NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

[elbens01]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

i know its only been a couple of days, and i havent read through this thread, but has the ea guy come back to check in on this thread or given any possible solution?

I know that they have come out here and acknowledged there is a roster problem, but guys i do not think that we have as much power or say so as you think we do. The people who post on these type of threads are geeks for college football. Me being one of them. If you notice, there are only about 40 of us who consistantly post and there are hardly ever 200 people on here at a time. I think you guys are overestimating how much pull you think we have. yes we brought the roster thing to their attention, but lets just say for arguements sake that ncaa 10 sells 1 milion copies. Well the people like us probably only make up between 5 and 10 percent of that number, MAYBE. I am sure that they will search for a solution, but they arent going to delay release or screw up any new features just because less than a hundred people on some forums are pissed. Thats just my opinion. So i think people should just chill out and if you dont like the game dont buy it.

You might be right about this until it comes out and the average fan buys it and realizes how f'ed up it is. That average fan will remember it and not buy the game next year. EA may not lose much this year but down the road they will. So they better pay attention to what is said on forums like this because it is a built in focus group on how their product will be received.

Not trying to sound like an internet tough guy I am just trying to be realistic. If this is how loyal purchasers feel how do think the more fickle casual buyer will feel?

[icmOU72]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

oh i am not abandoning hope yet. I just feel like beating up the dev team isnt going to get us anywhere and we should sit back and relax and give them a chance to fix the problem to the best of their ability.

[bdawkins20]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

Not to be a pessimist, okay maybe I am, but if attempts are being made to resolve the roster issue why is the Teambuilder site still running?

[icmOU72]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

I feel like the casual buy will get the game and play online dynasty, but will not play with their favorite team whose roster may or may not be screwed up on July 14 (depending on if they can fix it), they will use florida and ohio state, whose roster are right for the most part. Out side of that, i believe that a lot of casual fans will find teambuilder really cool and will play with their created team.

I am not tryin to be a tough guy on here either and i like this discussion and seeing points of view that are different than mine. A good conversation is fun as long as we dont get too fired up.

[GigemAGGIES13]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

Not to be a pessimist, okay maybe I am, but if attempts are being made to resolve the roster issue why is the Teambuilder site still running?

My guess is that they quickly ruled out any solution that affects TeamBuilder.

[Drocks]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

Not to be a pessimist, okay maybe I am, but if attempts are being made to resolve the roster issue why is the Teambuilder site still running?

They've already said they're not gonna just immediately blow up Teambuilder if they don't need to, and I don't think they should. They should try to keep it and still fix the issue. When push comes to shove though, in the end, if re-tooling the Teambuilder site is a necessity in order to get the roster fix on the disc, I hope they make the right decision.

[auburntigersfan]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

so...out of all the possible problems they could have, the problem is one quarter of the players did not make the game. wow.

[marcoyk]

hahahaha yeah just a small part of the game, right?

[icmOU72]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

is it possible that they can fix the roster and then just replace the one on teambuilder site with a new roster file? or do they have to actually go back and use the existing roster and just update it?

[MrArlingtonBeach]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

So first we have 2K that completely screws up their MLB game with an completely dysfunctional Franchise mode and severely limited editing options.

Then SCEA released a patch for The Show that caused in-progress RTTS and Franchise modes to freeze (or something like that...I don't have a PS3. I only know the basics & what I read on here).

Now EA can't get rosters straight on their NCAA Football game.

This year has been rough on sports gamers...

I can't wait until glaring weaknesses in Madden, the NHL games, etc. are discovered.

[KingVMSU]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

Whats the bigger screw up?

Sliders that dont work or bunk rosters?

Neither should ever happen....back to back years nonetheless.

EA was in a position to really earn the consumers trust back after last years debacle, instead they dug the hole deeper.

[callmetaternuts]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

so...out of all the possible problems they could have, the problem is one quarter of the players did not make the game. wow.

Remember, the game isnt out yet so A) they could fix it and we would never notice or B) there could be other big issues.

Take whichever option suits you best. Im just hopeful that it all gets ironed out. Its a big deal, but the fact that its before the game is out lends credence that A) their should be MORE community involvement prior to game going gold to catch this stuff B) we are making a difference and C) that nothing is a foregone conclusion.

Bringing in outside help seems the most obvious. Don't writers have editors? Dont athlete have coaches (swing coaches, strength coaches)? AN outside eye can diagnose issues sometimes as they arent biased and they havent been looking at the code/writing for months on end.

[DoubleDeuce]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

So did this only get figured out when people looked at the rosters on the Teambuilder site? If so, at least Teambuilder is good for something. Otherwise nobody would have realized this until after we had paid our money to buy the game.

[jaydee6385]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

Good point Deuce. I'd be pissed if these rosters surprised me first day.

[nxt]

Re: NCAA Football 10 Rosters Issue

Whats the bigger screw up?

Sliders that dont work or bunk rosters?

Neither should ever happen....back to back years nonetheless.

EA was in a position to really earn the consumers trust back after last years debacle, instead they dug the hole deeper.

QFT. If this is not resolved before July 14, I seriously hope the word of these roster problems spread throughout the land and sales for NCAA drop dramatically. This is an absolute outrage!!!