Franchise CPU GM AI needs work

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Nickflyers
    MVP
    • Oct 2008
    • 1858

    #1

    Franchise CPU GM AI needs work

    There needs to be a bit of an overhaul or adjustment to the CPU GMs' AI. The AI can't seem to grasp planning and prioritizing players to build a complete roster that can compete.

    I'm in Year Three(2018-19) of a Franchise and I'm noticing teams making unnecessary signings and decisions.

    Big example of this is the San Jose Sharks who let an 89 Overall Martin Jones walk(Who signed with Nashville, who has an 89 Pekka Rinne still, but more on that later) and did not sign a legit NHL goaltender. They are currently going into Year three with three goalies ALL UNDER 70 OVERALL. Now it's not because there is a lack of goalies in FA or through Trades, but they have put themselves right up at the cap limit. and here's how based on what I've seen.

    At the 2018 Draft they traded peanuts away for Jason Spezza(86ovr and a $7.5M contract)(Who is now currently on the Block at Season Opening). Ok cool they acquired a solid center. Only problem is they have Logan Couture(88), Tomas Hertl(85), Melker Karlsson(84), Mike Ribeiro($4M contract), Chris Tierney(83), AND Daniel O'Regan(81) at center. LW is set as is RW(well 5 players over 82) along with 9 Defenseman above 81. So they went after Spezza for no reason and it cost them Martin Jones(who signed for $7.275M). And easy trade to make just looking at the trade values is trading Jeremy Roy(Who's upset, has a lot of value and is lost in the depth chart) to a team like Tampa Bay for Vaselevski(Who's stuck behind Bishop)

    So they are in a bind now but there are plenty of options, but the AI refuses to make any trades(All throughout the NHL). Teams are hoarding players at the expense of other positions in DIRE NEED. Detroit and the Rangers have four goalies over 80, Winnipeg, Toronto, Dallas, Hartford(Carolina), Islanders, Seattle(ARZ), St. Louis, and Tampa Bay all have three goalies over 80 overall. There are plenty of options for a team like San Jose to make a trade.

    CPU appears to not utilize the buyout option when it could be extremely useful and almost 95% of the teams stay right up on the cap limit.

    I don't understand programing, nor will I ever, but there needs to be a bit of an adjustment to the AI of the General Managers so they field the best teams they can.
    Twitter

    Twitch


    YouTube Channel
  • Jatt96
    Rookie
    • Oct 2016
    • 260

    #2
    Re: Franchise CPU GM AI needs work

    The dual goalie signings really tick me off. Why would Nashville get two #1s. I understand if a franchise developed two #1s at the same time, that happens in real life but there's no logic in signing Rask if you already have Crawford.

    Comment

    • actionhank
      MVP
      • Jan 2010
      • 1530

      #3
      Re: Franchise CPU GM AI needs work

      Trade and GM AI in general needs some work.

      You notice it all the time around the trade deadline. It's such a boring day, because basement teams aren't trying to move their UFA's, and competitive teams aren't trying to fill their needs.

      Teams in the game always just seem to trade for whatever random thing they find. Basement teams don't trade for future players or try to stockpile draft picks for veterans, and teams in general don't seem to address needs in players they keep or let go.

      The other issue is that a players ratings and potential seem to matter more than anything else. A UFA that's playing the best hockey of their life should not only be a huge trade chip at the deadline for a poorly performing team, they should also be demanding big money and term when they get to free agency, forcing you or other teams to gamble on them. But as it stands in the game now, trades just don't make a lot of sense. Shattenkirk is still a massive trade piece, even in his final year with no contract. So you could potentially trade him at the deadline for prospects to a team that needs their pics and prospects, and then re-sign him in the off season. The offseason just opens a whole other can of worms. There's no market for players, no negotiations or trying to convince a player to join your team. Guys don't seem to desire going to a winning team, or playing close to home.

      It just seems that everything outside of the on-ice action was a second thought.

