luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

[37]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

I was wondering this, too.

I really hope it doesnt....the game just isn't the same without his rosters.....and it's unfortunate if one random incident spoils everything goin forward

[buckeye02]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Mad props bro.

[redsfan4life]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Why does it matter who does what with the rosters? It's not like he said check out MY rosters that I did all by myself! He gave credit for a FREE service which is all he is required to do. Luv, you do great work but you really need to stop being so defensive about these rosters. I am not against you or anyone else in this thread, just calling it like I see it. This is a free service. He gets ton of praise from everyone on the board as is, I have no problem if he wants to wait to release v2 at a later date but it seems like he just doesn't want anyone stealing his "thunder". And that really shouldn't be the goal here. The goal should be providing gamers with the best rosters possible, if a few Georgia fans want to share there upgrades to your rosters they should be allowed. This should not influence your work at all. Just my two cents.

[Figment]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

I would like to say that I use your rosters every year and they are the most accurate I have ever come across. I will not even start a madden franchise until I get your rosters just so I have the best draft classes.

I just want to thank you for all the hard work and dedication that you put into this, I couldn't do it.

I have read a few posts and I would like to ask you to not let the words of a few ruin it for everyone.

Thanks

[jd@os]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Why does it matter who does what with the rosters? It's not like he said check out MY rosters that I did all by myself! He gave credit for a FREE service which is all he is required to do. Luv, you do great work but you really need to stop being so defensive about these rosters. I am not against you or anyone else in this thread, just calling it like I see it. This is a free service. He gets ton of praise from everyone on the board as is, I have no problem if he wants to wait to release v2 at a later date but it seems like he just doesn't want anyone stealing his "thunder". And that really shouldn't be the goal here. The goal should be providing gamers with the best rosters possible, if a few Georgia fans want to share there upgrades to your rosters they should be allowed. This should not influence your work at all. Just my two cents.

Go. Away.

If you want to exercise your free speech as you did in the quoted post above, please do so in the form of a private message to Luv--there is absolutely no need to post that in a thread.

Why does it matter who does what with the rosters? I'M NOT SAYING YOU DID THIS, but I shouldn't take Luv's roster, make some changes to the Tar Heels, and release the entire roster as all my own work. I'M NOT SAYING YOU DID THAT, but why shouldn't I do that? BECAUSE IT MATTERS WHAT PEOPLE DO WITH THE ROSTERS. Look at it this way: ever hear the disclaimer they give during a sporting event (Any rebroadcast....without the expressed written consent of the ___ is prohibited)? IT'S NOT THE EXACT SAME THING, but one thing I can't do is show a game I taped at my house and charge people to watch it; I'm just showing one example of how it matters what you do with a televised sporting event.

You say, "The goal should be providing gamers with the best rosters possible"; that's the very reason Luv welcomes your input as well as everyone else when it comes to providing suggestions. He's been working around the clock to provide these rosters, not only naming players but editing height, weight, appearance, and even some hometowns. It's not about someone "stealing his thunder", it's about paying the dude respect, and I have MAD respect for Luv and the work he does not for himself, but all of us.

If someone painted corn rows on the Mona Lisa and passed it off as his own work WITHOUT GIVING LEONARDO THE CREDIT, don't you think that would be a little messed up?

[luvtotha9s]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Why does it matter who does what with the rosters? It's not like he said check out MY rosters that I did all by myself! He gave credit for a FREE service which is all he is required to do. Luv, you do great work but you really need to stop being so defensive about these rosters. I am not against you or anyone else in this thread, just calling it like I see it. This is a free service. He gets ton of praise from everyone on the board as is, I have no problem if he wants to wait to release v2 at a later date but it seems like he just doesn't want anyone stealing his "thunder". And that really shouldn't be the goal here. The goal should be providing gamers with the best rosters possible, if a few Georgia fans want to share there upgrades to your rosters they should be allowed. This should not influence your work at all. Just my two cents.

dude...you are way off...you aren't even close....I'm not in this for thunder stealing or whatever junk you're talking.....I work hard on these rosters and never....never have appreciated someone using my rosters for a base....people expect everything in this world....but guess what?? I dont have to do rosters and you don't have to get them for free...capice?? So if someone wants to go against my wishes..when I asked very nicely....then thats how it is...you worry about yourself man.....I don't know you and I don't care for your opinion.....You obviously don't understand...I dont just put names in...I spend 10-15 hours a days customizing my roster...and to have someone slap a few changes and then offer them up to the community like some hero....I'll never like it...and that's my prerogative...I wasn't being defensive...just want to make it clear....it will never be cool with me when someone slaps a few edits on my rosters and then offers them up to the community.....Edit them up all you want for your own purposes, but all I ask is don't offer them up to the community...

