[ambizytl]

Quote: Originally Posted by at23steelers

CJ had one fantastic year and two good years, while Foster had 1 great year. No I wouldn't have CJ a 99 ovr. I would have him around 96 ovr. AP had 4 good years in a row, so I would give him a 98 ovr. CJ last year receiving yards: 50 catches 503 yards and 2 TD's Foster this year receiving yards: 66 catches 606 yards and 2 TD's However, Chris Johnson had a better season before that one with 1,200 yards. Not to mention the two years we are comparing, CJ had 400 more rushing yards. So, yeah that deserves a 96 overall in Madden. Now, with his scaled back ratings: a 94 ovr AP, 93 over CJ, and a 91 ovr Foster is what I would do.

This is Foster's second year--and how many rushing attempts did he have last year? 6 games, 54 attempts, 4.8 avg per attempt.

AP has been a fumbler, but this year he was good, just 1 fumble. Do you change his carry rating based on this year?