What Dynasty Idea Should I Do?

[MidnightClaw]

I'm going to do a Coaching Dynasty on NCAA Football '11 and I have everything ready to post, I just haven't found the time to post it. I might be able to tomorrow, but we'll see.

However, I also wanted to do another Dynasty on NCAA '11, but I had so many ideas and I know I can only handle two Dynasties at a time, so I want to know what this forum thinks I should do?

Idea #1: RTG/Superstar Dynasty - Pretty simple, I'll make a prospect and follow their career from their Senior high school playoffs to their retirement from the NFL. Start out in NCAA Football '11 and end in Madden '11. The character will most likely be a QB because I play it in real life.

Idea #2: TeamBuilder Dynasty - Also pretty simple, I'll make a team on TeamBuilder and put them in one of the mid-major conferences. I'll then proceed to make them into a National Championship contender and get them into one of the major conferences. The team will start a one star program. I'll also mix the conferences up a ton.

Idea #3: Turning a Team from a Mid-Major Conference into a NC Contender - Kinda like the TeamBuilder idea, but instead of a TeamBuilder team, it's a existing team. It'll be someone from a mid-major conference and I'll get them into a powerhouse program and into one of the BCS conference. Teams such as Boise State and TCU, despite being in a mid-major conference, is already a powerhouse program, so they aren't accepted. I'll also mix the conferences up a ton.

Also, alternative idea #4 will just combine ideas #2 and #3 together. Like how Deuce is doing with Boise State and Eastern Washington.

So what should I do?

[Thugger Jackson]

Re: What Dynasty Idea Should I Do?

BMS chise will be cool but now after i sent u that pm i realize they are simply too many roster holes too fill and that there is a lot of chises but not a lot of RTG's. so def RTG. can we choose stuff like where he get to college though?

[MidnightClaw]

Re: What Dynasty Idea Should I Do?

BMS chise will be cool but now after i sent u that pm i realize they are simply too many roster holes too fill and that there is a lot of chises but not a lot of RTG's. so def RTG. can we choose stuff like where he get to college though?

The BMS will be fun to do if we can figure out the roster. But with all the unknown players on the team, it might be impossible, but it would still be fun if we could figure out the roster.

Yes, if I did do the RTG idea, I'll get the community involved. I guess the community could be like the character's "family" of sorts, giving him advice and stuff. I was trying to find a way to get the forum involved and I think that might be the best way.

[PocketSizeSun]

Re: What Dynasty Idea Should I Do?

I've always been a fan of option 3. Someone like East Carolina, for example.

[Deuce2223]

Re: What Dynasty Idea Should I Do?

I voted #4, but that is just me. I wouldn't mind #1 either though. I am curious once your play signs with a school, is there a possibility that you could create a coach to take over that team as well, so that way you control future recruiting for your team as well?

[MidnightClaw]

Re: What Dynasty Idea Should I Do?

I voted #4, but that is just me. I wouldn't mind #1 either though. I am curious once your play signs with a school, is there a possibility that you could create a coach to take over that team as well, so that way you control future recruiting for your team as well?

I don't know if you can make or coach or not, but I highly doubt it since you can't even control other players. But I think it'll still be pretty cool dynasty, especially with the community involved.

I was thinking maybe trying to add idea #4 (which is ideas #2 and #3 together) with my coaching dynasty. That way I'll have all the elements to dynasty in one single dynasty, but I'm not sure about that one.

[footballfan4life]

Re: What Dynasty Idea Should I Do?

I definitely like #4 because nobody on here's wrote a good RTG, but you could do it.

[MidnightClaw]

Re: What Dynasty Idea Should I Do?

I decided to do a RTG Dynasty. However, my coaching dynasty will now become a Coaching and TeamBuilder Dynasty. Sorta like what Deuce is doing, but yet different at the same time.