Your tired of reading people state that the animations look poor, and they move like robots? Why do you think you keep reading that? Because the game does does look and play like that.
What does NBA 2k have to do with it? This isn't a 2k vs EA war discussion, it's about Madden 15. The animations are still poor, and there are already many post that stated this after the ign video. It's not hate, it's fact. You can't expect everyone to just fall in love with everything Madden does, because you like it. People just stating what their eyes see.
The graphics look much improved though. Got to give them props for that. I wasn't going to buy the game this year, but the upgrade in visuals might actually get me to pick it up.