Smart Trade?

[BabyBoi8587]

I'm in the third year of my Eagles franchise and I just traded T.O. for Roy Williams (Lions) and Charles Rogers) was this a smart trade? I'm thinkin it is because both are younger than T.O. and can only get better, Roy was a 87 when i got him but in week 12 he's a 92 now. Charles went up from 92 to 95. . . Also, i traded Correll Buckhalter and Reno Mahe for Greg Jones. . . .I added 10lbs to Jones and he's now my running back. Only reason I traded Correll was because i drafted my created running back from NCAA. He was a 99 in NCAA but when i drafted him, he's a 90. . .5'8-240lbs. . He's a MONSTER
Also i got Kellen Winslow w/ a 2nd round pick for Chad Lewis and a 2nd round pick. . .Are the Browns stupid!?!

[nkhera1]

Re: Smart Trade?

I'm in the third year of my Eagles franchise and I just traded T.O. for Roy Williams (Lions) and Charles Rogers) was this a smart trade? I'm thinkin it is because both are younger than T.O. and can only get better, Roy was a 87 when i got him but in week 12 he's a 92 now. Charles went up from 92 to 95. . . Also, i traded Correll Buckhalter and Reno Mahe for Greg Jones. . . .I added 10lbs to Jones and he's now my running back. Only reason I traded Correll was because i drafted my created running back from NCAA. He was a 99 in NCAA but when i drafted him, he's a 90. . .5'8-240lbs. . He's a MONSTER
Also i got Kellen Winslow w/ a 2nd round pick for Chad Lewis and a 2nd round pick. . .Are the Browns stupid!?!

to trade is really good, however i don't think the correll buckhalter and reno mahe for greg jones was a good trade, you could have gotten something better, but i'm not quite sure about madden's player ratings. Also i think the chad lewis trade was a good depending on how well kellen winslow progresses

[nkhera1]

Re: Smart Trade?

I'm in the third year of my Eagles franchise and I just traded T.O. for Roy Williams (Lions) and Charles Rogers) was this a smart trade? I'm thinkin it is because both are younger than T.O. and can only get better, Roy was a 87 when i got him but in week 12 he's a 92 now. Charles went up from 92 to 95. . . Also, i traded Correll Buckhalter and Reno Mahe for Greg Jones. . . .I added 10lbs to Jones and he's now my running back. Only reason I traded Correll was because i drafted my created running back from NCAA. He was a 99 in NCAA but when i drafted him, he's a 90. . .5'8-240lbs. . He's a MONSTER
Also i got Kellen Winslow w/ a 2nd round pick for Chad Lewis and a 2nd round pick. . .Are the Browns stupid!?!

to trade is really good, however i don't think the correll buckhalter and reno mahe for greg jones was a good trade, you could have gotten something better, but i'm not quite sure about madden's player ratings. Also i think the chad lewis trade was a good depending on how well kellen winslow progresses

[Staind_2020]

Re: Smart Trade?

I'm in the third year of my Eagles franchise and I just traded T.O. for Roy Williams (Lions) and Charles Rogers) was this a smart trade? I'm thinkin it is because both are younger than T.O. and can only get better, Roy was a 87 when i got him but in week 12 he's a 92 now. Charles went up from 92 to 95. . . Also, i traded Correll Buckhalter and Reno Mahe for Greg Jones. . . .I added 10lbs to Jones and he's now my running back. Only reason I traded Correll was because i drafted my created running back from NCAA. He was a 99 in NCAA but when i drafted him, he's a 90. . .5'8-240lbs. . He's a MONSTER
Also i got Kellen Winslow w/ a 2nd round pick for Chad Lewis and a 2nd round pick. . .Are the Browns stupid!?!

As fars as the TO deal goes if you were lookign to get younger at wide out then it was a good deal. I'm assuming that's what you wanted to do. As for Greg Jones who really knows because you might have been able to pick up something else but then again Jones maybe a sleeper in his later years.

On the Winslow front if he progresses well then it was a good trade for you. As far as weather the Browns would have done it or not I'd have to think no but it just depends on the deal they get I guess.

[Staind_2020]

Re: Smart Trade?

I'm in the third year of my Eagles franchise and I just traded T.O. for Roy Williams (Lions) and Charles Rogers) was this a smart trade? I'm thinkin it is because both are younger than T.O. and can only get better, Roy was a 87 when i got him but in week 12 he's a 92 now. Charles went up from 92 to 95. . . Also, i traded Correll Buckhalter and Reno Mahe for Greg Jones. . . .I added 10lbs to Jones and he's now my running back. Only reason I traded Correll was because i drafted my created running back from NCAA. He was a 99 in NCAA but when i drafted him, he's a 90. . .5'8-240lbs. . He's a MONSTER
Also i got Kellen Winslow w/ a 2nd round pick for Chad Lewis and a 2nd round pick. . .Are the Browns stupid!?!

As fars as the TO deal goes if you were lookign to get younger at wide out then it was a good deal. I'm assuming that's what you wanted to do. As for Greg Jones who really knows because you might have been able to pick up something else but then again Jones maybe a sleeper in his later years.

On the Winslow front if he progresses well then it was a good trade for you. As far as weather the Browns would have done it or not I'd have to think no but it just depends on the deal they get I guess.