Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

[JBH3]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

So I guess my theory on the sheriff is dead wrong.

What was puzzling for me and my wife this week was the fact that NOT A SINGLE PERSON acknowledged that Lucy was missing. She was the girl who was burned alive the week before in the pit.

Everyone was swimming in the pool during the day and at the rehearsal dinner at night time. In all that time not a single person was concerned that she was nowhere to be seen?

I was beginning to suspect the sherriff too until he found the note w/ his eyes painted red.

As for Lucy...yea I thought that was odd too that no one had made mention of her nor the preacher.

I've been reading some theories on other message boards and one suspect that I find interesting that has been mentioned is the owner of the Candlewick Inn Maggie Krell who is also the Wedding Planner.

Here's a few things that I have read about her:

The owner would have access to everybody's motel room.

The gun that killed Hunter Jennings was property of the Candlewick Inn.

She knows the island and could have set the traps.

She would have to work with the flower girl, Madison. She told her parents a "friend" told her that people had died on the island.

She's only had a couple of minutes of airtime so far so she could have been anywhere during the murders.

She also could be a relative of John Wakefield all we know. Wife, sister, etc.

This is an interesting thought.

I noticed that when that blonde chick w/ the British guy was on that scavenger hunt and found Wakefield's grave there were candles set all around/on top of it...someone is mourning his "death."

Perhaps the girl who was hung, or a psycho relative...that is if he's dead...

[fistofrage]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Another tidbit I caught during the last eppy. Hunter had a bag with a gun and money inside. Could this be the same bag Uncle Marty was shown with during the first episode?

There is no doubt that was Uncle Marty's cash and gun. Do we know why uncle Marty had the cash and gun?

Did anyone know Marty had the cash. Was that speedboat the way Hunter got to the island? Its odd that the money was on that boat. Its almost like they were trying to frame Hunter, but I don't know how they could frame him if noone knew he had it.

Right now, I'm saying its the Sherriff. He's Dr. Jeckyl and Mr. Hide.

[goh]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I think it's the flower girl being possessed by the spirit of Wakefield.

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I was just surfing through my upcoming dvr recordings and it shows harper's Island on Saturday night instead of Thursday.

Just searched the net and found this:

According to TV Guide, the day and time has changed. It is now on Saturdays at 9 effective immediately.

http://www.tvguide.com/News/Harpers-Island-Schedule-1005503.aspx

Because Harper's Island is making a killing in the land of DVR playback and online screaming streaming, CBS is shuttling the slasher series to Saturdays at 9 pm/ET, effectively immediately.

Though many deem that destination a "death slot," CBS senior executive VP Kelly Kahl posits that the preliminary returns on the freshman series' DVR+7 playback and online streaming data "suggest a passionate audience for Harper's outside its current Thursday time period borders.

"This move gives us an opportunity to improve the time period on Thursday while experimenting with more original programming on Saturday."

This week, Harper's will be replaced by a CSI repeat. The CSI: NY season finale will occupy the Thursday-at-10 slot on May 14.

[fistofrage]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Its dead. They better show the rest of it either on-line or something. I bet they cancel it in 2 weeks.

[The Chef]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Its dead. They better show the rest of it either on-line or something. I bet they cancel it in 2 weeks.

I disagree, from the sounds of it they think Harpers is doing good enough through DVR recordings and online streaming that it wont matter the day. Im sure they are going to move a struggling show to Thursday in hopes that the Survivor lead in, or CSI if they have it at 10:00, can help that show while moving Harpers to Saturday shouldnt hurt the majority of viewers since its through DVR and online streaming anyways.

[VanCitySportsGuy]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I've found the show to be pretty boring but since there's only 13 episodes, I'll stick with it to the end. I'll make a crazy prediction and say the killer is the main female character.

I DVR every show so it doesn't bother me that they moved it to Saturday.

[ExtremeGamer]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I actually think it's dead too, it'll end up having every episode available online to finish the season. I give it 1-2 more weeks before that happens.

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

A couple more weeks and I say this is toast. All 13 episodes have been filmed so they will probably put them online for those who want closure.

After watching episode 4 it still boggles my mind that NO ONE is concerned as to where Lucy is. She's one of the freaking bridesmaids!!! She wasn't at the big fancy dinner party in the third episode. She wasn't at poolside when everyone was at the pool. Nobody noticed she wasn't at the bachelorette party with her yippy dog? Her name was even listed on the psychic's list.

[BigRed]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I'm going to stick with this show to the end, but they are really making it difficult on me.

[Unoriginal Name]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

A couple more weeks and I say this is toast. All 13 episodes have been filmed so they will probably put them online for those who want closure.

After watching episode 4 it still boggles my mind that NO ONE is concerned as to where Lucy is. She's one of the freaking bridesmaids!!! She wasn't at the big fancy dinner party in the third episode. She wasn't at poolside when everyone was at the pool. Nobody noticed she wasn't at the bachelorette party with her yippy dog? Her name was even listed on the psychic's list.

That bugs me also. None of the people who have gone missing have been mentioned at all since they went missing. The uncle had a little bit of mention but after that the nephew doesn't seem that concerned that he hasn't shown up yet and it is a couple days later. No one has noticed that the priest is no longer around either...wouldn't he be pretty obvious if he wasn't around anymore.

I do enjoy watching this show but some of the things they do are pretty out there as to believablilty.

[deaduck]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Well, they had killer(s) fake a text from the uncle saying he found a wild blond or something and would be back for the wedding.

After that however...

[goh]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Wouldn't the priest be kind of a loner anyway? Probably just think he's off doing God stuff somewhere. No excuse for not noticing Lucy though.

Was the 45 year old emo guy in this last episode or did he die? I didn't think he died during that incident but forgot exactly what happend. I know he was strung up and accidently shot or cut or something like that.

It would've been cool if they killed off Trish.

[deaduck]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

It would've been cool if they killed off Trish.

When it looked like she was a goner, my first thought was, "I hope somebody notices the bride is missing."

[fistofrage]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I don't think that dud shot himself in the Leg.