Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • kehlis
    Moderator
    • Jul 2008
    • 27738

    #121
    Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

    Originally posted by SiNsinNatti
    Let's just enjoy this game. Ratings aren't going to stay the same anyway. They're all very capable athletes.

    Lol, I agree.

    People never listen to me but overall rating means absolutely nothing. Individual attributes is what matter and overall is merely cosmetic. Been saying that for years but I digress on that.


    I simply found it amusing that pro bowl appearances was brought up to prove a players merit. That's it.

    Comment

    • BreakingBad2013
      Pro
      • Aug 2013
      • 848

      #122
      Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

      Originally posted by kehlis
      What's Polamalu's rating?

      And no, I'm not missing your point. Even your last post mentioned all pro nominations. If you want to talk merit of players go for it, won't intervene because I don't know enough collectively about them to really give a great opinion.

      An initial argument was made that he's a perennial pro bowler, that's the only reason I even made a post (and geez I'm sorry I did). No reason to get so defensive about it all.
      Polly is tied with Kam Chancellor as the highest rated SS at a 94 or 93. He had 50 tackles 2 INTs, but 7 or 8 forced fumbles.
      Popularity outweighing production here.
      Official Scouting Tips!

      Comment

      • atom27
        Director of Fun and Games
        • Aug 2014
        • 60

        #123
        Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

        Originally posted by SiNsinNatti
        Let's just enjoy this game. Ratings aren't going to stay the same anyway. They're all very capable athletes.
        Truth.
        Hell, there will be a day 1 ratings update. Bet your house on it.

        You can always count on dozens of players having bust out years that no one expected. And their OVR and individuals will skyrocket.
        You could also say players are also going to "hit the wall" and ratings plummet.

        Look at Evan Mathis for the latter- a pedestrian OL until he got to Philly. His ratings have probably gone up *every* update.

        Comment

        • jerwoods
          MVP
          • Jan 2009
          • 2997

          #124
          Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

          Originally posted by atom27
          First post! Hi all.

          Getting back into Madden after a 5 year layoff, and came here to check out ratings and stuff. Seems like an awesome site you guys got here.

          A question: Looking at the rosters and ratings, there are 70+ guys on each roster! i know camp comes with cuts, but are *all of the cuts* going to end up in free agency? i seem to remember the free agency list being huge in '09- but not 500 guys huge! how large was the FA wire last year?
          no once the week 1 update is in it seems like about 300 players go missing but by jan about 250 are back on by the end of the season

          Comment

          • BreakingBad2013
            Pro
            • Aug 2013
            • 848

            #125
            Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

            Originally posted by atom27
            First post! Hi all.

            Getting back into Madden after a 5 year layoff, and came here to check out ratings and stuff. Seems like an awesome site you guys got here.

            A question: Looking at the rosters and ratings, there are 70+ guys on each roster! i know camp comes with cuts, but are *all of the cuts* going to end up in free agency? i seem to remember the free agency list being huge in '09- but not 500 guys huge! how large was the FA wire last year?
            There is a massive list until preseason is over, then they remove a bunch of guys from the game, forever.
            Official Scouting Tips!

            Comment

            • ggsimmonds
              Hall Of Fame
              • Jan 2009
              • 11235

              #126
              Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

              First, why does it matter what team someone is a fan of? This happens frequently. If we are discussing a player on the Giants what does it matter if the poster is a steeler fan or not? Homer logic is awesome.

              Which bings me to my next point: The NFC east appears to be the most homerific division.

              Comment

              • t_money25
                Rookie
                • Aug 2012
                • 9

                #127
                The one thing I think we can all agree on is Donny Moore is wayyyy in over his head with these ratings. The ratings should be done by a committee rather than by just one person. So many questionable ratings to begin the season I have serious doubts Donny will ever get it right smh.

                Comment

                • ggsimmonds
                  Hall Of Fame
                  • Jan 2009
                  • 11235

                  #128
                  Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

                  Originally posted by t_money25
                  The one thing I think we can all agree on is Donny Moore is wayyyy in over his head with these ratings. The ratings should be done by a committee rather than by just one person. So many questionable ratings to begin the season I have serious doubts Donny will ever get it right smh.
                  I don't think he does it by himself; I am pretty sure he has a team working under him. So the problem is not that Donny cannot do it by himself, the problem is the methodology.

                  Comment

                  • cokill
                    Rookie
                    • Jul 2009
                    • 50

                    #129
                    Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

                    Where's the spreadsheet?

                    Comment

                    • A_Quiet_Pro
                      Banned
                      • Feb 2013
                      • 2572

                      #130
                      Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

                      Originally posted by ggsimmonds
                      I don't think he does it by himself; I am pretty sure he has a team working under him. So the problem is not that Donny cannot do it by himself, the problem is the methodology.
                      Fair enough, but even so. Why can't they see the flaws in their methodology, and be wise enough to amend their practices to make a better game?

                      Comment

                      • Gman 18
                        MVP
                        • Jul 2012
                        • 2902

                        #131
                        Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

                        I am pretty sure that the marketing team forces Donny to increase popular players' ratings. I remember DCEBB2001 saying that he found that out a while back

                        Sent from my KFTHWI using Tapatalk
                        Hieroglyphics 3rd Eye Vision '98- You never knew

                        Comment

                        • A_Quiet_Pro
                          Banned
                          • Feb 2013
                          • 2572

                          #132
                          Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

                          Originally posted by Gman 18
                          I am pretty sure that the marketing team forces Donny to increase popular players' ratings.

                          Sent from my KFTHWI using Tapatalk
                          Well, players are popular because they're good; which they should get good ratings because of that. Even so, the methodology to the madness is flawed, and NEEDS to be fixed. BY MADDEN 16!

                          Comment

                          • ggsimmonds
                            Hall Of Fame
                            • Jan 2009
                            • 11235

                            #133
                            Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

                            Originally posted by A_Quiet_Pro
                            Fair enough, but even so. Why can't they see the flaws in their methodology, and be wise enough to amend their practices to make a better game?
                            Gman 18 answered it. We have seen in this thread what happens when Donny's ratings make certain fanbases unhappy. EA's marketing guys see it as bad press.

                            Comment

                            • ggsimmonds
                              Hall Of Fame
                              • Jan 2009
                              • 11235

                              #134
                              Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

                              Originally posted by A_Quiet_Pro
                              Well, players are popular because they're good; which they should get good ratings because of that. Even so, the methodology to the madness is flawed, and NEEDS to be fixed. BY MADDEN 16!
                              Or because they have been good in the past.

                              Let us not forget the fans voted Peyton Hillis to be the cover guy once.

                              Comment

                              • Gman 18
                                MVP
                                • Jul 2012
                                • 2902

                                #135
                                Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

                                Originally posted by ggsimmonds
                                Gman 18 answered it. We have seen in this thread what happens when Donny's ratings make certain fanbases unhappy. EA's marketing guys see it as bad press.
                                If only Donny rated players like DCEBB, then the game would play a lot better and we would see more and better looking animations but of course most casual fans would complain

                                Sent from my KFTHWI using Tapatalk
                                Hieroglyphics 3rd Eye Vision '98- You never knew

                                Comment

                                Working...