[ATLsportsfan]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

I love the rosters and I appreciate all that you do to enhance the experience of playing NCAA football every single year. If I may offer some constructive suggestions though as far as player ratings go so that your rosters can be even more realistic. Some player ratings need to change. Notable players bolded below...

Your rated QBs: (according to Scout)
Mettenberger- LSU (#1 JC) 82 ovr
Driskel- UF (#1 QB) 81 ovr
Miller- OSU (#2) 80 ovr
Isham- LA Tech (NR) 78 ovr
Nebrich- UCONN (#72) 77 ovr
Brissett- UF (#9) 76 ovr
Watford- UVA (#77) 75 ovr
Keeton- USU (#64) 75 ovr
Ash- Texas (#21) 75 ovr
Jones- Maryland (NR) 75 ovr
Bridgewater- LOU (#6) 75 ovr
Smith- UK (NR) 75 ovr
Bercovici- ASU (#55) 75 ovr
Shreve- Utah (NR) 74 ovr
Wittek- USC (#11) 74 ovr
Kessler- USC (#12) 74 ovr
Worley- TENN (#38) 74 ovr
Shortell- MINN (#58) 74 ovr
Coker- FSU (#44) 74 ovr
Mariota- ORE (#34) 73 ovr
Thompson- OU (#36) 73 ovr
Williams- UNC (#16) 73 ovr
Cook- MSU (#82) 73 ovr
Stoudt- CLEM (#28) 73 ovr
Frazier- Auburn (#4) 72 ovr
Walsh- OSU (#5) 72 ovr
Cobbins- UK (#61) 72 ovr
Boehm- CAL (#17) 72 ovr
Eubank- ASU (#18) 72 ovr
Smith- WYO (#89) 71 ovr
Stave- WIS (#111) 71 ovr
Grady- VANDY (#50) 71 ovr
McEvoy- SC (NR) 71 ovr
Cato- MAR (#126) 71 ovr
Allen- ARK (#32) 71 ovr
Ely- BAMA (#41) 71 ovr

------
Hundley- UCLA (#3) 70 ovr
LeMay- UGA (#8) 70 ovr
Golson- ND (#15) 68 ovr
Coyne- CIN (#19) 68 ovr

------

Hogan- STAN (#13) not on roster
Randall- LSU (#14) not on roster

[ATLsportsfan]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Your rated RBs: (according to Scout)
Thomas- ORE (#1 ATH) 84 ovr
Crowell- UGA (#1) 84 ovr
Lane- TENN (#23) 82 ovr
Brown- TEX (#2) 80 ovr
Hart- BAMA (#8) 80 ovr
Buie- WVU (#49) 79 ovr
Bergeron- TEX (#3 FB) 79 ovr
Carson- SC (#24) 79 ovr
Agnew- OS (#129) 79 ovr
Green- NEB (#6) 79 ovr
Freeman- FSU (#9) 79 ovr
Bellamy- CLE (#7) 79 ovr
Huggins- RUT (#4) 78 ovr
Williams- OU (#3) 78 ovr
Wilder- FSU (#3 OLB) 78 ovr
Blakely- AUB (#10) 78 ovr
Langi- UTAH (#13) 77 ovr
Grooms- MIA (#16 DB) 77 ovr
Van- MAR (NR) 77 ovr
Poteat- CIN (#28) 77 ovr
Ward- OS (NR) 76 ovr
Mason- AUB (#29) 76 ovr
Heard- NEB (NR) 75 ovr
Gordon- WIS (#38) 74
Moore- SYR (NR) 74 ovr
Atkinson- ND (#30) 74 ovr
Knight- NEV (NR) 74 ovr


-------

Sims- OSU (#5) 72 ovr
Williams- TT (#12) 73 ovr
Hayes- MICH (#14) 72 ovr
Carlisle- USC (#15) 73 ovr
Marquez- TT (#16) 64 ovr


------
Lasco- CAL (#19) not on roster
Washington- TT (#26) not on roster

[Ncrowland]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Seems odd people keep comparing luvs rosters to LEGAL COPYWRITTEN items. I love his rosters and they are the best, but he's basically doing what EA can't and that's SELLING the likeness of players. I could understand if that uga fan started asking for donations, I would be upset. You have to realize the system that EA forces us to use for rosters, is set up for customization like that. To get mad because somebody cited your amateur work (legally; figuratively definitely professional work) and shared it with others has no merit. Now having said that, this game sucks with out his rosters so he basically has us at gunpoint.

