By Scott Portman | January 5, 2025
PHILADELPHIA — In a season defined by frustration and futility, rookie wide receiver Malik Nabers was the lone, brilliant exception. While the New York Giants' 100th season culminated in a franchise-worst 3-14 record after a 20-13 loss to the Philadelphia Eagles, Nabers etched his name in the history books with a performance that felt both triumphant and tragic.
The rookie sensation was a beacon of hope on a gloomy day for Big Blue. In the fourth quarter, with the Giants trailing and the offense sputtering as it had for much of the year, he provided a glimpse of a brighter future. On a deep post route, Nabers created a step of separation against the Eagles' secondary, and quarterback Drew Lock, stepping up in a collapsing pocket, unleashed a perfect spiral. Nabers caught it in stride and raced into the end zone for a 45-yard touchdown, the team's only trip to the end zone. The catch was more than just six points; it was his 109th reception of the year, shattering the Giants' single-season franchise record of 107 set by Steve Smith in 2009.
Beyond that, Nabers also set a new NFL record for most receptions by a rookie wide receiver, surpassing the 105 catches Puka Nacua had for the Rams in 2023. It's a remarkable achievement in a pass-heavy league, placing him in rarefied air.
"It's a blessing, for sure, to have my name in the record books for this great franchise and for the league," Nabers said to reporters by his locker after the game, the box score sheet still in his hand. "But it's hard to celebrate. We're 3-14. I came here to win football games, not just to set records. This feeling in my stomach right now... this is what we have to remember so we never feel this way again."
That somber feeling permeated the entire organization. The loss marked their 12th consecutive road defeat in Philadelphia, a house of horrors for the Giants for over a decade. Worse, it finalized a season where they were swept by every single one of their NFC East rivals—the Eagles, Cowboys, and Commanders—for the first time in franchise history, a statistic that underscores the team's complete divisional collapse.
At the center of the storm is Head Coach Brian Daboll. After being lauded as the AP Coach of the Year for leading the team to a surprising playoff berth and a postseason victory just two seasons ago, he now holds the unenviable distinction of being the first Giants coach to ever lose 14 games in a single season. His overall record with the team fell to a disappointing 18-32-1.
"It starts with me. The performance today and the performance this season was not good enough, period," a somber Daboll stated at the post-game podium, his voice heavy. "We didn't coach well enough, we didn't play well enough, and the results are the results. From offense to defense to special teams, there wasn't a phase where we were consistent enough to win football games. Every aspect of our organization will be under evaluation, and that starts with me looking in the mirror. It's completely unacceptable for this organization and for our fans."
The mounting losses have led to a vocal portion of the fan base calling for a coaching change. The hashtag #FireDaboll was trending on social media before the final whistle even blew, with fans airing a season's worth of grievances about predictable play-calling and a lack of discipline. The disconnect between the 2022 success and the 2024 failure has left many wondering if the magic from that first season has simply run out.
While the season ended on a sour note, a small consolation prize emerged from the wreckage. With losses by the Browns and Titans and a win by the Patriots on the final Sunday, the Giants officially locked in the third overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. This gives General Manager Joe Schoen a prime opportunity to select a cornerstone player to help rebuild a roster in desperate need of elite talent, whether that be a franchise quarterback, a dominant pass rusher, or a foundational offensive lineman. The pressure to make the right choice will be immense.
"No one is happy with where we are," Giants co-owner John Mara is expected to say in his end-of-season press conference later this week. "To our fans, you deserve better than this. But I will say this: we have a foundational piece in Malik Nabers, and we will have a very high draft pick. It is on us to make the right decisions and get this team back to playing Giants football—a brand of football that is tough, smart, and fundamentally sound."
For now, the Giants head into a long offseason filled with more questions than answers. While Nabers' historic season provides a glimmer of hope for what could be, the stench of a 3-14 finish will linger as the front office faces critical decisions about the future of the coaching staff, the quarterback position, and the overall direction of a proud, but currently broken, franchise.
Comment