I see your point, but by default on All Star I found that free throws are a good challenge for shooters who shoot 80% or above; however your 60-79% shooters become horendous. Obviously the more you play the easier it will get and you can adjust that rating as needed to suit your needs. Personally I believe where Live is flawed, I miss their right analog stick free throw mechanic, but 2Ks is by far the best when it comes to free throw mechanics.