Godfather 2 wasn't as good as the first for me. Saving Private Ryan had some awesome war scenes. The part where they accidently inform the wrong Ryan is great as well.
Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
Collapse
Recommended Videos
Collapse
X
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
Godfather 2 wasn't as good as the first for me. Saving Private Ryan had some awesome war scenes. The part where they accidently inform the wrong Ryan is great as well. -
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
Saving Private RyanComment
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
I believe you are doing that for me. The acting alone is enough to separate these two films. SPR has Tom Hanks and............Tom Sizemore????
The Godfather has
Al Pacino
Robert Duvall
Diane Keaton
Robert De Niro
John Cazale
Lee Strasberg
Bruno Kirby
Danny Aiello
Harry Dean Stanton
For those youngsters out there these might constitute some of the greatest actors of their or anyone else's time.Comment
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
I believe you are doing that for me. The acting alone is enough to separate these two films. SPR has Tom Hanks and............Tom Sizemore????
The Godfather has
Al Pacino
Robert Duvall
Diane Keaton
Robert De Niro
John Cazale
Lee Strasberg
Bruno Kirby
Danny Aiello
Harry Dean Stanton
For those youngsters out there these might constitute some of the greatest actors of their or anyone else's time.
If anything, that speaks more towards SPR. seeing as how Spielberg was saddled with such 'lowly talent' and still created a compelling film.Originally posted by Alexis de TocquevilleThe America Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money.Comment
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
Compelling? Really beyond the first 20 minutes? What was so compelling?Comment
-
Originally posted by Alexis de TocquevilleThe America Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money.Comment
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
I'm shocked this is even a debate. GF2 is a much better movie, imo. I'm not suggesting SPR is a bad movie, but I would never have put these two in the same echelon.Comment
-
Comment
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
So basically were heading for Lucas/Spielberg movies final four.Comment
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
Unfortunately you are correct it would seem. While I am a hugh Star Wars fan and a fan of some of Spielberg's work, their film's don't belong in a top 100 list. The sweet 16 is pretty embarrassing with many quality films not even mentioned in the original polls. OS'ers seem to favor action/comedy over drama's or character driven stories. It is what it is.Comment
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
Unfortunately you are correct it would seem. While I am a hugh Star Wars fan and a fan of some of Spielberg's work, their film's don't belong in a top 100 list. The sweet 16 is pretty embarrassing with many quality films not even mentioned in the original polls. OS'ers seem to favor action/comedy over drama's or character driven stories. It is what it is.Comment
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
Schindler's List belongs and maybe Jaws. The rest. Nope
Close Encounters of the Third Kind? HahahaComment
-
Re: Sweet 16! OS Movie Madness: Godfather-Pt 2 vs Saving Private Ryan
I like how some people are the definitive authority on what may or may not be top 100.Comment
Comment