Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

**fistofrage** · 05-24-2009, 07:49 PM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Still sticking to the Sherrif has a split personality and he's the murderer. There was a bod\y in Wakefield's coffin, but I bet that isn't Wakefield.

**goh** · 05-24-2009, 11:40 PM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

My spirit of Wakefield possesing the little girl theroy is out. Isn't the sherif out now too along with Abby,JD and Herny too? Weren't they all in the woods when what's his name got harpooned?

**fistofrage** · 05-25-2009, 09:17 AM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Originally posted by goh

My spirit of Wakefield possesing the little girl theroy is out. Isn't the sherif out now too along with Abby,JD and Herny too? Weren't they all in the woods when what's his name got harpooned?

If its not the Sherriff then perhaps its Abby's old boyfriend, but I still think its the sherriff.

**Burns11** · 05-25-2009, 12:59 PM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Originally posted by fistofrage

If its not the Sherriff then perhaps its Abby's old boyfriend, but I still think its the sherriff.

Maybe it's both, like Scream.

**goh** · 05-25-2009, 05:05 PM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

While he'd have a harpoon,wouldn't it have been hard for him to get the first guy and tie him to the propeller then get back in time? Maybe it's the British guy and his girlfriend.

**Unoriginal Name** · 05-26-2009, 08:37 AM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I didn't see it brought up at all but any thoughts as to who is the guy with the messed up face that we saw when the dog was chasing Trish and her dad and then saw him again in the cabin that JD went in to?

**fistofrage** · 05-26-2009, 09:57 AM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Originally posted by Unoriginal Name

I didn't see it brought up at all but any thoughts as to who is the guy with the messed up face that we saw when the dog was chasing Trish and her dad and then saw him again in the cabin that JD went in to?

I think that's Wakefield. But he didn't commit the murders and now he's laying low because everyone thinks he's dead.

**Unoriginal Name** · 05-26-2009, 10:32 AM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Originally posted by fistofrage

I think that's Wakefield. But he didn't commit the murders and now he's laying low because everyone thinks he's dead.

That was my first thought too because I don't believe the body in the grave was Wakefield.

If it is Wakefield though and JD knows it is Wakefield why was JD trying to pin the new murders on Wakefield being back? By JD showing up at the cabin door my impression is that the guy with the messed up face and JD are friendly.

**~LiverpoolRed~** · 05-26-2009, 10:50 AM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

I've read on several sites that the burnt face guy is named Cole Harkin. According to wiki, and I know anyone can write stuff on there but I've seen it on other sites to. it says:

Cole Harkin

The Survivor (Portrayed by Dean Wray)
Cole Harkin was one of the two officers attacked by John Wakefield during his rampage. He was caught in a boat explosion that burned his face and the entire right side of his body. He was sent to Seattle for treatment and returned to the island months later. He now lives as a recluse in the woods, with a German shepard dog, perhaps to hide his burned face from others. In the 5th episode, Thomas and Trish trespassed on his land and he sent his dog to attack them. Thomas managed to kill the dog and they escaped. Harkin is also looking after Lucy's dog, Gigi.
Appearances: Episodes 5, 6

**fistofrage** · 05-26-2009, 11:03 AM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Originally posted by ~LiverpoolRed~

I've read on several sites that the burnt face guy is named Cole Harkin. According to wiki, and I know anyone can write stuff on there but I've seen it on other sites to. it says:

Cole Harkin

The Survivor (Portrayed by Dean Wray)
Cole Harkin was one of the two officers attacked by John Wakefield during his rampage. He was caught in a boat explosion that burned his face and the entire right side of his body. He was sent to Seattle for treatment and returned to the island months later. He now lives as a recluse in the woods, with a German shepard dog, perhaps to hide his burned face from others. In the 5th episode, Thomas and Trish trespassed on his land and he sent his dog to attack them. Thomas managed to kill the dog and they escaped. Harkin is also looking after Lucy's dog, Gigi.
Appearances: Episodes 5, 6

Guess I had that wrong. I'm still sticking with it either being the Sherriff or Abby's ex-boyfriend or a combo of the two.

**~LiverpoolRed~** · 05-29-2009, 11:44 AM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Another good episode last night. I won't spoil anything but I will say they show the background story of Abby's relationship with Jimmy before the Wakefield stuff started.

**fistofrage** · 05-31-2009, 05:09 PM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Good episode. Pretty sure Abby is Wakefield's daughter and Abby's mom was with the sherriff because he was the safe bet and better provider. Thats why it was easy to ship Abby off. I mean with a murderer loose on the island, if you were the sherriff, wouldn't you have your daughter with you AT ALL TIMES?

**Burns11** · 05-31-2009, 06:23 PM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Also that Abby's mom said he's been good to us, and I seem to remember the sheriff saying something that made me feel that she wasn't his.

I'm really starting to wonder if the small odd things we are focusing on are the result of bad writing, or are cleverly crafted. A good example is the last episode where Jimmy stopped by the killer in his truck. Here he sees a guy standing in the road over a bloody corpse with a bloody implement, and he stops? He says later he saw Abby after he stopped, he didn't stop because of Abby, so either he is a party to what happened or he is some kind of idiot.

**deaduck** · 05-31-2009, 06:45 PM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Just got caught up on all the episodes I had taped and sorry but unless I'm missing something bigtime...this show is just going in circles.

If it was Wakefield and the whole Abby storyline, Why did he and is he killing all these other people? Is he just an unfocused killer and can't keep his eye on the goal?

Then we get little things like despite seeing Wakefields face in photos...when Abby stumbles upon him, they hide his face. That creates confusion in the narrative. So when Jimmy gives his off-logic reason for stopping, we're left to not trust it.

In fact, we're lead to not trust ANYTHING. Absolutley nobody can be assumed to be innocent because of the way the narrative is laid out. Nobody is off the hook, not even the "dead" people.

I'm sticking with the show out of an investment in what is promised, more than what has been delivered to me so far.

I'm pretty sure I'll be mad at myself for sticking to it.

**~LiverpoolRed~** · 06-05-2009, 11:31 AM

Re: Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

It seems to get better and better by the week. Last night's show was the best so far. Make sure you check it out tomorrow night.

Anyone Gonna Check Out Harper's Island?

Recommended Videos

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment