3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • RicoLaguna
    Rookie
    • Jul 2003
    • 349

    #1

    3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

    So I am writing this in the hopes that we can constructively call out some improvements that EA may recognize, take note of, and hopefully make adjustments as these 3 things all indirectly impact the user gameplay immersion and experience on the field in different ways....yet I dont actually think they are actually "gameplay tweaks"

    1- USER CUSTOMIZABLE CAMS
    Why do we need them?
    Over the last several versions of Madden, being limited to the same set of predefined CAMS has made each Madden feel far to similar. Every modern day sports game I can think of today offers multiple preset CAMs to select and many slider realated adjustments to also customize your own. Maddens own replays can be adjusted to infinite CAMS and seem to replay fine with no lag or CPU limitations....so the tech is there and it can be done!

    What benefit will it provide?
    It gives the users customization options to make the game feel fresh and new and also allow more choice which is always a great thing! I would personaly set a CAM to a more FIFA/Tecm Bowl like Zoomed out view to capture more of the downdfield action


    2- GAME SPEED SLIDER
    Why do we need them?
    Not everyone wants to play the game at a NFL simulated speed, nor can some people keep up with that arcade-like reaction reflex requirement. Some people prefer a more strategic approach in which they feel like they have more time to make adjustments that will make an impact in the game....especially in single player matches

    What benefit will it provide?
    Again it just gives the users more choices and customization on how they prefer to play the game. Also on slower speeds, many of the jerky and inconsistent player movements and transistions seem to feel more smoothed out and natural (at least this is my experience from older versions)


    3-SILENT/MISSING ON FIELD SOUND FX
    Why do we need them?
    For some reason since EA went to this 3D immersive sound technology over the last several Maddens, the on field sounds from zoomed in CAM seem to gradually disappear the further CAM back you select. This year it seems worse then ever. In theory this makes sense as the tech is working to capture the sounds closer to the CAM but that doesnt mean its a better experience! Who wants to be playing in broadcast CAM and not hear the whiz of an Aaron Rodgers rope, or a soft slap of a hands on ball reception, the grunts and groans in the trenches, the stinging crack of a helmet to helmet hit, or pads on pads stick!.....These are all the wonderful sounds of football and they are so perfectly captured in PRACTICE MODE! They should be user adjustable to give you that same immersive feeling

    What benefit will it provide?
    For all the obvious reasons I pointed out above


    Since I am so grumpy today with this wonderful game, I will add a bonus feature that I have also asked for many times.

    GLOBAL RATING SLIDER ADJUSTER

    For those of us that like to further tailor gameplay to our own liking, a Global RATINGS Slider for each the players ratings should be added so we can easily go into a roster and make sweeping changes as we see fit. Not happy with how every Safety closes down on a reciever....no problem. Go into a Global Slider adjustment page, Filter by all safeties and adjust their PLAY RECOGNITION...or whatever slider would fix that. You get the point

    Not happy with all QBs Medium Throw Accuracy?.....go into the global slider and slide the Medium Throw Accuracy!

    Why not add this?.....Please folks, let me know your thoughts. Im trying to make a game that has started to feel SAME OLD SAME OLD over the years a little fresher experience....and non of these tweaks/features I feel would completely require any major overhauls
  • RicoLaguna
    Rookie
    • Jul 2003
    • 349

    #2
    Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

    wow....I thought at least some of you would be interested in some of this?.....guess not

    Comment

    • oneamongthefence
      Nothing to see here folks
      • Apr 2009
      • 5683

      #3
      Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

      We really need menu optimizations.

      Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk
      Because I live in van down by the river...

      Comment

      • King Gro23
        MVP
        • Jan 2008
        • 2548

        #4
        Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

        The ability to edit player tags

        A quick edit and global roster editor

        And speed up menu UI


        Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
        Catch Madden 15/ NBA 2k15 Footage on my Twitch Channel
        TopShotGwaup15
        http://www.twitch.tv/topshotgwaup15

        Suscribe on Youtube
        https://www.youtube.com/user/GleezyBaby43
        Gleezybaby43

        Comment

        • bkrich83
          Has Been
          • Jul 2002
          • 71574

          #5
          Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

          Originally posted by oneamongthefence
          We really need menu optimizations.

          Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk
          JFC yes! The menu lag is absolutely ridiculous.
          Tracking my NCAA Coach Career

          Comment

          • RicoLaguna
            Rookie
            • Jul 2003
            • 349

            #6
            Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

            was any of this addressed in the patch discussions?

            Comment

            • Detroit Tigers
              MVP
              • Mar 2018
              • 1375

              #7
              Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

              Originally posted by RicoLaguna
              was any of this addressed in the patch discussions?
              The audio stuff is supposedly being addressed.
              Just one man’s opinion.
              I don’t actually care about any of this.

