Eurasian Professional Baseball had a two-player Hall of Fame class in 1987. Pitcher Nikolai Saidov was a first ballot choice leading the way with 77.5%. He was joined by fellow pitcher Pavel Melnichuk, who barely reached the 66% threshold with 66.4% on his third attempt. Another pitcher, Serhiy Belov, fell just short with 61.4% on his third try. Four others were above 50% with starting pitchers Artyom Rudasev (56.2%) and Eryk Wozniak (54.3%) both short for the ninth time. 2B Ali Alasgarov was at 54.6% on his fifth ballot and closer Marius Patrascu was at 54.0% in his second.

One player was dropped after ten failed attempts in closer Vyacheslav Leskov. A three-time Reliever of the Year winner, he had a 15-year career between eight teams with 315 saves and 388 shutdowns, 1.82 ERA, 1004.1 innings, 1546 strikeouts, and 45.1 WAR. Relievers with weaker resumes had gotten into other Halls of Fame and you could argue he fit more than 1973 inductee Theo Siitonen, but the lower save total hurt him with some voters. Leskov got very close though with 64.1% on his debut, although he plummeted down to 15.1% by the end.

Nikolai “Rival” Saidov – Starting Pitcher - Chelyabinsk Cadets – 77.5% First Ballot
Nikolai Saidov was a 6’0’’, 190 pound left-handed pitcher from Selyatino, Russia; a town of around 12,000 located within the Moscow Oblast. Saidov’s biggest strength was having excellent control, which allowed him to thrive even with merely above average at best stuff and movement. His velocity peaked at 96-98 mph and he mixed a splitter, changeup, cutter, and curveball. Saidov had respectable stamina and his defense won him a Gold Glove in 1970. Saidov was a team captain and very respected in the clubhouse for his work ethic, loyalty, and intelligence. He also was very durable and pitched 30+ games in every season but his rookie year.
Saidov was selected 13th overall by Chelyabinsk in the 1965 EPB Draft. He was used sparingly as a reliever in the first two seasons, then was moved into the rotation full-time in 1968. Saidov posted 11 seasons worth 5+ WAR and was consistently solid, although rarely dominant or atop the leaderboard. In 1973, Saidov led the European League in wins, WHIP, and quality starts, taking third in Pitcher of the Year voting. This was his only time as a finalist for the award.
Saidov pitched for Russia’s national team off and on in the World Baseball Championship with a 1971-73 run and 1978-80 run. He tossed 29.1 innings with 50 strikeouts with a 3.07 ERA. Chelyabinsk was generally middling in his tenure, making the playoffs only twice in his tenure. They were one-and-done in 1973, but put it all together in 1978 to win their first Soviet Series. Saidov had an impressive postseason with five starts, a 4-1 record, 1.80 ERA, 40 innings, 43 strikeouts, four walks, and 1.5 WAR. The playoff run was a big reason that Saidov’s #17 uniform would later be retired by the franchise.
He stayed loyal as a team leader for the Cadets into his 30s. Saidov’s production stayed consistent until the 1980 season, where he saw his velocity begin to fall. Chelyabinsk opted to buyout the rest of his contract and he became a free agent at age 36. Saidov played one additional season with Tbilisi in 1981 and had an alright season for the Trains. He opted to retire though after the season at age 37.
Saidov’s final stats: 227-177 record, 2.71 ERA, 3757.1 innings, 3726 strikeouts, 543 walks, 326/461 quality starts, 154 complete games, FIP- of 82, and 81.2 WAR. His stats are firmly in the middle of the Hall of Fame leaderboard where he isn’t a slam dunk no-doubter, but he isn’t out of place either. Saidov was consistently reliable and loyal to Chelyabinsk, which resonated with enough voters to get him the first ballot nod with 77.5%.

