Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • deaduck
    MVP
    • Mar 2009
    • 2389

    #31
    Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

    At this point, here's what I'm hoping...

    It's Wakefield (dumb name for a serial killer, lacks poetry, but I digress)

    He sinks all the boats then kills EVERYBODY on the island but Abby. Tracks her down and tricks her into picking up one of his blood soaked weapons. Runs to hidden jet ski with Abby chasing him...and yells back at her as he zooms off...

    "Just try and explain this to the cops."

    Comment

    • ~LiverpoolRed~
      YNWA
      • Dec 2008
      • 10755

      #32
      Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

      The wife and I re-watched episode 2 last night.

      We think J.D. (Henry's brother) was the one that wrote psycho and tied the dead deer to Shane's truck. We did see him in the woods with Kelly when Abby saw her with him. Revenge for starting a fight with him at the cannery.

      I think he also put the deer head in his brother's bathtub to frame Shane for it. Did you see the sly grin on his face when Henry punched him at the beach?

      I'm still going with the sheriff as my killer choice but J.D. is a possibility.

      Comment

      • fistofrage
        Hall Of Fame
        • Aug 2002
        • 13682

        #33
        Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

        Originally posted by ~LiverpoolRed~
        The wife and I re-watched episode 2 last night.

        We think J.D. (Henry's brother) was the one that wrote psycho and tied the dead deer to Shane's truck. We did see him in the woods with Kelly when Abby saw her with him. Revenge for starting a fight with him at the cannery.

        I think he also put the deer head in his brother's bathtub to frame Shane for it. Did you see the sly grin on his face when Henry punched him at the beach?

        I'm still going with the sheriff as my killer choice but J.D. is a possibility.
        JD, too obvious. He's a trouble maker, but no reason to cut his uncle in half.

        The Sherrif would have really been the only one with the time to dig the Pits and snares and such. Unless it was those other 2 Townies, but I don't see that.
        Chalepa Ta Kala.....

        Comment

        • ~LiverpoolRed~
          YNWA
          • Dec 2008
          • 10755

          #34
          Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

          So I guess my theory on the sheriff is dead wrong.

          What was puzzling for me and my wife this week was the fact that NOT A SINGLE PERSON acknowledged that Lucy was missing. She was the girl who was burned alive the week before in the pit.

          Everyone was swimming in the pool during the day and at the rehearsal dinner at night time. In all that time not a single person was concerned that she was nowhere to be seen?

          Comment

          • deaduck
            MVP
            • Mar 2009
            • 2389

            #35
            Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

            Yeah, okay, they sort of covered up the Uncle goes missing but why is nobody noting the others gone "missing".

            Come on, The priest is dead. Nobody has noticed a missing priest the week of a big wedding.

            On a seperate note, how rich are all these people? They're on the island a WEEK before the ceremony. Nobody has a job?

            Other than that, the red eye thing was a cool touch of menace.

            Comment

            • ~LiverpoolRed~
              YNWA
              • Dec 2008
              • 10755

              #36
              Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

              Very odd isn't it? Lucy is supposedly one of Trish's best friends and one of the bridesmaids. Surely someone realized she wasn't there at the rehearsal dinner!

              Comment

              • fistofrage
                Hall Of Fame
                • Aug 2002
                • 13682

                #37
                Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

                Originally posted by ~LiverpoolRed~
                So I guess my theory on the sheriff is dead wrong.

                What was puzzling for me and my wife this week was the fact that NOT A SINGLE PERSON acknowledged that Lucy was missing. She was the girl who was burned alive the week before in the pit.

                Everyone was swimming in the pool during the day and at the rehearsal dinner at night time. In all that time not a single person was concerned that she was nowhere to be seen?
                Not so fast, imagine if the Sherriff had 2 personalities.......Noone saw him kill Wakefield.
                Chalepa Ta Kala.....

                Comment

                • deaduck
                  MVP
                  • Mar 2009
                  • 2389

                  #38
                  Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

                  Is that even psychologically sound?

                  A split personality/serial killer who's activity is triggered by the proximity of the daughter?

                  Comment

                  • fistofrage
                    Hall Of Fame
                    • Aug 2002
                    • 13682

                    #39
                    Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

                    Originally posted by deaduck
                    Is that even psychologically sound?

                    A split personality/serial killer who's activity is triggered by the proximity of the daughter?
                    He made her move away right?

                    Anyway, the killer must be someone who has been on the island. The snares, and especially the Tiger Pit where they set the girl on fire. That couldn't have been done once the killer got to the island.

                    Abby's old boyfriend could be in the mix too.

                    However, don't know how to explain the guy tied to the axel of the boat taking them to the island.
                    Chalepa Ta Kala.....

                    Comment

                    • ~LiverpoolRed~
                      YNWA
                      • Dec 2008
                      • 10755

                      #40
                      Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

                      I've been reading some theories on other message boards and one suspect that I find interesting that has been mentioned is the owner of the Candlewick Inn Maggie Krell who is also the Wedding Planner.

                      Here's a few things that I have read about her:

                      The owner would have access to everybody's motel room.

                      The gun that killed Hunter Jennings was property of the Candlewick Inn.

                      She knows the island and could have set the traps.

                      She would have to work with the flower girl, Madison. She told her parents a "friend" told her that people had died on the island.

                      She's only had a couple of minutes of airtime so far so she could have been anywhere during the murders.

                      She also could be a relative of John Wakefield all we know. Wife, sister, etc.

                      Comment

                      • fistofrage
                        Hall Of Fame
                        • Aug 2002
                        • 13682

                        #41
                        Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

                        Originally posted by ~LiverpoolRed~
                        I've been reading some theories on other message boards and one suspect that I find interesting that has been mentioned is the owner of the Candlewick Inn Maggie Krell who is also the Wedding Planner.

                        Here's a few things that I have read about her:

                        The owner would have access to everybody's motel room.

                        The gun that killed Hunter Jennings was property of the Candlewick Inn.

                        She knows the island and could have set the traps.

                        She would have to work with the flower girl, Madison. She told her parents a "friend" told her that people had died on the island.

                        She's only had a couple of minutes of airtime so far so she could have been anywhere during the murders.

                        She also could be a relative of John Wakefield all we know. Wife, sister, etc.
                        Was the wedding planner the one who saw the priest before he died?

                        That would be brutal if the murderer was someone who got very little air time.
                        Chalepa Ta Kala.....

                        Comment

                        • ~LiverpoolRed~
                          YNWA
                          • Dec 2008
                          • 10755

                          #42
                          Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

                          Originally posted by fistofrage
                          Was the wedding planner the one who saw the priest before he died?

                          That would be brutal if the murderer was someone who got very little air time.

                          Yeah that's her.

                          Comment

                          • deaduck
                            MVP
                            • Mar 2009
                            • 2389

                            #43
                            Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

                            Yeah, that'd be a big foul on the play if the killer is somebody hardly on the screen....like the one eyed taxi driver or some crap.

                            Comment

                            • JBH3
                              Marvel's Finest
                              • Jan 2007
                              • 13506

                              #44
                              Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

                              I got caught up on the last 2 episodes...thank you On Demand.

                              Who thinks it's John Wakefield back from the dead, or did he ever really die????
                              Originally posted by Edmund Burke
                              All that is needed for the triumph of evil, is for good men to do nothing.

                              Comment

                              • ~LiverpoolRed~
                                YNWA
                                • Dec 2008
                                • 10755

                                #45
                                Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

                                Another tidbit I caught during the last eppy. Hunter had a bag with a gun and money inside. Could this be the same bag Uncle Marty was shown with during the first episode?

                                Comment

                                Working...