Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

[ggsimmonds]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

Nice work EA!! Brice Butler has been making big noise for the Raiders since OTA's and has even been getting 1st team reps, but since he was drafted in the 7th round, I guess he deserves his 59 ovr. Nice work there.... I am soooooooo thankful for Madden share this year.

Gotta disagree with you and side with Donny Moore on this one. Until guys prove it when it counts they should not get the benefit of the doubt. Also check his actual ratings. His skillset may be decent but low awareness may be keeping him down.

Edit: Anyone wanna be a good e-samaritan and look up Flacco's throwing power?

[DeuceDouglas]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

That's why I first ASKED when was the last time he played? I'm seeing he played only 11 games. You sure he played in the playoffs? He did not play against Houston and I know he didn't play against us, yet my statement has no merit. Maybe Peyton Manning treatment would be too extreme.

He did play against Houston in the playoffs where he re-broke his arm.

Nice work EA!! Brice Butler has been making big noise for the Raiders since OTA's and has even been getting 1st team reps, but since he was drafted in the 7th round, I guess he deserves his 59 ovr. Nice work there.... I am soooooooo thankful for Madden share this year.

I remember last year during Chiefs camp and OTA's, Jon Baldwin was the talk of the town. Everyday there was a new story about how great Jon Baldwin was doing and was going to be last year. This catch:



had people thinking he was the second coming of Randy Moss. 20 catches and a 2-14 season later and you're probably still asking yourself 'Who the hell is Jon Baldwin?'.

[MitchDaCr3ator]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

My best guess is that they simply forgot to put in acceleration in the PowerPoint. I say this because during LeSean McCoy's rating reveal on Twitter they said he had 98 acceleration and Adrian Peterson had 99.

[CarryTheWeight]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

Opinions from a Biased Bills Fan:

As expected, Marquise Goodwin has some insane top-end speed and agility. I also see his Kick Return rating skyrocketing in the first roster update based on his preseason performance against the Colts. Only thing I disagree with is his Jump rating...dude was the best performer at the US Olympic Trials and could have won Gold in London had he repeated those numbers!

EJ Manuel rated one OVR point higher than G. Smith, and like Geno has lower awareness but great physical tools. Greater than expected speed rating for him as well, but lower than expected accuracy. Still looking forward to start the season with him! Hopefully Doug Marrone feels the same way... :P

Glad to see CJ Spiller, Stevie Johnson and even Scott Chandler getting some love. Robert Woods (70 OVR) is a bit lower than expected, but even he has some good physical tools. Should be a high-potential receiving corps.

[NDAlum]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

More of why I simply hate the awareness rating boost. Make it just not count into the overall ratings or something.

They just try to lower down the ratings of certain guys by dropping AWR...I hate it

[brettmickey]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

Opinions from a Biased Bills Fan:

As expected, Marquise Goodwin has some insane top-end speed and agility. I also see his Kick Return rating skyrocketing in the first roster update based on his preseason performance against the Colts. Only thing I disagree with is his Jump rating...dude was the best performer at the US Olympic Trials and could have won Gold in London had he repeated those numbers!

EJ Manuel rated one OVR point higher than G. Smith, and like Geno has lower awareness but great physical tools. Greater than expected speed rating for him as well, but lower than expected accuracy. Still looking forward to start the season with him! Hopefully Doug Marrone feels the same way... :P

Glad to see CJ Spiller, Stevie Johnson and even Scott Chandler getting some love. Robert Woods (70 OVR) is a bit lower than expected, but even he has some good physical tools. Should be a high-potential receiving corps.

I agree with all of your assessments. Did you notice that Mario Williams somehow found his way on to the spreadsheet?? 92 overall... One thing that stuck out to me was Stevie's 85 speed. If I remember correctly it was an 89 speed before. I know he isn't the fastest receiver around but I don't know what he did in between the end of the season and now to lose 4 points there...

[splff3000]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

Gotta disagree with you and side with Donny Moore on this one. Until guys prove it when it counts they should not get the benefit of the doubt. Also check his actual ratings. His skillset may be decent but low awareness may be keeping him down.

