I am looking for every game to be different. To see something each game that I haven't seen before.
Of all the sports games that have been made this gen, I think that Backbreaker, despite it's flaws, is the game that has had the most innovation. True RTP is a source of endless replay value. I really hope that are going to make a sequel, because if they improve upon this foundation, it will be an instant classic.
Every single sports game should offer the option to save/upload/download replays at least. Entire games to be truly innovative. It would be awesome to save your entire football season, and make an NFL Films type movie, highlighting the up and downs of a season.