Pavel Melnichuk – Starting Pitcher – Kharkiv Killer Bees – 66.4% Third Ballot
Pavel Melnichuk was a 6’4’’, 190 pound right-handed pitcher from Moscow, Russia. He had overpowering stuff with 99-101 mph peak velocity and used that to overwhelm hitters despite having lousy control and below average movement. Melnichuk knew how to change speeds though with a fastball, changeup, slider arsenal. He was pretty durable in his career, but his hard throwing meant he rarely went the distance in games compared to his contemporaries. Critics also panned Melnichuk for a lack of work ethic, but his talent still carried him to a great career.
Growing up as an amateur in Moscow, Melnichuk drew a lot of attention from Russian teams. His hometown Mules drafted him 32nd overall in the 1964 EPB Draft, but Melnichuk opted not to sign and play another year of college baseball. In 1965, Kazan picked him 31st overall and he decided to sign with the Crusaders. They used him as a back-end starter and bullpen piece for his first three seasons, but he showed flashes of potential. In 1968, Melnichuk had a 15 strikeout, one walk no-hitter against Riga. That season, he stepped up big in the postseason with a 1.47 ERA and 42 strikeouts over four starts and 30.2 innings. This helped Kazan claim the Soviet Series title.
Melnichuk was a full-time starter the next season and in 1970, but the Crusaders decided to move him at the 1970 deadline. His final stats with Kazan was a 59-26 record, 2.45 ERA, 821.2 innings, 1150 strikeouts, 242 walks, and 18.1 WAR. In 51.2 playoff innings, he had a 1.39 ERA and 80 strikeouts. He was traded straight up to Kharkiv for 1B Mykyta Lukyanenko. Melnichuk’s longest run was with the Killer Bees, although he was only there four-and-a-half years like with Kazan.
He wasn’t as good in the playoffs with the Killer Bees as he had a 3.38 ERA in 53.1 innings, but Melnichuk helped Kharkiv to the 1983 European League pennant. His inconsistent control kept him from ever being a Pitcher of the Year finalist despite his strikeout tallies. In total with the Killer Bees, Melnichuk had a 65-43 record, 2.86 ERA, 1006.2 innings, 1313 strikeouts, 287 walks, and 20.8 WAR. He also had a second no-hitter while in Ukraine, striking out 10 with one walk on September 3, 1973 against Helsinki.
Melnichuk entered free agency for the first time at age 32 and signed for the 1975 season on a two-year, $508,000 deal with Almaty. The Assassins were on their own playoff streak at this point and Melnichuk pitched in two league championship series with Almaty, posting a 2.70 playoff ERA in 33.1 innings. His 1976 season was arguably his best as he led the Asian league with a 1.77 ERA. This was Melnichuk’s only time with an ERA title or really any spot atop a leaderboard. He had an impressive 1.92 ERA and 36-15 in his two seasons in Kazakhstan with 588 strikeouts over 453.2 innings and 11.6 WAR.
Coming off arguably his best season, Melnichuk was a free agent again now at age 34. He went back home to Moscow on a four-year, $1,168,000 deal with the Mules. 1977 saw another sub-two ERA and a career-best 6.9 WAR season. He was more mid the next season and was relegated to a part-time role in 1979. Melnichuk was still under contract for all of 1980 with Moscow, but didn’t see the field. He retired after the season at age 38. With the Mules, he had a 34-25 record, 2.47 ERA, 609.2 innings, 675 strikeouts, and 12.1 WAR.
Melnichuk’s final stats had a 194-109 record, 2.51 ERA, 2891.2 innings, 3726 strikeouts, 796 walks, 291/389 quality starts, 82 FIP-, and 62.6 WAR. His strikeout rate is impressive, but his other tallies were on the lower end compared to other Hall of Famers. Bouncing between teams also soured him for some voters and Melnichuk missed the cut narrowly on his first two ballots with 65.4% and 61.0%. His postseason success helped give him some consistent supporters and kept him close to that 66% threshold. In the 1987 ballot, he got just enough new allies to sneak across the line at 66.4% to become a third ballot Hall of Famer.
Comment