This video game represents the sport of football and claims to be a "football simulator." So, I don't understand what you're trying to really say. If that is your attitude towards the game, then OS might not be the best place for you.
On topic, I say cheese. On default sliders you're going to have nearly no risk going for a strip every tackle. The sliders I use have tackle near 0, or maybe even 0, I don't remember exactly, but I hardly ever go for a strip unless the ball carrier is already wrapped up by another defender also, or I really need a strip no matter what. Going for a strip with the tackle slider lower results in a broken tackle 8/10 times in my dynasty for me and the CPU.