
The 1995 Central American Baseball Association Hall of Fame class was one of the most impressive of all time. Four first-ballot selections were made with each getting in with more than 90% of the vote. SP Junior Vergara (99.4%) led the way, joined by SP Luis Feliz Brea (99.1%), 3B Kenedy Ortiz (98.2%), and CF Mario Bueno (91.0%). No other player was above 50% with the best returner being catcher Hansel Morel with 46.7% on his fifth ballot. No players were dropped after ten failed ballots.

Junior “Paydirt” Vergara – Starting Pitcher – Puebla Pumas – 99.4% First Ballot
Junior Vergara was a 5’11’’, 200 pound left handed starting pitcher from Axochiapan, a small city with around 39,000 people in the south central Mexican state of Morelos. Vergara had legendary stuff with outstanding control and good movement. His velocity peaked at 98-100 mph with five pitches that could beat you: fastball, slider, sinker, splitter, and knuckle curve. Vergara was incredibly intelligent and knew when to throw the right pitch, making him one of the most dominant pitchers ever. His skill and work ethic helped make him one of the most beloved pitchers in Mexican baseball history.
Vergara’s excellence was noted even in his amateur days, making him a prized prospect ahead of CABA’s 1975 Draft. Puebla grabbed him with the #2 overall pick and his entire CABA career would be as a Puma. Vergara was a full-time starter immediately and was respectable right away, taking third in Rookie of the Year voting in 1976. By his third season, Vergara had emerged as a true ace, leading in ERA and WHIP for the first time. He took second in Pitcher of the Year voting, hurt by a poor record from lousy run support.
From 1979-85, Vergara won seven consecutive Mexican League Pitcher of the Year awards, joining the legendary Ulices Montero as the only CABA pitchers to win it seven times. In this stretch, Vergara led the ML all seven years in strikeouts, WHIP, FIP-, and WAR. He also led in wins and ERA both five times and K/BB five time. Vergara earned Triple Crowns in 1979, 1980, 1981, and 1983. He was also regularly in the MVP conversation, taking third in 1979, third in 1982, second in 1983, and third in 1984. He also took his talents to the world stage for Mexico in the World Baseball Championship. From 1978-90, he had a 20-4 WBC record, 2.06 ERA, 218.2 innings, 310 strikeouts, and 9.0 WAR.
Puebla would be a regular team above .500 during Vergara’s reign, but the Pumas couldn’t get over the ump. They made the playoffs in 1982 and 1984, but were ousted both times in the MLCS. Puebla locked him up to a seven-year, $5,000,000 extension during the 1982 season. Vergara’s dominance carried into his 30s, posting a career-best 433 strikeouts in 1985. That was the third most Ks in a season and the first 400+ season in CABA since the 1920s. That season also had a career best in WHIP (0.67) and a staggering 13.7 WAR. The WAR mark was also the third-best season in CABA pitching history.
Vergara’s first major setback would come in the final week of spring training 1986. The 32-year old suffered a torn UCL, knocking him out for 12 months. Many pitchers are never the same after such an injury and it was an open question on how Vergara would look after missing the entire 1986 campaign. Amazingly, he didn’t seem to lose a beat.
In 1987 and 1988, Vergara again led the Mexican League in WAR, ERA, WHIP, and K/BB. He also led in wins and strikeouts in 1988 to secure an unprecedented fifth Triple Crown. As of 2037, he’s the only pitcher in any world league to reach this distinction. 1987 was his eighth Pitcher of the Year with a second place in MVP voting. 1988 would be his ninth Pitcher of the Year and his first league MVP. Vergara joined BSA’s Lazaro Rodriguez as the only pitchers in any world league to win POTY nine times at this point.
Puebla made the MLCS again in 1987, but yet again couldn’t advance further. It certainly wasn’t Vergara’s fault, as he had a 1.92 ERA in 51.2 playoff innings for the Pumas with 78 strikeouts and 2.5 WAR. 1989 would be his weakest season in some time, although his 6.9 WAR was still great by normal pitcher standards. Vergara finished third in Pitcher of the Year voting, but found himself at a crossroads. The Pumas dropped to .500 and contemplated going for the full rebuild.
Ultimately, Puebla would part ways with Vergara, making him a free agent for the first time at age 36. Certainly he was still absolutely beloved and his #2 uniform would soon be retired. CABA teams were interested, but so were MLB teams with bigger checkbooks. Vergara would sign a two-year, $3,520,000 deal with Los Angeles. The Angels had just ended a playoff drought and were hoping to be a contender into the 1990s.
