Top Five EA NCAA Football Games of All Time

[Balrog]

06 was by far the best for me.

[MachoMyers]

Re: Top Five EA NCAA Football Games of All Time

My same list. NCAA '04 will go down as my favorite game ever. So awesome.

[bkrich83]

Re: Top Five EA NCAA Football Games of All Time

I loved 2004. I had an **** Hawaii dynasty in 04 AND i loved the SI covers. Man that game was good

I ram with Hawaii on 2004 as well. To this date still my all tome favorite dynasty experience.

[toyblue]

Re: Top Five EA NCAA Football Games of All Time

Great list! Also, my first choice for #3 was NCAA '98. However, you're right about NCAA '99 being a better selection. While the '06 version was awesome, it was the continued evolution of the '04 version when everything came together. I remember going through recruiting, checking the results, then starting over just to see if I could earn a better class. I didn't even mind that Carson Palmer was the cover!

One word. Addictive.

[Renard]

I had a gamecube cause I was a loser i guess haha...

But my favorite was NCAA 2005..

I LOVED it and still do dynasties on it to this day!

Best sports game to me.... but hey I also liked Madden 2005 as well lol

[phade3]

My list would be:

Bill Walsh College Football '95

Bill Walsh College Football

NCAA Football '06

NCAA Football '98

NCAA Football '04

[blamalex]

'06 was the greatest. I miss the celebrations and seeing you're team on the magazines. You could even add pride stickers to your created schools. They had FCS Rosters too.

[MetalCavs]

NCAA 2005 was an improved version 2004 , still playing it

[ryan]

Re: Top Five EA NCAA Football Games of All Time

which NCAA had the catching meter where it seemed everyone dropped passes? 2004?

[Bigsheen]

05 is probably my favorite ever just because it was the first one i owned. I had played them since 99 but didnt get a ps2 till the 05 game.

[Renard]

Finally some love for NCAA 05...

The mag covers were there... Recruiting was simple.. Speed killed.. Coaching contracts were legit...

Love the new ones... but it is still a classic.. Dynasty mode rocked!

[Bumble14]

05 was the one plagued with the dropped pass issue--killed that game for me.

[coogrfan]

Re: Top Five EA NCAA Football Games of All Time

05 was the one plagued with the dropped pass issue--killed that game for me.

That...and beachball physics. 05 was a dog, imo.

[baufan2005]

No Bill Walsh college football? List fail.

[DoomsDayD1978]

Re: Top Five EA NCAA Football Games of All Time

That...and beachball physics. 05 was a dog, imo.

Gotta agree...05 was an absolute trainwreck!