I don't know, maybe it's just me but I actually think this game is incredible. Easily the best sports sim around, there are a few annoying glitches like the casual outfielder throw, or the infielder running over a grounder but in the 40 games I've played these things have happened in maybe 5 games.
The only thing I find really annoying is the same sign wielding fan shown during the lineup introduction screen every damn game. Come up with some new material, sign boy!