Staff Roundtable: When Is the Best Time To Release a Sports Game?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ChaseB
    #BringBackFaceuary
    • Oct 2003
    • 9844

    #1

    Staff Roundtable: When Is the Best Time To Release a Sports Game?


    NCAA Football 12 is being released tomorrow, but Madden's release date is the one that has caused a stir this summer. Up until this year, Madden had revolved around the "Madden Holiday" that sat right in the middle of August. This release date had become a tradition that helped to get people excited about the looming NFL season. However, this year the game's release date is being pushed back to August 30 to more closely align with the real NFL schedule -- assuming the lockout ends. Of course, we still have NCAA Football being released in its well known July slot, which is obviously well before the start of the actual college football season.

    There are clearly a couple different philosophies at work here. So do you guys get more excited about a sports game when it's released well in advance of the upcoming real season, or do you get more pumped about playing sports video games when the real season is underway or about to begin?

    Read More - Staff Roundtable: When Is the Best Time To Release a Sports Game?
    I won't ask for Christmas or birthday gifts if you subscribe to the Operation Sports Newsletter (Not Just Another Roster Update). I write it, and it hits your inbox every Friday morning (for freeeeeee). We also have an official OS Discord you can now join.
  • Facts
    Rookie
    • May 2009
    • 203

    #2
    NCAA style. With the difference in times, I believe a patch would get the game up to speed at the same time as if you went with the Madden style. You just get a month more to play the game.

    Comment

    • johnprestonevans
      Pro
      • Oct 2008
      • 529

      #3
      I think EA just wants to give NCAA Football more time before it's "big brother" comes out. I enjoy both games, but I find that as soon as Madden is released, NCAA jumps right on the trading block for me. Giving the college game another couple of weeks sounds like a great idea. I think realeasing Madden at the end of August is the perfect time to lead into the new NFL season. I will however miss Madden in mid August simply because it was always a great birthday present.

      Comment

      • Vince Howard
        Rookie
        • Mar 2011
        • 34

        #4
        I prefer the NCAA style because that way we have time to get adjusted to this year's game, make a good slider set, and adjust rosters. This way, when the real season starts, we will be ready to play a great game from September to January and not have to worry about adjusting anything.
        It's all about the U! 5-time National Champions: 1983, 1987, 1989, 1991, 2001

        Comment

        • Demoncrom
          Rookie
          • Jun 2008
          • 118

          #5
          In the case of Madden, it may be better to push it closer to the real season for 2 reasons, 1 it gives NCAA players more time to rock before switching over to the Big Boys and 2. with this years lockout there is going to be lots of movement in the league after the dust settles.

          I also think that EA is making a move because they know that if there is no agreement than I do not believe they can still use the roster names. Remember, the player association was dissolved and the names and likenesses of players is not own by the league but by that every association that no longer exists. I say they are pushing it back just in case the league needs more time to figure this mess out and I say its a good move.

          Comment

          • LucianoJJ
            Pro
            • Jan 2006
            • 593

            #6
            I'd be happy if the game shipped a week in advance to the opener of the real life season. The extra time could help with patching bugs, more play testing, and proper player ratings/rosters. I know these companies are concerned with helping retailers hit sales numbers, but quality of product can drive sales, too.

            Yes, NCAA ships earlier to allow it to get a share of the sales before Madden comes along. But you won't see people in parkas in the bleachers of Wrigley Field in August because of retailers. There is a time for everything. College football in July is just wrong. EA can bring back Arena Football if they need to move some units in the summer.

            Comment

            • Layoneil
              Rookie
              • May 2003
              • 35

              #7
              why do people think there is going to be "extra time"? that extra time will only happen once for the first time they change the date, the development cycle is still ultimately just going to be a year long for every game after that. old games had less bugs because the newer consoles are more difficult to develop for.

              pro-games should come out when the first preseason game starts, just as the athletes need some time to get ready for the year so do the developers and most gamers.

              i'm also mostly a franchise guy who will restart after the trade deadline.

