Can't speak for others, but at this stage of the game (on PS4) I scored my first 8 points shooting over 80%. The commentators in game said I completed the goal ("he stepped up" or whatever) but the in game player rating kept saying it was an active goal. By the end of the game I had dropped 50 points while shooting well over 60% and despite that, the cut scene was still the coach saying how I failed and how my minutes were to be cut.
Again, I accomplished what the dynamic goal was (by a lot), triggered the in game commentary and still got the "you failed" cut scene. It's definitely a bug of some kind.