Beisbol Sudamerica’s 2024 Hall of Fame class was loaded with three players each finishing above 94% of the vote. SP Fernan Murillo (99.2%), OF Marco Del Cid (96.0%), and SP Samuel Alves (94.8%) were each slam dunk picks. The best returner was 3B Artemio Reyes at 61.1% on his eighth ballot, falling just shy of the 66% requirement. No other players cracked 50% and only two others were above 40%.

3B Emilio Aruquipa was dropped after ten ballots, peaking with 42.3% in his debut and ending at 9.5%. He had a 21-year career between Santa Cruz and Buenos Aires with 2744 hits, 1269 runs, 417 doubles, 183 triples, 79 home runs, 821 RBI, 904 walks, 1409 stolen bases, .316/.382/.434 slash, 129 wRC+, and 69.0 WAR. Aruquipa was a great leadoff man and ranks second in stolen bases in BSA history and 27th among all world players as of 2037. He never led in any other stats though and lacked accolades and power, keeping him in the Hall of Good.
Another guy dropped was 1B Theo Rijo, who peaked with his 36.9% debut and ended at 7.1% on his tenth try. He had 15 years primarily with Belo Horizonte with 2118 hits, 1085 runs, 322 doubles, 440 home runs, 1210 RBI, .311/.379/.565 slash, 166 wRC+, and 74.4 WAR. Rijo was quietly a very efficient hitter, but had no black ink or awards. He would’ve needed a few more years to get the tallies high enough to earn more attention.

Fernan Murillo – Starting Pitcher – Buenos Aires Atlantics – 99.2% First Ballot
Fernan Murillo was a 6’4’’, 200 pound left-handed starting pitcher from Barrancabermea, a city of 203,000 people in north central Colombia known as the nation’s oil capital. Murillo had excellent stuff and control along with above average movement. His velocity peaked in the 99-101 mph range with a cutter as his most powerful pitch. Murillo’s deadliest offering was his curveball, although his slider and knuckle curve were both good. He also had a rarely used changeup as the fifth option. His diverse arsenal helped Murillo become one of the elite strikeout pitchers of his generation.
Murillo’s stamina was merely average compared to most aces of his era. He held up remarkably well over a 21-year career and avoided the major arm injuries that ruin many pitchers, but he did miss sporadic starts mostly to back issues. Murillo was great at holding runners and was quite good defensively. He ended up as one of the continent’s most popular and successful pitchers of all time.
In September 1994, a scout from Buenos Aires convinced Murillo to sign a developmental deal to leave Colombia for Argentina. He spent three years in their academy before debuting in 1998 at age 20. Murillo was respectable over 153 innings that year, taking third in Rookie of the Year voting. He would become Buenos Aires’ ace for the next 14 years, posting 5+ WAR in each of those seasons.
From 2001-04, Murillo led the league each year in wins, peaking with a 24-7 mark in 2003. He also had his career best of 376 strikeouts in 2003 and also led in Ks for 2003 and 2006. Murillo couldn’t quite snag the top award at this point, finishing second in Pitcher of the Year voting in 2002, 2003, 2005, and 2006 with a third in 2005. He struck out 300+ batters each year during this run. 2006 was Murillo’s first time as the WARlord with a career-best 11.1.
The Atlantics were a regular contender in this era, earning five consecutive playoff berths from 1999-03. They also made it into the postseason in 2005 and 2007, but could never get over the hump. Buenos Aires lost in the Southern Cone League championship in 2000, 2002, and 2003. Their other berths all saw divisional series defeats. Murillo was surprisingly average in the postseason for BA with a 3.66 ERA over 76.1 innings, 3-5 record, 85 strikeouts, 99 ERA+, and 1.2 WAR.
Murillo did step up on the World Baseball Championship stage as a regular for his native Colombia from 1999-2016. He tossed 261.2 innings with a 22-8 record, 2.58 ERA, 376 strikeouts, 62 walks, 140 ERA+, and 9.1 WAR. Murillo led all pitchers with 60 strikeouts as Colombia lost to the United States in the 2010 World Championship. They also had a third place finish in 2006. As of 2037, Murillo leads all Colombians in the WBC in pitching WAR, wins, innings, and strikeouts. Among all nations, he ranks 19th in wins, 34th in strikeouts, and 25th in pitching WAR.
