Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I mentioned a while back that the wedding planner (And Owner of the Candewick Inn) could be the killer.

She was there when the firecrackers were set off. She could have easily planted the one that Henry found.

She's old enough that she could potentially be Wakefield's wife out for revenge.

She lives on the island so she would have ample time to set up all the traps.

We've seen the Candelewick Inn logo twice now for two of the killings. The matches used to kill Lucy had the logo and the gun that killed Hunter.

She was the last person to see the priest. He was killed so he wouldn't ruin the chandelier trap. (Meaning he would be at the church prior to the rehearsal and flick the switch before it was supposed to).

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Well you could say what's the point of having us get to know all the characters who are eventually killed...?

I see your point. I'm just saying it's a miniseries where the viewer has 13 weeks to find out whodunit and it turns out to be someone that played no onscreen role at all throughout the series. That would be disappointing.

[Unoriginal Name]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I see your point. I'm just saying it's a miniseries where the viewer has 13 weeks to find out whodunit and it turns out to be someone that played no onscreen role at all throughout the series. That would be disappointing.

I would agree wholeheartedly with you on this. To me the whole point of a whodunit series is to give the viewers a chance to figure it out along the way.

[goh]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Has she even been on the show in any of the other episodes?

As I learned looking up the last episode since I missed it,she's the main character of the minisodes on the website.

[deaduck]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

She was the last person to see the priest. He was killed so he wouldn't ruin the chandelier trap. (Meaning he would be at the church prior to the rehearsal and flick the switch before it was supposed to).

My only problem with this (and kudos because the rest is well thought out and logical)...Why didn't she just whack him when they were alone together at the church? Why wait until he goes and takes a walk? Or just poison him with the (was it pie?) she gave him?

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

My only problem with this (and kudos because the rest is well thought out and logical)...Why didn't she just whack him when they were alone together at the church? Why wait until he goes and takes a walk? Or just poison him with the (was it pie?) she gave him?

Because he was in charge of the scavenger hunt. She brought him all the stuff needed for it (I'm guessing someone would know who supplied him with the stuff and pinpoint her if she killed him right there.). She said something like, "The winners need to have their picture taken with 1 of these 2 hats". Just a guess.

[deaduck]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Maybe I'm having a brain hiccup but didn't he get roped and hooked right after she left and none of the scavenger people made it to him. Remember both parties gave up.

Shoot, from a logic standpoint, if she is the killer why did she leave evidence that she was there at all?

I don't know but I gots a bad feeling the setup isn't going to match the identity of the killer(s)

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Maybe I'm having a brain hiccup but didn't he get roped and hooked right after she left and none of the scavenger people made it to him. Remember both parties gave up.

Shoot, from a logic standpoint, if she is the killer why did she leave evidence that she was there at all?

I don't know but I gots a bad feeling the setup isn't going to match the identity of the killer(s)

Dammit! I give up, she didn't do it. Too many questions!

[deaduck]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Dammit! I give up, she didn't do it. Too many questions!

See that's what they want us to do...just give up.

So we won't notice that when they revel the killer...it makes absolutly no sense what so ever.

At this stage I'm prepared to believe that Harry Hamlin brought a bag a money to the island to pay off his twin brother, who got a face lift/sex change and married Papa Wellington.

But she/he wanted more money than Hamlin had so she/he kills her/his brother then her/his husband with a crossbow chandelier knowing full well she's not in the will. But she/he's got a plan....fake a serial killer to cover his/her 4 needed kills...Hamlin,Papa Wellington, the bride Trish and her sister. That means all the money goes to the sister's husband who he/she's allready seduced.

And take out the dead mother china set...because the china had it coming.

....Or not.

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Good episode last night.

[ExtremeGamer]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Is it back on Thursday's again? LOL

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Is it back on Thursday's again? LOL

It's ALWAYS on Thursday's here in Canada. You Yanks have to wait until Saturday.

[deaduck]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Dude that's so wrong.

Your Canuck humor made me think I missed an episode.

[~LiverpoolRed~]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Dude that's so wrong.

Your Canuck humor made me think I missed an episode.

Be sure to check it out tonight. IMO this is the best episode of the series so far.

[goh]

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I already saw the UFC preview so I guess I'll watch. Would've on thursday if I thought of it but it would've been SD.