Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

[booker21]

https://www.reddit.com/r/Madden/comm...RN&sh=66e592aa

People will complain no matter what.

Sad but true.



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[BleedGreen710]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

the madden reddit is not "we" they have a very different community then the one we have here

[ginix]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

That post doesn't really look too dissimilar to things you see on here, just that on reddit they posted it as it's own thread.

Anyway, that's a pretty big overthrow. Yes, there should be more inaccuracy from QBs and this is certainly that but it doesn't look pretty.

[Black Bruce Wayne]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

the madden reddit is not "we" they have a very different community then the one we have here

This exactly. Reddit is completely separate from us, from this

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

[ForUntoOblivionSoar∞]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

the madden reddit is not "we" they have a very different community then the one we have here

Exactly. Look at the picture. Dude is playing with a ridiculously unrealistic uniform. Reddit is not a sim crowd like OS is.

[Klocker]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

Yea the perfect game will never be made. People need to just accept some things in life .. lol

I remember the good ole days when a game was released and that was it, no such things as patches or talking to devs.

And yet we still managed to have fun

[strawberryshortcake]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

I scrolled through the reddit comment section just for kicks, but there are people that do defend inaccurate throws.

[–]EliteTeamKiller 1 point 2 minutes ago
Tbh people like you are why we can't have a true NFL simulation game. You probably play MUT, the single most damaging game mode of all time, because the community is more interested in muh video games than an NFL simulation.
Not only do we need more inaccuracy, we need more drops and we need to significantly increase pass rush on obvious passing downs so players have to get rid of the ball in an average of 3 seconds like the real NFL.
You might like arcade crap, but I want an NFL simulation for the only NFL game there is...
sigh

[SmashMan]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

I mean...the poster is allowed to not like or want overthrows just like most of us here want more. Ideally that's why there are different game styles, to cater to everyone's different ways of playing.

Not sure we need to shame someone for not playing the game the same way we do. Come on, man.

[ForUntoOblivionSoar∞]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

I mean...the poster is allowed to not like or want overthrows just like most of us here want more. Ideally that's why there are different game styles, to cater to everyone's different ways of playing.

Not sure we need to shame someone for not playing the game the same way we do. Come on, man.

Maybe, but the more people like that the less likely the game the way we like it- realistic.

[thouse34]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

Maybe, but the more people like that the less likely the game the way we like it- realistic.

Ooooor and a big or here, we could figure out how to tune the game to create realistic missed throws, not misses that go 10 yards over your receivers head right into the arms of the safety... I've seen some seriously scripted interceptions. Real NFL Qb's miss, but they barely miss. There is sometime a miscommunication on the receivers route, but it's not that bad.

[SmashMan]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

Maybe, but the more people like that the less likely the game the way we like it- realistic.

Okay, so what's the next step? Do we drive those people away from the game because they don't play 100% realistically? Is there an OS rehab facility to condition them to only play the way we deem acceptable?

Or how about EA just makes sure the play style options work effectively, allowing everyone to have fun with the game however they want? That might work.


Sent from my iPad using Operation Sports

[goillini03]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

Okay, so what's the next step? Do we drive those people away from the game because they don't play 100% realistically? Is there an OS rehab facility to condition them to only play the way we deem acceptable?

Or how about EA just makes sure the play style options work effectively, allowing everyone to have fun with the game however they want? That might work.


Sent from my iPad using Operation Sports

Smash, you are right here. We just need the three styles to actually work 100% as they are intended.

[untrugby]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Madden/comm...RN&sh=66e592aa

People will complain no matter what.

Sad but true.



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Of course people will complain no matter what but I think the main issue here that previous versions of madden were more complete than the ones we have now. Think about the franchise mode in madden 2005 vs the one we have now. EA seems mostly focused MUT and sticks based gameplay which is not things that most who come here want.

[NimitsTexan]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

I mean...the poster is allowed to not like or want overthrows just like most of us here want more.

Not if he is playing sim mode, no, he is not. It would be illogical to want to play a simulation/realistic mode, but not want realistic game play.

[ForUntoOblivionSoar∞]

Re: Reddit post make me realize we will never be happy.

Okay, so what's the next step? Do we drive those people away from the game because they don't play 100% realistically? Is there an OS rehab facility to condition them to only play the way we deem acceptable?

Or how about EA just makes sure the play style options work effectively, allowing everyone to have fun with the game however they want? That might work.


Sent from my iPad using Operation Sports

If the three styles work right and sim plays like an NFL simulation than no. Otherwise yes. But that's just my opinion.