Made my own ratings calculator

[The Kid 24]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

I'm surprised with Cabrera's power rating being at 75/69 that he still is among the leaders in HR's.

[The Kid 24]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

Scott... Do you plan on editing all the offenses in your franchise using this calculator? Also how drastic were ratings from the calculator to The Show's ratings?

[Scott]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

Scott... Do you plan on editing all the offenses in your franchise using this calculator? Also how drastic were ratings from the calculator to The Show's ratings?

They weren't real drastic. Yes, once V3 comes out with pitch edits, i plan on using this system.

[OSfan093]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

These look pretty good, i have a couple question though. 1st, are con vs. righty and con vs. lefty treated the same. what i mean is, if you have a guy who hits .270 vs lefties and .270 vs righties in the same year, he will have exactly the same rating for con vs. left and vs. right correct? (this is a hypothetical situation)

also, i see that you use RISP for clutch, that is good to see. My question is do you take into account their normal batting average. Because clutch is a MODIFIER so if you just did their avg. w/ RISP then it will be slightly misleading. This is because, lets say a guy hits .330 w/o RISP but hits .300 w/ RISP, he shouldn't have a good clutch rating in game, since it modifies his ratings. he would have high contact but low clutch. Is that how your system works, or would he have high contact and pretty high clutch too? (sorry if that sounds confusing)

[Scott]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

These look pretty good, i have a couple question though. 1st, are con vs. righty and con vs. lefty treated the same. what i mean is, if you have a guy who hits .270 vs lefties and .270 vs righties in the same year, he will have exactly the same rating for con vs. left and vs. right correct? (this is a hypothetical situation)

also, i see that you use RISP for clutch, that is good to see. My question is do you take into account their normal batting average. Because clutch is a MODIFIER so if you just did their avg. w/ RISP then it will be slightly misleading. This is because, lets say a guy hits .330 w/o RISP but hits .300 w/ RISP, he shouldn't have a good clutch rating in game, since it modifies his ratings. he would have high contact but low clutch. Is that how your system works, or would he have high contact and pretty high clutch too? (sorry if that sounds confusing)

Personally I think Clutch should be determined by RC...

But that's also an Advanced Batting stat that would have to added for every person.

[tbbucsfan001]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

Personally I think Clutch should be determined by RC...

But that's also an Advanced Batting stat that would have to added for every person.

It has been established that Clutch is simply AVG RISP and other factors like stolen bases and 3B/2B ratio factor into RC.

[Scott]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

It has been established that Clutch is simply AVG RISP and other factors like stolen bases and 3B/2B ratio factor into RC.

Oh okay, I gotcha.

[tbbucsfan001]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

Oh okay, I gotcha.

Russell came out and said that pretty bluntly.

[DeathMetal]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

Take a look at the stats that me and tbbucsfan posted. They look very accurate. DM have you thought of using 2012 ZiPS Projections instead of 3 year splits?

With ZiPS, here are Bautista's ratings...

RC - 68
LC - 70
RP - 96
LP - 96
V - 53
D - 99
CL - 69

I've never even heard of ZiPS before, heh. I'll look into it.

Yeah I do believe so...My last simulation I had just 6 players hit 36+ HRs...and just 9 players hit over 100+ RBIs. (AL ONLY).

I think if there is someway we can implement Baserunning (BR/BA), Durability (which I have a formula for), and Fielding (Arm Str/Arm Acc/Fielding Ability), it would be perfect.

Edit: There's already a spot in the spreadsheets for Games, just wasn't filled in. If that gets filled in, all you need is a formula that reads (GP/162)*100. Though BR & BA is more difficult to get implemented.

I actually implemented that exact formula the other night. Of course it will take a while to get that info into the databases for the auto calculator, but for the time being the manual calculator can be used to find durability ratings if you don't mind a bit of stat searching on the internet. I'll upload the newest version now.

[DeathMetal]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

These look pretty good, i have a couple question though. 1st, are con vs. righty and con vs. lefty treated the same. what i mean is, if you have a guy who hits .270 vs lefties and .270 vs righties in the same year, he will have exactly the same rating for con vs. left and vs. right correct? (this is a hypothetical situation)

also, i see that you use RISP for clutch, that is good to see. My question is do you take into account their normal batting average. Because clutch is a MODIFIER so if you just did their avg. w/ RISP then it will be slightly misleading. This is because, lets say a guy hits .330 w/o RISP but hits .300 w/ RISP, he shouldn't have a good clutch rating in game, since it modifies his ratings. he would have high contact but low clutch. Is that how your system works, or would he have high contact and pretty high clutch too? (sorry if that sounds confusing)

Yes, if R and L averages are the same, the ratings will be the same. As for clutch, I just use their average with RISP to calculate the rating. There seems to be a good mix of guys who have a high batting avg but a low RISP avg, and the other way around.

[Scott]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

I've never even heard of ZiPS before, heh. I'll look into it.



I actually implemented that exact formula the other night. Of course it will take a while to get that info into the databases for the auto calculator, but for the time being the manual calculator can be used if you don't mind a bit of stat searching on the internet. I'll upload the newest version now.

I have the ZiPS projections in spreadsheet form and it also has L/R splits. I can email it to you. Have you thought of a good way to calculate baserunning and fielding? The only thing with ZiPS is that it doesn't offer RISP AB.

[DeathMetal]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

I have the ZiPS projections in spreadsheet form and it also has L/R splits. I can email it to you. Have you thought of a good way to calculate baserunning and fielding? The only thing with ZiPS is that it doesn't offer RISP AB.

Okay, I'll PM you my email. As for fielding and baserunning, I haven't really worked on it yet, and that is more information that I would have to add into the player databases.

[Scott]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

Okay, I'll PM you my email. As for fielding and baserunning, I haven't really worked on it yet, and that is more information that I would have to add into the player databases.

That's true, baserunning and fielding could probably be left alone. I'll send you the file but the format we have now is probably the best one, and it's generating realistic results.

[spboden]

Re: Made my own ratings calculator

Hey Scott,

Thanks for all your input....I know you said you would put them in once V3 came out.....when that does happen, will you be placing this on the roster valut? thanks again.....

[Scott]

Hey Scott,

Thanks for all your input....I know you said you would put them in once V3 came out.....when that does happen, will you be placing this on the roster valut? thanks again.....

Yeah I can.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk