I realized that the first game I played I played on default game time, I think it was 6 minutes. After that I changed the quarter length to 10 minutes. So today i changed the length back to 6 minutes and it worked, I had post game highlights again.
Does anyone know a work around for this bug? I would hate to have to sacrifice realistic stats in order to be able to see end game highlights (one of my favorite things, especially with the awesome graphics on next gen). Or does anyone know if 2K is aware of this and working on fixing it? I did submit a bug report on 2K sports website, not sure if that will lead to anything.

Comment