Official Trade Talk Thread

[IlliniM1ke]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

Does this sound like a fair trade..

I give up
WR Calvin Johnson
RB Michael Bush

For

WR A.J. Green
RB Mikel Leshoure

I Would be the one proposing the trade. Do you guys think it will be a smart move? I think Leshoure's gonna be a stud and Green is constantly putting up numbers. My other WRs are Dez Bryant, Kenny Britt, Laurent Robinson, and Randy Moss. He's already got Doug Martin, Marshawn Lynch, and Green-Ellis so I don't think he'll mind giving up Leshoure. So I need some advice. Should I try this or not?

Hard to say, Megatron is the best WR in the game and while Bush's touches will drop once Forte is back he'll still get touches and goalline carries.

Green is a great WR as well but Leshoure has only done it in one game so far, giving up Megatron for Green is all about how comfortable you are with Green. I like Leshoure and think he'll do well but not sure I'd part with Megatron to get him.

He isn't as consistent as Megatron and I personally wouldn't do it although I am high on Green and have him in 2 of my leagues.

Whats the rest of your team look like actually?

[Mo]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

Benson, McFadden, AP, BJGE, Turner

Marshall, Miles Austin, Amendola, Randy Moss

So I traded Benson for Chris Johnson.

Grades?

[redsrule]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

So I traded Benson for Chris Johnson.

Grades?

Big upside for you. Chris Johnson could come out of his funk and produce again, but then again he could keep blowing.

[DerkontheOS]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

I have Eli starting, but I have been thinking about going after Matt Ryan as he is on a guys bench right now. What do you think the price would be for him?

My Line up

QB Eli Manning
RB Maurice Jones Drew
RB Ryan Matthews
WR Larry Fitzgerald
WR Julio Jones
TE Jimmy Graham
FLEX Brandon Marshall
D/ST Jets
K Greg Zuerlein

Bench
Demarco Murray
Michael Vick
Jermichael Finely
Jeremy Maclin
Torrey Smith
Brandon Lafell
Danny Amendola

His Line up
QB Drew Brees
RB Frank Gore
RB Doug Martin
WR Victor Cruz
WR Vincent Jackson
TE Rob Gronkowski
FLEX Dwayne Bowe
D/ST Colts
K Garret Hartley

Bench
Mike Wallace
Trent Richardson
Ravens D/ST
Fred Davis
Jonathan Stewart
Matt Ryan
Kevin Smith

[IlliniM1ke]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

You shouldn't be able to get Lynch either, but if they guy will go for it, that's a good deal.

I would still try to trade him if you get LeShoure (which I doubt you will).

Coworker went for the Welker/Bradshaw for Lynch deal, he needed WR help (was starting Randall Cobb) and as long as Bradshaw was looking like he'll be back this week he was all over it, talking to him he doesn't like Lynch because of his off field stuff lol well I have no problems accepting a guy with off field baggage onto my team!

So I traded Benson for Chris Johnson.

Grades?

I have CJ on my team and I'm hoping to drop him, I'm 4th on waivers and hoping to land either LeShoure or Mendenhall to replace him. He looks awful and I don't see it getting better for him anytime soon.

That said if he isn't going to be counted on to start for you that's a pretty low risk high reward deal if he can get things going, if he'll be starting for you much though I think you lost out. Benson is at least producing a little, CJ is just atrocious right now.

[dsan88]

Hard to say, Megatron is the best WR in the game and while Bush's touches will drop once Forte is back he'll still get touches and goalline carries.

Green is a great WR as well but Leshoure has only done it in one game so far, giving up Megatron for Green is all about how comfortable you are with Green. I like Leshoure and think he'll do well but not sure I'd part with Megatron to get him.

He isn't as consistent as Megatron and I personally wouldn't do it although I am high on Green and have him in 2 of my leagues.

Whats the rest of your team look like actually?

My Team

QB Tony Romo
QB Alex Smith
RB Andre Brown
RB Alfred Morris
RB Shonn Greene
RB Donald Brown
RB Michael Bush
WR Calvin Johnson
WR Dez Bryant
WR Kenny Britt
WR Randy Moss
WR Laurent Robinson
TE Dennis Pitta
TE Greg Olsen
DEF Lions
K Adam Viniateri

[Candyman5]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

Got offered 2 trades:



or




My Team:




His Team:

Ok he sent me another trade:



Since he is so determined to try to get Torrey Smith or Alfred Morris from me I was trying to come up with a trade for him. I would prefer to get a good running back from him. Either Stephen Jackson or Trent Richardson. Ryam Mathews has not looked good to me so far and trading for Pierre Thomas would be stupid since I got Sproles already.

