5000 career strikeouts, retiring the all-time leader with 4988. Jordan retired at age 41 and between his two runs with Houston, had a 160-123 record, 3.65 ERA, 2608 innings, 2297 strikeouts, and 60.3 WAR. The Hornets added him to the ring of honor by retiring his #8 uniform.
Jordan’s final career stats: 312-275 record, 3.67 ERA, 5308 innings, 4988 strikeouts to 1241 walks, 376/660 quality starts, 308 complete games, FIP- of 85, and 112.8 WAR. His longevity pushed him up the leaderboards and at induction, he was the strikeout leader, tied for fourth in wins, fifth in innings pitched, third in complete games, and seventh in pitching WAR. On the downside, he was second all-time in losses, second in home runs allowed, and his ERA was among the worst of other Hall of Famers. Still, even as of 2037, Jordan is still MLB’s career strikeout leader. He was never the most dominant or impressive pitcher in the league, but his longevity and durability made him a fixture on the leaderboards and a first round selection at 98.6%.

Carson Hanford – Closer – Oakland Oaks – 98.0% First Ballot
Carson Hanford was a 5’11’’, 180 pound right-handed relief pitcher from Carlsbad, California; a city of around 115,000 people in San Diego County. He only had a 97-99 mph fastball and changeup, but his stuff was considered legendary. Hanford also had very good control and solid movement, making him tough to crack when he was on. He was known for solid stamina and durability and was one of the only relievers to hold a closer role his entire run, getting 20+ saves in all of his 20 professional seasons. Hanford was also a team captain and incredibly hard worker, making him an endearing player, especially on the national stage.
Even though he’s considered by many to be Major League Baseball’s greatest closer, perhaps his most notoriety came in the World Baseball Championship. Hanford was a fixture from 1960-78 on the United States team with 17 starts, 101 appearances, and 255 innings. In that stretch, he had an impressive 560 strikeouts, 2.12 ERA, 26-6 record, 31 saves, 0.65 WHIP, and 12.8 WAR. As of 2037, no pitcher has appeared in more WBC games and he’s one of nine pitchers with 550+ career strikeouts. Hanford won 14 world titles and was the 1975 Best Pitcher with a 0.83 ERA over 21.2 innings.
He made a few starts in the WBC, but was a career reliever as a pro. Hanford was a great starter in college though at Tennessee and was second in 1959 NCAA Pitcher of the Year voting. Over 205 college innings, he had a 1.54 ERA, 293 strikeouts, and 11.3 WAR. In the 1959 MLB Draft, Albuquerque selected Hanford 29th overall. In his second year with the Isotopes, he took second in Reliever of the Year voting with 5.1 WAR. Hanford was the closer five seasons for the then middling Albuquerque squad, posting 135 saves, a 1.80 ERA over 335.1 innings, 480 strikeouts, and 18.7 WAR.
Just before the start of the 1965 season, the Isotopes traded Hanford straight up for starting pitcher Rylan Zimerman. His one season with the Firebirds saw him lead the American Association in saves for the second time. Hanford became a free agent that offseason at age 27 and signed a four-year, $604,000 deal with Oakland. This began his signature run of 13 seasons with the Owls, the type of longevity almost never seen for a closer in pro baseball.
Hanford was the starting closer for all of that run for Oakland, who was consistently at or just above .500. They made the postseason six times in his tenure, but never got out of the second round. Hanford won Reliever of the Year twice; in 1973 and 1976. He also took second in 1969 and third in 1974. In total with the Owls, Hanford had 368 saves, a 1.96 ERA over 800.1 innings, 1101 strikeouts, and 36.3 WAR.
He continued his productivity seemingly unabated through his 30s. In 1974, Hanford became MLB’s fourth pitcher to 400 career saves. By 1977, he was the all-time leader and the only one to 500. Hanford ended up with 536 MLB saves, still the all-time leader as of 2037 by a solid margin. He finished with Oakland after the 1978 season and saw his #27 uniform retired. Hanford played one more pro season in Monrovia of West African Baseball and after going unsigned in 1980, retired at age 42. Counting his WAB season, Hanford had 571 career saves.
For his MLB career, Hanford finished with 536 saves and 557 shutdowns, a 1.89 ERA, 130-96 record, 1104 games, 1192.2 innings, 1660 strikeouts to 331 walks, a FIP- of 49 and 58.2 WAR. As of 2037, he remains the MLB leader in saves and games pitched. Hanford also has the most WAR, most strikeouts, and second best ERA among Hall of Fame relievers. Many point at him as MLB’s GOAT closer for good reason and Hanford was an obvious first ballot choice at 98.0%.
Comment