      Comment

      • Nickflyers
        MVP
        • Oct 2008
        • 1858

        #4
        Re: Franchise CPU GM AI needs work

        More issues

        The damn CPU GM AI makes my head hurt......Start of the 2020 season

        Colorado let Duchene walk...they have MacKinnon, Soderberg, Jost coming up, so ok cool....BUT they sign 31 year old Sergei Bobrovsky to a 6yr/$7.5M contract DESPITE HAVING Varlamov(87ovr) on a 4yr/$5.4M AND Pickard(85) on a 2yr/$4.5M contract(Both are on the block BTW)....so that's $16M+ tied up in THREE NHL CALIBER GOALIES.....

        Dallas who was in serious need to get a goalie has the following LW DEPTH
        J.Benn(94), M.Pacioretty(89), JVR(86), J.Dickinson(85), M.Janmark(83), R.Tufte(81). Patches and JVR were free agent signings

        Ottawa is in the same boat, but they went out and got Wayne Simmonds(I didn't have enough cap to sign him at Resigning, then he rejected our FA offer due to wanting to go to a "Playoff Caliber team" i.e Ottawa with Darling as their goalie and no defense outside of Karlsson) giving them 5 RW over 85....

        So here's the NHL team's Goalie depth charts(Top three)

        ANA: Gibson(91), Bernier(84), A.Bibeau(77)
        BLT: Scheider(91), Blackwood(85), Halverson(82)
        BOS: Rask(89), Subban(88), Vladar(78)
        BUF: Lehner(84), Kuemper(82), Ullmark(79)
        CBJ: Lack(80), Merzlikins(79), Kozun(72) ($3.6M Cap space)
        CGY: Elliott(84), Gilles(83), C.Gibson(79)
        CHI: Crawford(89), J.Fazio(75), B.Moran(74)
        COL: Bobrovsky(89), Varlamov(87), Pickard(85)
        DAL: Hammond(83), Lehtonen(81), Niemi(77)(But they sign Pacioretty & JVR)
        DET: Mrazek(87), Neuvirth(83), Khudobin(82) (and Hitchinson 80)
        EDM: Mason(88), Talbot(86), Montoya(79)
        FLA: Reimer(82), Montembeault(82), Billia(77)
        HFD: Nedeljkovic(84), Mazanec(81), Helvig(72)
        LA: Quick(93), Lyon(80), Luukonen(75, Med Starter)(THEY ALSO HAVE THEIR 1st OVERALL SELECTION ON THE BLOCK!!???)
        MIN: Dubnyk(87), Kahkonen(83), Van Pottelberghe(79)
        MTL: Price(93), McNiven(76), Outhouse(73)
        NSH: Jones(87), Rinne(86), Saros(80)
        NYI: Soderstrom(86), Halak(84), Greiss(81), Howard(81)
        NYR: Shestyorkin(85), Lundqvist(85), Raanta(83), Hellberg(80)
        OTT: Darling(81), Ingram(76), Zajdlik(68)
        PIT: Fleury(87), Murray(86), Jarry(83)
        SEA: Domingue(81), Smith(80), Vehvilainen(80)
        SJ: Vasilevskiy(86), Khavanov(73), Arkhipov(70)
        STL: Allen(88), Fitzpatrick(82), Nilsson(81)
        TB: Bishop(89), Sandstrom(80), Gudlevskis(80)
        TOR: Andersen(86), Korpisalo(85), Bouck(65)
        VAN: Demko(87), Markstrom(82), Masiello(75)
        WPG: Hellebuyck(86), Comrie(85), Pavelec(83)
        WSH: Boltby(92), Samsonov(89), Lindgren(77)

        ITALIC = ON TRADE BLOCK

        There are trades that CAN BE MADE, but it seems the only time teams trade is at the DRAFT. LOOKING AT YOU MINNESOTA who traded for Boychuk and his BIG CONTRACT only to turn around and put him on the block at the start of the season.....

        Stupid stuff like this is really making it difficult for me to take my Franchise seriously....