[ATLsportsfan]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Your rated WRs: (according to Scout)
Watkins- CLEM (#5) 82 ovr
Williams- WASH (#2) 81 ovr
Farmer- USC (#3) 79 ovr
Lee- USC (#3 S) 79 ovr
Shipley- TEX (#6) 78 ovr
Cooks- OS (#67) 78 ovr
Landry- LSU (#4) 78 ovr
Peake- CLEM (#9) 78 ovr
Byrd- SC (#18) 77 ovr
Turner- NEB (#7) 77 ovr
Mitchell- UGA (#7 DB) 77 ovr
Blackmon- ORE (#20) 76 ovr
Spencer- OSU (#19) 76 ovr
Coxson- MYL (NR) 76 ovr
Bray- AUB (#18 RB) 76 ovr
Doe- WIS (#182) 75 ovr
Knowles- VT (#185) 75 ovr
Jennings- UVA (#43) 75 ovr
Sumler- ORE (#56) 75 ovr
Kelley- ORE (#137) 75 ovr
Jones- MINN (#168 DB) 75 ovr
Turner- LSU (#52 S) 75 ovr
Rogers- LOU (#55) 75 ovr

-----
Arnett- TENN (#8) 73 ovr
Greene- FSU (#10) 73 ovr
Belton- PSU (#11) 73 ovr
Benjamin- FSU (#12) 74 ovr
Shinn- BAMA (#17) 72 ovr

----
Brassell- MISS (#7) not on roster
Blackwell- USC (#13) not on roster

[billyo]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Hi all, am at work and do not have time to read the thread. Are these rosters on PSN and if so under what name. If not how do I get them?
Thanks in advance!

[PaperBoyx703]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Hi all, am at work and do not have time to read the thread. Are these rosters on PSN and if so under what name. If not how do I get them?
Thanks in advance!

Yes these are ps3 rosters and go to roster share and download type in luvtotha9s to get them.

[jd@os]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

Seems odd people keep comparing luvs rosters to LEGAL COPYWRITTEN items. I love his rosters and they are the best, but he's basically doing what EA can't and that's SELLING the likeness of players. I could understand if that uga fan started asking for donations, I would be upset. You have to realize the system that EA forces us to use for rosters, is set up for customization like that. To get mad because somebody cited your amateur work (legally; figuratively definitely professional work) and shared it with others has no merit. Now having said that, this game sucks with out his rosters so he basically has us at gunpoint.

But Luv didn't get mad--go back and read his posts. If UGA had numerous errors, all anyone has/had to do was post them and Luv would have taken care of them--that way EVERYONE would have received the UGA edits--not just the people who got the rosters from one guy who got them from Luv.

I think some people are missing the point here. What Luv doesn't care for is someone taking his roster as a base, making changes, AND MAKING THEM AVAILABLE TO THE COMMUNITY. What he probably wouldn't care about is if I downloaded his roster, made some changes to UNC, then told my neighbor, "Hey man--you want the player names? Here ya go; they're on my jump drive".

Again, there would have been no problem if someone had just posted UGA corrections. If you want to correct UGA or any other team, that's YOUR BUSINESS...just make sure that when you post them for the community, it's YOUR ROSTER.

I just thought of another way to put it. If you don't understand where Luv is coming from, look up the Superman II controversy over directors. It's not the same thing, but you'll get the idea. And by the way...it's an interesting story for those of you who think the Superman II that was released in theaters was the real Superman II.

[ATLsportsfan]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

TEs:
Lyerla- ORE (#4 OLB) 81
O'Leary- FSU (#3) 76
Owens- SC (#23) 75
Rome- UGA (#4) 75
McFarland- TEX (#21) 74
Hamilton- Iowa (#18) 74
Stevenson- OU (#11) 73
Vannett- OSU (#14) 73
Tukes- UCF (NR) 73
Fulse- AUB (#13) 73
Seferian Jenkins- WAS (#2) 72
Koyack- ND (#1) 72
MacLain- CLE (#9) 72
Amaro- TT (#5) 70
Leonard- UF (#6) 70

------

Uzomah- AUB (#8) 69
van Der Wal- VAN (#12) 61



------
Davis- ILL (#7) not on roster

[daUnpackfan]

Re: luvtotha9's 2011-2012 PS3 Rosters

rosters are amazing appreciate it you have Miami U lookin right easports need to quit makin it like this for you guys to fix it