How ever I am stuck at this part in my thinking. I just dont know what to offer.

Any help, tips and or suggestions would be appreciated.

[rangerrick012]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

Someone in my lg just put Cam Newton on the block. What should I offer to try to get him? As you can see I need help as Vick and Cutler have failed me so far.



And his roster...

[DerkontheOS]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

Should I trade Heath Miler for Reggie Bush or Marshawn Lynch?

Heath is my back up TE.

[IlliniM1ke]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

My Team

QB Tony Romo
QB Alex Smith
RB Andre Brown
RB Alfred Morris
RB Shonn Greene
RB Donald Brown
RB Michael Bush
WR Calvin Johnson
WR Dez Bryant
WR Kenny Britt
WR Randy Moss
WR Laurent Robinson
TE Dennis Pitta
TE Greg Olsen
DEF Lions
K Adam Viniateri

Yeah I'm pretty torn on that one to be honest, LeShoure if he is the real deal will be a pretty big piece for you and I do think he will be effective, AJ is still a top WR.

I really don't know though, giving up Megatron is a bitter pill to swallow, I'd see if some more people chime in here I don't feel confident enough to give you an answer one way or another on that one.

[IlliniM1ke]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

Should I trade Heath Miler for Reggie Bush or Marshawn Lynch?

Heath is my back up TE.

If you can do it absolutely, your backup TE is probably going to start 1 game for you if not for an injury so if you can get Lynch or Bush for him I wouldn't hesitate.

You can find a bye week option at TE when the time comes.

[DerkontheOS]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

If you can do it absolutely, your backup TE is probably going to start 1 game for you if not for an injury so if you can get Lynch or Bush for him I wouldn't hesitate.

You can find a bye week option at TE when the time comes.

Should I get Bush? Lynch? Maybe try for Spiller?

I have a monoply of TEs

Jimmy Graham (Draft)
Jermichael Finely (Draft)
Heath Miller (FA)

and there are a majority of teams with sub par starting TEs.

[wwharton]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

I have Eli starting, but I have been thinking about going after Matt Ryan as he is on a guys bench right now. What do you think the price would be for him?

My Line up

QB Eli Manning
RB Maurice Jones Drew
RB Ryan Matthews
WR Larry Fitzgerald
WR Julio Jones
TE Jimmy Graham
FLEX Brandon Marshall
D/ST Jets
K Greg Zuerlein

Bench
Demarco Murray
Michael Vick
Jermichael Finely
Jeremy Maclin
Torrey Smith
Brandon Lafell
Danny Amendola

His Line up
QB Drew Brees
RB Frank Gore
RB Doug Martin
WR Victor Cruz
WR Vincent Jackson
TE Rob Gronkowski
FLEX Dwayne Bowe
D/ST Colts
K Garret Hartley

Bench
Mike Wallace
Trent Richardson
Ravens D/ST
Fred Davis
Jonathan Stewart
Matt Ryan
Kevin Smith

You'll be including Manning or Vick so it shouldn't have to be anything crazy. Then again, he's trading for a back up QB so he may not be willing to give equal value for a good QB coming back. May need to include Maclin or Smith (or Amendola if it's a PPR).

Ok he sent me another trade:



Since he is so determined to try to get Torrey Smith or Alfred Morris from me I was trying to come up with a trade for him. I would prefer to get a good running back from him. Either Stephen Jackson or Trent Richardson. Ryam Mathews has not looked good to me so far and trading for Pierre Thomas would be stupid since I got Sproles already.

How ever I am stuck at this part in my thinking. I just dont know what to offer.

Any help, tips and or suggestions would be appreciated.

He's trying to give you garbage. If he wants either of them that bad he'll send you something worth your while. Pierre Thomas is not. I'd tell him you don't want to talk unless he's including a better RB. With that said, no reason you should shy away from Mathews. That would be a great deal for you.

[wwharton]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

Should I get Bush? Lynch? Maybe try for Spiller?

I have a monoply of TEs

Jimmy Graham (Draft)
Jermichael Finely (Draft)
Heath Miller (FA)

and there are a majority of teams with sub par starting TEs.

They're TEs. if you can get somebody to trade you a top RB for a TE more power to you but good luck with that unless you're willing to give up Graham.

[Mo]

Re: Official Trade Talk Thread

Benson, McFadden, AP, BJGE, Turner

Marshall, Miles Austin, Amendola, Randy Moss

Same league- IDP, PPR league,

I get gronk, pp7 and S-Jax. I give up VD85, AP and laron landry.


I want to counter by replacing S-jax with torrey smith or should I stick with this deal?