I would agree with you if that was the case with all rookies, but that's not how he does it. With just a tad bit of research, the rosters could be significantly better. For instance, he has our 4th round pick, Tyler Wilson, QB skills rated about even or even slightly better than our starter, Matt Flynn. If he would have read any kind of article or seen any kind of update about the Raiders training camp, he would know that Flynn has been just short of spectacular and that Wilson has been stinking up the joint. In fact, Wilson might not even make the team. He's the 4th string QB right now and there's a big gap between him and the 3rd string QB. By that same premise, he would know that Brice Butler has been tearing it up. He doesn't look tho. He recognizes Tyler Wilson's name from college so he makes him decent without looking at what's happening NOW. On the flipside, he doesn't recognize Brice Butler's name and he was a 7th round pick so he makes him rated very low without looking at what's happening NOW. I didn't expect him to be rated in the 80's or anything, but I did think he would at least be in the mid 60's. He definitely has more of a shot to make the team than those other WR's that are rated in the 60's on our team.

I remember last year during Chiefs camp and OTA's, Jon Baldwin was the talk of the town. Everyday there was a new story about how great Jon Baldwin was doing and was going to be last year. This catch:



had people thinking he was the second coming of Randy Moss. 20 catches and a 2-14 season later and you're probably still asking yourself 'Who the hell is Jon Baldwin?'.

I remember that too. In fact, I was ready to draft him in my fantasy league as a sleeper(Glad I didn't tho lol). This just kinda proves my point tho. Baldwin had a horrible year, yet he's still rated a 73 ovr. I'm assuming because he was a 1st round pick. At this point tho, what round he was picked in should have nothing to do with ratings, but it obviously does because anyone else with just 20 catches is gonna be rated much lower than a 73. Once again, if he kept up with what's happening in training camp, he'd know that Baldwin hasn't made any noise in camp this year and that whispers of bust are starting to come up. He'd know that 73 is probably too high for him right now.

[Wildcats302]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

Titans fans or anyone. Did I miss something or where is Kendall Wright on the Titan's roster? He was not on the excel sheet I pulled up. I am sure it is just a mistake though as surely they did not somehow leave him off our roster, just our 1st round pick from last year who had a pretty decent to good rookie campaign.

[TRchamp12]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

Titans fans or anyone. Did I miss something or where is Kendall Wright on the Titan's roster? He was not on the excel sheet I pulled up. I am sure it is just a mistake though as surely they did not somehow leave him off our roster, just our 1st round pick from last year who had a pretty decent to good rookie campaign.

he's there... all the way on the bottom

[SA1NT401]

Ratings ... Smatings.... Aside from the big 5.... No others mean anything anyway.

If we can do custom rosters to take into COM.... I'll be dropping EVERYONE by 8-10 PTA anyway. At least then they do feel a bit different and not just carbon copies of each other with different numbers.

Soooo many missing players on just about EVERY team. What a for crap roster to start with.

[eds133]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

Looking at wr and hb's..there a lot of them with 95+ agility ratings...I hope that doesn't mean that they all will feel the same with their cuts.

[dat boi Q]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

Looking at wr and hb's..there a lot of them with 95+ agility ratings...I hope that doesn't mean that they all will feel the same with their cuts.

Agility is important when making those cuts. Not surprised that they made most wrs and Hbs with high agility. Most of those players don't make sharp cuts in real life. Watch a guy lesean McCoy. He make people look silly with his agility. Not to many players can do that. But on madden they can.

[rvernet]

This list is messed up. Looking at the Eagles, there are only 3 rookies. Where are the rest? Where is Earl Wolff the safety?

[gr18]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

This list is messed up. Looking at the Eagles, there are only 3 rookies. Where are the rest? Where is Earl Wolff the safety?

This is a list of offensive players only.

[czech59]

Re: Madden NFL 25 Ratings For Every Offensive Player

I'm pretty sure that the ratings released were just their guess on who would make the (extended) roster considering there are surely a limited number of roster positions. Some of the ratings are also inconsistent with overalls that were revealed on this nfl dot com article:

Edit: Since I just signed up I can't post the link but if you google "madden 25 ratings" it's one of the top results.

The excel sheet must have been the initial "working" roster which will surely already have an update available when the game is released, one such example is every receiver in the Patriots' training camp is in the game besides one of the ones who is going to make the roster - Kenbrell Thompkins.