Madden 24 vs Madden 23

[Cycloniac]

So, I tried Madden 24 early on in the release cycle.

I thought there was some good, but the game just never felt right to me. Glaring issue I couldn't get past was the run-pass ratio. Even in sims it was really bad.

I re-installed Madden 23 last night to check in on a franchise I started. I'm curious how people feel about 23 vs 24.

Is 23 worth revisiting, or is 24 that much better?

Getting the football itch with the free agency frenzy going on.

[Mattanite]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

I think 24 is the best in several eras.

https://forums.operationsports.com/forums/madden-nfl-football/1012610-state-madden-franchise.html

[I_HATE_THAT_DUDE]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

After all the updates, I like where the gameplay is. Therefore, with the info released by Charles Davis verifying, there will be multiple announcers going in to record commentary for m25 and the way the gameplay improved over the winter. I'd say 24 is in a better place than 23, and m25 will hopefully start to give us the game we've been looking for. I am actually starting another franchise over in 24 bc the gameplay was so much better in the later stages of this release.

Sent from my SM-S908W using Tapatalk

[easts1d3raider]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

I played 23 for a long while before getting 24 recently. 24 is way better.

[Iteachpercussion]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

I have gone back to playing M23 because at the end of the day, due to 2 glaring issues, it is the superior game.

Madden 24 issue #1: CPU play calling.
If you want anything that slightly resembles NFL play calling and actual true run/pass ratio; you will not find it will M24. All of the playbooks, including the generic playbooks, have the CPU passing way too much. This is mentioned in a couple of threads here and is a major issue. Especially because the sim engine in franchise mode does not have this issue. For me, this alone is a killer for franchise mode.

Madden 24 issue #2: 3-4 Defense Bug
This is a huge issue that EA will not even mention. While it is easy to fix for the user, it is only possible to fix for the CPU if you go in and change the depth chart for each team. While that is certainly doable, it is a ridiculous adjustment that we as players have to make in order for the game to play correctly.

M23 has neither of these issues. Yes, some M23 playbooks are a little too pass heavy, but that can be adjusted by a couple of playbooks adjustments for CPU teams. The 3-4 bug is simply not there for M23.

Another minor issue is penalties. While penalties are a problem in both games, I can consistently get a fair amount of penalties in M23 but not in M24.


Now, if none of the above bothers you, yes, M24 is a slightly better game. Not overwhelmingly better, but slightly better.

[Cycloniac]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

I have gone back to playing M23 because at the end of the day, due to 2 glaring issues, it is the superior game.

Madden 24 issue #1: CPU play calling.
If you want anything that slightly resembles NFL play calling and actual true run/pass ratio; you will not find it will M24. All of the playbooks, including the generic playbooks, have the CPU passing way too much. This is mentioned in a couple of threads here and is a major issue. Especially because the sim engine in franchise mode does not have this issue. For me, this alone is a killer for franchise mode.

Madden 24 issue #2: 3-4 Defense Bug
This is a huge issue that EA will not even mention. While it is easy to fix for the user, it is only possible to fix for the CPU if you go in and change the depth chart for each team. While that is certainly doable, it is a ridiculous adjustment that we as players have to make in order for the game to play correctly.

M23 has neither of these issues. Yes, some M23 playbooks are a little too pass heavy, but that can be adjusted by a couple of playbooks adjustments for CPU teams. The 3-4 bug is simply not there for M23.

Another minor issue is penalties. While penalties are a problem in both games, I can consistently get a fair amount of penalties in M23 but not in M24.


Now, if none of the above bothers you, yes, M24 is a slightly better game. Not overwhelmingly better, but slightly better.

The playcalling was really the one that I couldn't get past. The run/pass ratios were so extreme.

What's the 3-4 defense bug?

[Iteachpercussion]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

The playcalling was really the one that I couldn't get past. The run/pass ratios were so extreme.

What's the 3-4 defense bug?

If you use a 3-4 defense, the Dline is in the wrong spot based on the depth chart. The LDE is fine in normal formations, but your 1st DT will play RDE and your 2nd DT will play Nose. Your RDE will not be on the field. Then the rushing DE positions cause further problems.