              Comment

              • tril
                MVP
                • Nov 2004
                • 2914

                #8
                I dont think it matters, as long as its around the start of the season. IMO, seevral months before the seaosn starts is a bit odd.
                a new College football game in the middle of the summer is really pushing it, cause this is when the baseball season really get interesting, for fans of the sport.
                In addition, college football is a late summer early fall sport. the game shoudl be released just when all the college kids head baclk to school. maybe a week before.
                Last thing I want to think about is leaves falling off the trees in the middle of the summer.

                Comment

                • ChaseB
                  #BringBackFaceuary
                  • Oct 2003
                  • 9844

                  #9
                  Re: Staff Roundtable: When Is the Best Time To Release a Sports Game?

                  Originally posted by Layoneil
                  why do people think there is going to be "extra time"? that extra time will only happen once for the first time they change the date, the development cycle is still ultimately just going to be a year long for every game after that. old games had less bugs because the newer consoles are more difficult to develop for.

                  pro-games should come out when the first preseason game starts, just as the athletes need some time to get ready for the year so do the developers and most gamers.

                  i'm also mostly a franchise guy who will restart after the trade deadline.
                  Yeah, I don't get why some of the writers were talking about development time either.
                  I won't ask for Christmas or birthday gifts if you subscribe to the Operation Sports Newsletter (Not Just Another Roster Update). I write it, and it hits your inbox every Friday morning (for freeeeeee). We also have an official OS Discord you can now join.

                  Comment

                  • speedtrucker
                    Pro
                    • Jan 2008
                    • 536

                    #10
                    for NCAA I like the early release, the college game does not have the roster changes that pro leagues do with free agency and trading. there is not a big reason to restart dynasties like there is for pro leagues, in NBA2k11 I started my gaming with "My Player" where the rosters were not as important and then I went to the "Association" mode later but even then I had to restart my "Association" after the trade deadline but even then it felt disjointed because my Mavs roster was going to feel weird either way. there was no way to adjust properly for the season changes, excluding injuries which I feel are happenstance.

                    Pro games need to be as close to the start of a season as possible, NCAA can/should stay a bit further out for both 1. added playing time before Madden sales affect it & 2. less/rare roster turnover following the spring drills.

                    Comment

                    • goalieump413
                      Stay thirsty my friends
                      • Apr 2010
                      • 488

                      #11
                      When's the best time? When it's finished! I know release day patches are the norm now, but all too often, the devs miss some key issues even after the release day patch. Recall that NCAA11 was plagued by the reverse pump fake glitch?

                      Comment

                      • walkman02
                        Banned
                        • Jun 2011
                        • 2

                        #12
                        If NCAA Football released around the same time as Madden I would never buy it! Plus there's nothing to do during the summer so I'm like screw It I'll Buy NCAA Football!

                        Comment

                        • CujoMatty
                          Member of Rush Nation
                          • Oct 2007
                          • 5445

                          #13
                          Definetly at sone point before the season. Case in point OOTP 12. I had pre ordered it in February and it just came out end of June. I'm still in to it and think it's a great game but I know I would have been into it even more in April.
                          2016 NLL Champion Saskatchewan Rush
                          2018 NLL Champion Saskatchewan Rush
                          2019 CEBL Champion Saskatchewan Rattlers

                          Comment

                          • Ikki
                            Rookie
                            • May 2010
                            • 36

                            #14
                            I see no mention of FIFA. The best-selling sports game is released a solid month AFTER most european leagues kick off (almost 2 months after the start of the french league).

                            Comment

                            • mrclutch
                              MVP
                              • Nov 2008
                              • 2369

                              #15
                              Re: Staff Roundtable: When Is the Best Time To Release a Sports Game?

                              The earlier the better for NCAA. I prefer Madden mainly because I'm much more of a pro fan than college. I can usually get a good couple months in before Madden comes out and NCAA goes on the shelf until bowl season.

                              I think the bigger the gap in release dates for the 2 games would probally max the sales to other guys like me who prefer one to the other.
                              Gamertag and PSN Mrclutch1013
                              Currently Playing
                              XBOX :Overwatch, NBA 2k22, random old stuff [/B][/COLOR]
                              PS4: Nothing currently

                              Comment

                              Working...