              Comment

              • RicoLaguna
                Rookie
                • Jul 2003
                • 349

                #8
                Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

                was the audio tackle fx fixed??....on all madden 22 and coach viw.....are still littered with silent tackles

                Comment

                • blackhawksfan4ever19
                  MVP
                  • May 2017
                  • 1557

                  #9
                  Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

                  Originally posted by RicoLaguna
                  So I am writing this in the hopes that we can constructively call out some improvements that EA may recognize, take note of, and hopefully make adjustments as these 3 things all indirectly impact the user gameplay immersion and experience on the field in different ways....yet I dont actually think they are actually "gameplay tweaks"

                  1- USER CUSTOMIZABLE CAMS
                  Why do we need them?
                  Over the last several versions of Madden, being limited to the same set of predefined CAMS has made each Madden feel far to similar. Every modern day sports game I can think of today offers multiple preset CAMs to select and many slider realated adjustments to also customize your own. Maddens own replays can be adjusted to infinite CAMS and seem to replay fine with no lag or CPU limitations....so the tech is there and it can be done!

                  What benefit will it provide?
                  It gives the users customization options to make the game feel fresh and new and also allow more choice which is always a great thing! I would personaly set a CAM to a more FIFA/Tecm Bowl like Zoomed out view to capture more of the downdfield action


                  2- GAME SPEED SLIDER
                  Why do we need them?
                  Not everyone wants to play the game at a NFL simulated speed, nor can some people keep up with that arcade-like reaction reflex requirement. Some people prefer a more strategic approach in which they feel like they have more time to make adjustments that will make an impact in the game....especially in single player matches

                  What benefit will it provide?
                  Again it just gives the users more choices and customization on how they prefer to play the game. Also on slower speeds, many of the jerky and inconsistent player movements and transistions seem to feel more smoothed out and natural (at least this is my experience from older versions)


                  3-SILENT/MISSING ON FIELD SOUND FX
                  Why do we need them?
                  For some reason since EA went to this 3D immersive sound technology over the last several Maddens, the on field sounds from zoomed in CAM seem to gradually disappear the further CAM back you select. This year it seems worse then ever. In theory this makes sense as the tech is working to capture the sounds closer to the CAM but that doesnt mean its a better experience! Who wants to be playing in broadcast CAM and not hear the whiz of an Aaron Rodgers rope, or a soft slap of a hands on ball reception, the grunts and groans in the trenches, the stinging crack of a helmet to helmet hit, or pads on pads stick!.....These are all the wonderful sounds of football and they are so perfectly captured in PRACTICE MODE! They should be user adjustable to give you that same immersive feeling

                  What benefit will it provide?
                  For all the obvious reasons I pointed out above


                  Since I am so grumpy today with this wonderful game, I will add a bonus feature that I have also asked for many times.

                  GLOBAL RATING SLIDER ADJUSTER

                  For those of us that like to further tailor gameplay to our own liking, a Global RATINGS Slider for each the players ratings should be added so we can easily go into a roster and make sweeping changes as we see fit. Not happy with how every Safety closes down on a reciever....no problem. Go into a Global Slider adjustment page, Filter by all safeties and adjust their PLAY RECOGNITION...or whatever slider would fix that. You get the point

                  Not happy with all QBs Medium Throw Accuracy?.....go into the global slider and slide the Medium Throw Accuracy!

                  Why not add this?.....Please folks, let me know your thoughts. Im trying to make a game that has started to feel SAME OLD SAME OLD over the years a little fresher experience....and non of these tweaks/features I feel would completely require any major overhauls
                  I agree 100% with them all especially the SPEED of the game, As an "ahem...OLDER" player (we wont say HOW old) I would love to slow down the action a little.
                  I am the way
                  I am the light
                  I am the dark inside the night.
                  I hear your hopes
                  I feel your dreams
                  And in the dark I hear your screams
                  Don't turn away, Just take my hand
                  I'll never leave, All I ask of you, Is Believe.

                  Believe

                  Savatage - RIP Chris Oliva - April 3, 1963 – October 17, 1993

                  Comment

                  • Armor and Sword
                    The Lama
                    • Sep 2010
                    • 21781

                    #10
                    Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

                    Originally posted by RicoLaguna
                    wow....I thought at least some of you would be interested in some of this?.....guess not


                    I love all your suggestions.

                    The more customization the better.

                    The Show and NBA 2K are great at that.

                    Madden can get better.

                    I love 24.

                    This is great stuff for 25 hopefully.

                    And NCAA 24


                    Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
                    Now Playing on PS5:
                    CFB 26 Hurricanes/Fresno State Year 2
                    MLB The Show 25 - 2025 Yankees Year 1
                    MLB The Show 25 1985 Yankees Year 1
                    Oblivion Remaster



                    Follow me on Twitch
                    https://www.twitch.tv/armorandsword

                    Comment

                    • kingsofthevalley
                      MVP
                      • May 2011
                      • 1958

                      #11
                      Re: 3 NON GAMEPLAY specific FIXES that will Improve Madden Gameplay Experience

                      The franchise editor for the PC version is priceless.

                      Comment

                      Working...