        /rant
        Twitter

        Twitch


        YouTube Channel

        Comment

        • actionhank
          MVP
          • Jan 2010
          • 1530

          #5
          Re: Franchise CPU GM AI needs work

          Originally posted by Nickflyers
          More issues

          The damn CPU GM AI makes my head hurt......Start of the 2020 season

          Colorado let Duchene walk...they have MacKinnon, Soderberg, Jost coming up, so ok cool....BUT they sign 31 year old Sergei Bobrovsky to a 6yr/$7.5M contract DESPITE HAVING Varlamov(87ovr) on a 4yr/$5.4M AND Pickard(85) on a 2yr/$4.5M contract(Both are on the block BTW)....so that's $16M+ tied up in THREE NHL CALIBER GOALIES.....

          Dallas who was in serious need to get a goalie has the following LW DEPTH
          J.Benn(94), M.Pacioretty(89), JVR(86), J.Dickinson(85), M.Janmark(83), R.Tufte(81). Patches and JVR were free agent signings

          Ottawa is in the same boat, but they went out and got Wayne Simmonds(I didn't have enough cap to sign him at Resigning, then he rejected our FA offer due to wanting to go to a "Playoff Caliber team" i.e Ottawa with Darling as their goalie and no defense outside of Karlsson) giving them 5 RW over 85....

          So here's the NHL team's Goalie depth charts(Top three)

          ANA: Gibson(91), Bernier(84), A.Bibeau(77)
          BLT: Scheider(91), Blackwood(85), Halverson(82)
          BOS: Rask(89), Subban(88), Vladar(78)
          BUF: Lehner(84), Kuemper(82), Ullmark(79)
          CBJ: Lack(80), Merzlikins(79), Kozun(72) ($3.6M Cap space)
          CGY: Elliott(84), Gilles(83), C.Gibson(79)
          CHI: Crawford(89), J.Fazio(75), B.Moran(74)
          COL: Bobrovsky(89), Varlamov(87), Pickard(85)
          DAL: Hammond(83), Lehtonen(81), Niemi(77)(But they sign Pacioretty & JVR)
          DET: Mrazek(87), Neuvirth(83), Khudobin(82) (and Hitchinson 80)
          EDM: Mason(88), Talbot(86), Montoya(79)
          FLA: Reimer(82), Montembeault(82), Billia(77)
          HFD: Nedeljkovic(84), Mazanec(81), Helvig(72)
          LA: Quick(93), Lyon(80), Luukonen(75, Med Starter)(THEY ALSO HAVE THEIR 1st OVERALL SELECTION ON THE BLOCK!!???)
          MIN: Dubnyk(87), Kahkonen(83), Van Pottelberghe(79)
          MTL: Price(93), McNiven(76), Outhouse(73)
          NSH: Jones(87), Rinne(86), Saros(80)
          NYI: Soderstrom(86), Halak(84), Greiss(81), Howard(81)
          NYR: Shestyorkin(85), Lundqvist(85), Raanta(83), Hellberg(80)
          OTT: Darling(81), Ingram(76), Zajdlik(68)
          PIT: Fleury(87), Murray(86), Jarry(83)
          SEA: Domingue(81), Smith(80), Vehvilainen(80)
          SJ: Vasilevskiy(86), Khavanov(73), Arkhipov(70)
          STL: Allen(88), Fitzpatrick(82), Nilsson(81)
          TB: Bishop(89), Sandstrom(80), Gudlevskis(80)
          TOR: Andersen(86), Korpisalo(85), Bouck(65)
          VAN: Demko(87), Markstrom(82), Masiello(75)
          WPG: Hellebuyck(86), Comrie(85), Pavelec(83)
          WSH: Boltby(92), Samsonov(89), Lindgren(77)

          ITALIC = ON TRADE BLOCK

          There are trades that CAN BE MADE, but it seems the only time teams trade is at the DRAFT. LOOKING AT YOU MINNESOTA who traded for Boychuk and his BIG CONTRACT only to turn around and put him on the block at the start of the season.....

          Stupid stuff like this is really making it difficult for me to take my Franchise seriously....

          /rant
          Yeah, it's always frustrating once you pass one or more seasons. Teams just get goofy. The signings don't make sense, the guys they let walk don't make sense, the trades don't make sense...it's just all crazy.

          I wish they would let you force trades between all teams in GM Mode.

          Comment

          Working...