In July 2007, Murillo signed a six-year, $61,500,000 extension with Buenos Aires. The Atlantics started a decade-long playoff drought in 2008, hovering generally just below .500. Murillo continued to thrive though and won Pitcher of the Year thrice (2009, 2011, 2012). He led in strikeouts from 2009-11 and was the WARlord in both 2009 and 2011. 2012 saw Murillo’s low ERA title at 2.31, a career-best that he also hit the prior season. Towards the end of his BA run, Murillo reached the 250+ win and 4000+ strikeout thresholds.
The Atlantics weren’t competitive at this point and had one year left with Murillo under contract. With his 2012 ERA title, the 35-year old was still a hot property, so Buenos Aires traded him in the offseason to Brasilia in a four-player deal. They did get 3B Spinoza Arajo in the deal, who would be a 15-year starter, MVP winner, and Copa Sudamerica MVP winner for the Atlantics. Although BA made the right move, many were sad to see their long-time ace go.
For Buenos Aires, Murillo had a 253-124 record, 2.58 ERA, 3557.2 innings, 4388 strikeouts, 464 walks, 139 ERA+, and 107.8 WAR. His #13 uniform would be retired as soon as his pro career ended. Murillo led in strikeouts in his lone season for Brasilia, but saw a career worst 4.02 ERA. The Bearcats had been the LCS runner-up in 2012, but failed to get back to the playoffs in 2013.
Murillo was now a free agent for the first time and signed a three-year, $32,100,000 deal with Fortaleza, the defending Copa Sudamerica champ. He was done as an ace by this point and had seen his velocity drop from triple digits to the mid 90s. Recurring back injuries cost him starts each year for the Foxes, but he still provided positive value.
Fortaleza won the Southern Cone League in 2014, but couldn’t repeat as Copa Sudamerica winners in a rematch with Medellin. A herniated disc kept Murillo out for the playoffs. The Foxes lost in the first round of 2015 with Murillo allowing five runs in seven innings in his lone start. Fortaleza fell to below .500 in 2016, but Murillo that year became the seventh BSA pitcher to reach 5000 career strikeouts. In total for the Foxes, Murillo had a 28-25 record, 3.18 EREA, 467.2 innings, 387 strikeouts, 120 ERA+, and 10.4 WAR.
Now 39-years old, Murillo came home to Colombia on a three-year, $18,400,000 deal with Medellin. He kept up similar production with the Mutiny in two years as he had with Fortaleza. Murillo allowed four runs in 2017 in one playoff start as Medellin lost in the first round. They fell in the divisional series in 2018 with Murillo not getting used.
With the Mutiny, Murillo was able to reach 300 career wins, becoming only the fifth in BSA history to do so. He had a 26-20 record, 3.50 ERA, 396 innings, 299 strikeouts, 115 ERA+, and 9.2 WAR for Medellin. Murillo retired after the 2018 campaign at age 41.
Murillo finished with a 316-181 record, 2.79 ERA, 4658.2 innings, 5344 strikeouts, 605 walks, 439/610 quality starts, 117 complete games, 38 shutouts, 131 ERA+, 71 FIP-, and 132.3 WAR. As of 2037, Murillo ranks 4th in wins, 7th in strikeouts, 4th in innings pitched, 98th in complete games, 37th in shutouts, and 6th in pitching WAR. Among all BSA pitchers with 1000+ innings, his 0.97 WHIP is 66th.
By basically any measure, Murillo was considered the best pitcher of his era in Beisbol Sudamerica. Most rank him among BSA’s top ten pitchers, although he misses some top five lists as he wasn’t quite as otherworldly dominant as some of those just ahead of him on the leaderboards. Plus, Murillo’s playoff stats were underwhelming and he never had that defining postseason moment.
However, Murillo’s longevity helped earn him spot even on the world leaderboards. As of 2037 among all pitchers in baseball history, Murillo ranks 25th in wins, 23rd in strikeouts, 45th in innings, and 40th in pitching WAR. By WAR, Murillo is the best-ever player to come from Colombia and certainly has a case for being his country’s best-ever baseball product. Murillo was an easy headliner even in a loaded 2024 Hall of Fame class with a nearly unanimous 99.2%.
Comment