If can be "fixed" by making those adjustments on the depth chart, but in order to do that for the CPU in franchise you have to control the team you are going to play against and fix it. Also, as the used, if you use the in game adjustments and set the CBs match (i cannot remember the ingame terminology) it will fix it for the player.

It does not impact 4-3 defenses.

Oddly enough, custom playbooks do not have this issue either.

[IlluminatusUIUC]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

I play H2H and I've felt like 24 is superior to 23, with the very notable point that they took out the ability to choose how your AI defenders play passes in the air and hid Match coverage in the adjustments. Otherwise I think it plays a good game.


Madden 21 on the next Gen patch is still my favorite so far.

[Iteachpercussion]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

I play H2H and I've felt like 24 is superior to 23, with the very notable point that they took out the ability to choose how your AI defenders play passes in the air and hid Match coverage in the adjustments. Otherwise I think it plays a good game.


Madden 21 on the next Gen patch is still my favorite so far.

Madden 21 Next Gen is certainly a solid game and does not get the credit it deserves. Solid gameplay all the way around. Functional franchise mode (though without some bells and whistles we now have). I truly enjoy Madden 21!

[LocDawg5050]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

I play H2H and I've felt like 24 is superior to 23, with the very notable point that they took out the ability to choose how your AI defenders play passes in the air and hid Match coverage in the adjustments. Otherwise I think it plays a good game.


Madden 21 on the next Gen patch is still my favorite so far.

I concur with 21 next gen. Wish I knew a way to get updated Rosters on that on XSX.

The hits...sounds from the trenches... overall sound is spot on. I can't stand M23/24 silent tackles or line play.

Sent from my SM-S918U using Tapatalk

[gr18]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

The way I go through games by simming the first half and playing the 2nd works out perfect with run/pass ratios so for me 24 doesn't have any issues I can't get past.I'm happy with continuing with it and buying the college game this year.

[sabres32]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

The last Madden I bought was 18 until I finally bought 23. I had fun with it but it didn’t grab me like the game used to. I went to the attic, hooked up the Xbox 360 and am currently playing Madden 12. Im in year 3 of my franchise and I’m hooked. There are actually penalties called during games that stall out drives and play a role in the game. Injuries are beautiful in my franchise as it actually makes you have to mix things up. I always thought in the year 2024, Madden would be epic. Maybe one day?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Kanobi]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

I prefer '23 over '24. I poured more hours into '23 than any Madden game released in the last 10-12 years combined. I just recently got '24 from game pass and it's just not a big enough upgrade over '23 to warrant any more of my time or hard drive space. Plus, I prefer '23's gameplay, especially the war in the trenches and effectiveness of the pass rush.

[Breezy1844]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

I PREFER 23 OVA 24. 23 IS MORE REALISTIC 24 EVERYBODY IS GREAT. IN 24 AVERAGE RECIVERS HAVE RANDY MOSS HANDS, I DINT EVEN WANNA BEGIN TO CONTINUE TO COMPLAIN! IM BRINGING 23 BACK! IM IN THE MIDST OF COMPLETELY FINISHING A HEAD TO TOE ROSTER EDIT THAT INCLUDES EVERY M24 RATINGS AT EVERY POSITION FROM THE GREATS TO THE LOWER 50'S! AND IM IN THE PROCESS OF OFFSEASON FREE AGENCY CURRENT UP TO DATE AS IN AS OF MAY 22 2024. I GOT THE RATINGS FROM M24 AND ITS THE EXACT RATINGS AS IF THE GAME RATINGS TRANSFERED FROM THE LAST END OF SEASON PLAYER RATINGS UPDATE. I EVEN HAVE REALISTIC GAMEPLAY SLIDERS THAT MAKE THINGS MAKE SENSE LOGICALLY AS U SEE IT EVEN ON THE REPLAYS. MY GAMERTAG IS.... SenseiSatan#8355

[canes21]

Re: Madden 24 vs Madden 23

If they had fixed the 3-4 depth chart issues and the CPU play calling, I'd call Madden 24 the best Madden ever even with the lack of penalties and sliders not being efficient enough. It's not a gigantic leap over 23, but it was an improvement. However, the above issues do make it a tougher decision to choose between the two.