Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

[bostonboy_003]

Hi guys i am a little confused about todays news and seeing conflicting opinions.

As we all know by now, there yet again will not be any Y2Y saves for '22. However, does this include Rosters? Will there be a way to import rosters into 22? That is the ultimate decider of whether or not I will buy the game. THat would be INSANE if we cant import rosters to 22, but I wouldnt put it past them. Hours and hours and hours of work by roster creators would be wasted - that doesnt seem right to me.

Can someone help clarify this for me?

[KnightTemplar]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

Hi guys i am a little confused about todays news and seeing conflicting opinions.

As we all know by now, there yet again will not be any Y2Y saves for '22. However, does this include Rosters? Will there be a way to import rosters into 22? That is the ultimate decider of whether or not I will buy the game. THat would be INSANE if we cant import rosters to 22, but I wouldnt put it past them. Hours and hours and hours of work by roster creators would be wasted - that doesnt seem right to me.

Can someone help clarify this for me?

In my opinion the most overlooked part of this game. The junk roster they release with the game is unexplainable.

[ninertravel]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

seeing as last year they took out the import option of previous years rosters I can't see that returning again either this year and now that it is on the switch that will 100% confirm it as they don't have a previous years game. same issue with xbox last year.

We can hope for it but early signs point to 'no chance' with no Y2Y saves again. so mlb 20 will remain the only game where you could import older rosters.. so yes more months of work again to be made from scratch get your videos ready to record 21 players and moving them to 22 which takes 30 min per player

[bostonboy_003]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

In my opinion the most overlooked part of this game. The junk roster they release with the game is unexplainable.

Completely agree. The full minors rosters, classic rosters, and even Bacons rosters are the only reason i still buy the game since im not into the Diamond Dynasty crap. I truly would be upset if roster dont even carry over. Like i said in OP, that is a slap in the face to roster creators who likely spend the time and energy creating rosters that they assumed would be able to transfer over to 22.

I saw that Logos uploaded to the vault will automatically transfer. Maybe thats a good sign? but stadiums dont transfer, so now i dont know again. I need a definitive answer on this ASAP!!

[ninertravel]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

So what I am going to do now is take videos of faces from mlb 21 that I know won't be in 22 of players to be added for 22 and move them across when the game comes out in April.

start making videos now over the next few months over my phone transferring it to my PC all ready in prep I have 2 months

I am using my PC to create players for remote play between 2 screens one screen has the MLB 21 players face video and the other remote play PS app is running in 22 and I just copy the face numbers across watching the video

So that is what I will be doing come April 5 (and pray baseball will actually be on to have in the background while I am doing it)

I advice others to do the same so you are all ready April 5. it does take 30 mins per player it it a lot of work but if you have those videos ready it becomes easier. just move them from your phone to PC if you run out of room and do it remotely.

[ChaseB]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

Could you download rosters created on Xbox One for '21 and use them on PS4 etc.? I forget off the top of my head. If you can do that, I don't see why the roster carryover couldn't be a thing again from 21 to 22. But if it was tied to each console, I'd be less surprised if it were included for this year.

That said, I do think it's the thing that would likely come back before SOTS or carryover saves. The SOTS thing is almost certainly a console (and perhaps legal) issue that Sony/Microsoft just don't want to deal with, and carryover saves is most likely more technical than rosters as well.

[ninertravel]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

Could you download rosters created on Xbox One for '21 and use them on PS4 etc.? I forget off the top of my head. If you can do that, I don't see why the roster carryover couldn't be a thing again from 21 to 22. But if it was tied to each console, I'd be less surprised if it were included for this year.

That said, I do think it's the thing that would likely come back before SOTS or carryover saves. The SOTS thing is almost certainly a console (and perhaps legal) issue that Sony/Microsoft just don't want to deal with, and carryover saves is most likely more technical than rosters as well.

You could but the vault would always come back with a error that it didn't work but it actually did/. (they never fixed it)

but now with the switch they don't have MLB 21 so this is why like last year when Xbox didn't have MLB 20 I can see why they won't have it in again this years game.

[Houston]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

What no y2y saves mean is EXACTLY that! You or anyone else will have no option to load or transfer any franchise or roster to MLB 22. No one and I mean no one (THE ROCK) LOL will get on 22 and be able to load any 21 franchise or roster files.

Sent from my SM-A215U using Operation Sports mobile app

[ninertravel]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

What no y2y saves mean is EXACTLY that! You or anyone else will have no option to load or transfer any franchise or roster to MLB 22. No one and I mean no one (THE ROCK) LOL will get on 22 and be able to load any 21 franchise or roster files.

Sent from my SM-A215U using Operation Sports mobile app

Yep and what’s ridiculous here id the player templates will be the same again. So rather they give the option for the vault as well it’s “ nah spend 6 months of work again doing what you did before”

[PS9119]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

I'm KISS75 in the vaults. I AM DONE WITH MAKING CAPS. SDS is the new EA NO Y2Y SAVES!
[emoji35][emoji35][emoji35][emoji35][emoji35]20220201_024514_HDR.jpeg

Sent from my LM-K500 using Operation Sports mobile app

[lemarflacco]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

So what I am going to do now is take videos of faces from mlb 21 that I know won't be in 22 of players to be added for 22 and move them across when the game comes out in April.

start making videos now over the next few months over my phone transferring it to my PC all ready in prep I have 2 months

I am using my PC to create players for remote play between 2 screens one screen has the MLB 21 players face video and the other remote play PS app is running in 22 and I just copy the face numbers across watching the video

So that is what I will be doing come April 5 (and pray baseball will actually be on to have in the background while I am doing it)

I advice others to do the same so you are all ready April 5. it does take 30 mins per player it it a lot of work but if you have those videos ready it becomes easier. just move them from your phone to PC if you run out of room and do it remotely.

Thats insane. I think using two screens may be easier once the game cones out

[Madden08PCgmr]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

Franchise saves are one thing. I can understand porting issues there. Don't like it, but I do get it.

Roster saves? No sir. Inexcusable. Its just data. Essentially copying one Excel sheet over another. Unless they're adding roster spots, or overhauling player appearance, which we can safely assume they are not.

Diamond Dynasty must really be going strong to deliberately alienate such a huge portion of the fanbase.

.. and no PC release means we're still that much farther away from a roster editor, which is the REAL solution to this problem.

[ChaseB]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

You could but the vault would always come back with a error that it didn't work but it actually did/. (they never fixed it)

but now with the switch they don't have MLB 21 so this is why like last year when Xbox didn't have MLB 20 I can see why they won't have it in again this years game.

Oh that's true, it probably does add a little roadblock in for this year. Still think it's more likely rosters transferring (outside of a franchise) seems like a more logical next step to "normalcy" than normal Y2Y saves though.

[JoshC1977]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

Oh that's true, it probably does add a little roadblock in for this year. Still think it's more likely rosters transferring (outside of a franchise) seems like a more logical next step to "normalcy" than normal Y2Y saves though.

I'll be honest....I could much more easily stomach not having Y2Y franchise carryovers if we could at least import rosters from the previous years. Even playing every game, I could easily knock-out 3 seasons in a cycle if I had Bacon's roster from the date of launch.

[Karle]

Re: Does "No Y2Y Saves" Include Rosters in the Vault?

Being able to transfer my MLB 21 roster over to MLB 22 would be enough to make me happy. However, I expect that in MLB 22 such roster transfers will not be possible.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Operation Sports mobile app