Attribute Suggestions for CAG

[thedeafpoliceman]

So I've started the process of creating several pros who aren't in the game, and was wondering if any of you could give me some input as to what certain golfers ratings should be when I take them through Career Mode.

The list of golfers I am creating (using GameFace, and I've found not using the side pic helps, and if you toy with the face after uploading the pics you can make it look better, plus I think the faces look better while playing the game then looking at it zoomed up in the CAG screen):
Phil Mickelson
Matt Kuchar
Charl Schwartzel
Louis Oosthuizen
Sergio Garcia
Steve Stricker

for those who can't remember the actual ratings -
Power:
Accuracy:
Workability:
Spin:
Recovery:
Putting:

Any help would be appreciated, even if you only have one rating you'd want to input (i.e.-I think Sergio's Recovery rating should be a 62)

[thedeafpoliceman]

Re: Attribute Suggestions for CAG

Glad to see the OS community once again completely ignore people

[Flightwhite24]

You have to give them a chance to respond.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Flightwhite24]

Wish I could help but I wouldn't know where to start


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[BIG CAROLINA]

Re: Attribute Suggestions for CAG

Glad to see the OS community once again completely ignore people

^ That is so far from the truth.. This is one of if not the most helpful sites that I have ever been on (gaming or non-gaming).

So because someone does not jump when you thought they should have jumped, doesn't mean someone is not actually working on it on their own.

What do you have so far?

[dcherry]

Re: Attribute Suggestions for CAG

I would think you would have to compare your created player stats to the stats of actual players already in the game. Make your own judgements and/or use real world stats to determine how a player should be rated compared to every other player in the game.

[lnin0]

Re: Attribute Suggestions for CAG

Yeah. It is no easy task rating players. Like suggested you probably need to use the players in the game as a baseline. A site that might help compare stats:

http://www.pgatour.com/r/stats/filter/?1

The biggest issue is grinding XP for a half dozen players. The way EA setup the CAG with the bs xp grind sucks filling out attributes for one golfer, let alone six.

I really really hate the CAG setup in TW. It should be one thing grinding for XP if I want to do a "My Player" type career but if I just want to create players - like you are doing to add offline pros or to just to have a nicely rounded out, competitive, personalized CAG for online play - I should be able to do that without wading through all the grinding bs.

EA is the WORST company when it comes to realizing FUN is what gives a game true longevity - not artificial rewards and barriers.