Is overtime handled incorrectly?

[petz_e]

Hi,

I just played my first regular season overtime in M19. The opponent won the coin toss and decided to receive. They scored a FIELD GOAL and the game was over. I lost.

I thought that I would get the ball back. There was no turnover, no interception, no fumble. The receiving team got a field goal in their first possession and the game was over.

EDIT: I should mention that where were still 1:58 minutes on the clock.

[Smokewood]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

Hi,

I just played my first regular season overtime in M19. The opponent won the coin toss and decided to receive. They scored a FIELD GOAL and the game was over. I lost.

I thought that I would get the ball back. There was no turnover, no interception, no fumble. The receiving team got a field goal in their first possession and the game was over.

Something strange happened to me too. I was in OT and got the ball first. This means a touchdown wins and a field goal gives the other team a chance. However I held the ball the entire OT and drove down to the 15 yard line, and called timeout with 1 second on the clock.

I figured I would kick the field goal as time was running out and win because no more time was left. I made the field goal as time ran out and thought I won. Nope, I had to kickoff to the other team and they put 7 minutes back on the clock....

[petz_e]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

Something strange happened to me too. I was in OT and got the ball first. This means a touchdown wins and a field goal gives the other team a chance. However I held the ball the entire OT and drove down to the 15 yard line, and called timeout with 1 second on the clock.

I figured I would kick the field goal as time was running out and win because no more time was left. I made the field goal as time ran out and thought I won. Nope, I had to kickoff to the other team and they put 7 minutes back on the clock....

Yeah, this also makes no sense. They got it wrong then... I hope this gets patched.

[coach422001]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

In another thread it was mentioned the NFL rule indicates each team must possess or have the opportunity to possess the ball, so (while I've never seen it) running the overtime clock out without giving the other team a chance to possess the ball and kicking a field goal may trigger added time to give the opponent a chance to possess the ball.

The first situation though losing the toss and giving up a field goal and the game ending is incorrect per the rules. Did you make mention of this in the bug/error thread? Odd again that Smokewood had a similar situation but the game continued but petz-e's game ended on first possession field goals.

[peapod0609]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

In another thread it was mentioned the NFL rule indicates each team must possess or have the opportunity to possess the ball, so (while I've never seen it) running the overtime clock out without giving the other team a chance to possess the ball and kicking a field goal may trigger added time to give the opponent a chance to possess the ball.

The first situation though losing the toss and giving up a field goal and the game ending is incorrect per the rules. Did you make mention of this in the bug/error thread? Odd again that Smokewood had a similar situation but the game continued but petz-e's game ended on first possession field goals.

That happened to me in Madden 18 as well where I ran out the whole quarter, kicked a field goal, and the game didn't end.

I am also not sure if that is correct or not. The other team is supposed to possess the ball, so it would not surprise me if they actually are supposed to essentially start a new overtime period.

[HakeemDaDream]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

You mean you guys can actually get to overtime?

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/Eafl7gGbzyY" frameborder="0" allow="autoplay; encrypted-media" allowfullscreen></iframe>

[SilverBullet19]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

Unless a touchdown is scored, each team must possess the ball.


So it was incorrect that they won on a field goal on the first possession. It was not incorrect that they got the ball after the user drained the whole clock and kicked a field goal with the first possession.

From what I can tell, OT has been buggy for sure.

[mixxx01]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

Something strange happened to me too. I was in OT and got the ball first. This means a touchdown wins and a field goal gives the other team a chance. However I held the ball the entire OT and drove down to the 15 yard line, and called timeout with 1 second on the clock.



I figured I would kick the field goal as time was running out and win because no more time was left. I made the field goal as time ran out and thought I won. Nope, I had to kickoff to the other team and they put 7 minutes back on the clock....

Wow that’s crazy. Not sim at all.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[mixxx01]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

Wow that’s crazy. Not sim at all.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Maybe I’m wrong I will research this.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[mixxx01]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

Unless a touchdown is scored, each team must possess the ball.





So it was incorrect that they won on a field goal on the first possession. It was not incorrect that they got the ball after the user drained the whole clock and kicked a field goal with the first possession.



From what I can tell, OT has been buggy for sure.

https://sports.stackexchange.com/que...ams-possession



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[mixxx01]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

We’ve never seen it happen in an NFL game so we actually don’t know. I say the game ends of clock runs out with out the second team scoring a fg in the allotted OT period.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[mixxx01]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

Unless a touchdown is scored, each team must possess the ball.





So it was incorrect that they won on a field goal on the first possession. It was not incorrect that they got the ball after the user drained the whole clock and kicked a field goal with the first possession.



From what I can tell, OT has been buggy for sure.

It can be ran out no time should be added.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2017/05/22/new-overtime-rule-could-let-receiving-team-win-with-just-a-field-goal/amp/

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Smokewood]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

In another thread it was mentioned the NFL rule indicates each team must possess or have the opportunity to possess the ball, so (while I've never seen it) running the overtime clock out without giving the other team a chance to possess the ball and kicking a field goal may trigger added time to give the opponent a chance to possess the ball.

I don't think so. If I hold the ball the entire OT and don't score at all the game will end at a tie.

So if I score a FG on the last play of OT, I should win.

[patsfan1993]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

Preseason and Regular Season-IF the team receiving the kickoff in Overtime drains the entire clock and kicks the go ahead fg as time expires the game is over. Rule 16 Article 4(a): "There shall be a maximum of one 10-minute period, even if the second team has not had an opportunity to possess the ball
or if its initial possession has not ended"

[IcedCoffee1983]

Re: Is overtime handled incorrectly?

OT was bugged last year too.

No way this gets patched if they didn’t bother to fix it over a whole development cycle.