Vergara had a good MLB debut, leading the American Association in complete games (22) and posting 6.6 WAR. Los Angeles won the AA pennant, falling in the World Series to Virginia Beach. Vergara was surprisingly lousy in the playoffs thought with a 5.30 ERA in 35.2 innings. In 1991, he looked pedestrian for the first time in his career. A hamstring strain also cost him a chunk of the season. Between the two years with the Angels, Vergara had a 3.24 ERA over 395 innings with 242 strikeouts and 6.6 WAR. He was unsigned in 1992 with the exception of one start in minor league Tulsa that September. Vergara realized his reign was over, retiring at age 39.
For his Puebla run, Vergara had a 240-99 record, 1.90 ERA, 3264 innings, 4532 strikeouts, 406 walks, a 11.2 K/BB, 325/385 quality starts, 150 complete games, 58 shutouts, 54 FIP-, and 123.7 WAR. Despite having the third most shutouts in CABA history, Vergara somehow never had a no-hitter. He didn’t have quite the longevity to be at the very top of the accumulations, but he was still third in strikeouts and second in pitching WAR at induction. Despite being 12th in wins at induction, he is the only HOF starter as of 2037 in CABA to have a winning percentage greater than 70%. Vergara’s 1.90 ERA is still second-best among HOF starters. He was undoubtedly THE CABA pitcher of the 1970 and 1980s and any top five all-time CABA pitcher conversations have Vergara mentioned prominently. His 99.4% percentage appropriately puts him at the front of the loaded 1995 class.

Luis Feliz Brea – Starting Pitcher – Jamaica Jazz – 99.1% First Ballot
Luis Feliz Brea was a 6’0’’, 205 pound right-handed pitcher from La Herradura, a small town of around 3,000 people located 50 minutes southwest of Panama City. Brea was a well-rounded pitcher with very good stuff, movement, and control. He improved his movement and control in later years as his stuff and velocity declined. In his prime, Brea’s fastball regularly hit the 98-100 mph range. He had an outstanding curveball as well as a decent slider and changeup. Brea had good stamina and was very durable, pitching 195+ innings in each of his 16 pro seasons.
At a camp in Panama City in the summer of 1967, a teenaged Brea was spotted and signed by a scout from Jamaica. He spent six years in the Jazz’ developmental system before debuting in 1974 at age 22. He was a full-time starter for his entire run in Kingston. Brea’s second season saw him lead the Caribbean League for strikeouts for the only time in his career. It was also his first of three seasons leading the league in WAR. Brea also led once in wins, ERA, innings, and WHIP.
Brea didn’t light up the leaderboards like his Hall of Fame classmate junior Vergara, but he was consistently very good for a long while. He took second in Pitcher of the Year voting in 1977, which led to a five-year, $1,910,000 extension that winter. 1978 saw the Jazz end a decade-long playoff drought. They were ousted in the wild card round, although Brea’s lone playoff start was a shutout. Brea was third in 1979 Pitcher of the Year voting. He also pitched great for his native panama from 1975-89 in the World Baseball Championship. He tossed 227 WBC innings with an 18-7 record, 2.66 ERA, 265 strikeouts, and 7.2 WAR.
1980 was a banner year for many reasons. Brea won his first Pitcher of the Year and led in ERA for the only time in his career. The Jazz also went all the way and won the CABA Championship, although Brea’s personal stats were a mixed bag with a 3-1 record over 30.2 innings, but 4.11 ERA. Jamaica made the playoffs again the next two seasons, but wouldn’t get beyond the CLCS. For his postseason career, Brea had a 3.82 ERA over 70.2 innings with 75 strikeouts and 2.5 WAR. He took second in 1981 Pitcher of the Year voting.
Before the 1982 season, the 30-year old Brea was signed to a seven-year, $3,206,000 extension. He was second in 1982 Pitcher of the Year voting, then won the award for the second time in 1983. Brea was a finalist one more time, taking second in 1984. He remained steady and solid throughout the 1980s, although Jamaica fell towards the bottom of the standings by the midpoint of the decade.
1989 was the final year of his extension and Jamaica had just come off of four consecutive seasons with fewer than 70 wins. The team decided to trade Brea to Havana to get four prospects. He still remained well liked by Jazz fans and his #24 uniform would quickly be retired. Brea’s velocity dropped by this point and his one year with the Hurricanes was easily the weakest of his career. He did hit two major milestones in Cuba, becoming the 10th CABA pitcher to 4000 strikeouts and the seventh to 250 wins. Brea retired that winter at age 38.
Brea’s stats saw a 251-176 record, 2.79 ERA, 4023.1 innings, 4125 strikeouts, 624 walks, 370/517 quality starts, 126 complete games, 74 FIP-, and 107.6 WAR. His excellence gets overshadowed by playing in the same era as Vergara, but Brea at induction was fourth in pitching WAR. As of 2037, he’s still seventh best on that list. He sustained an stellar career almost quietly. The voters didn’t miss Brea’s contributions and gave him the inner-circle level nod with 99.1%.
Comment