SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

[Mizzou24]

In this thread we will discuss possible changes for the next version that will include equip edits for every team..


If u want something justified because I could have missed something/ over did something in my tedious amounts of hours working on this ... If you want it fixed speak up fellas and i will look into every issue..



POSSIBLE ERRORS/RATINGS ISSUES

Reds
- Brandon Phillips speed

- Alex Claudio velocity check

- Red Sox positional check( this is how we had them and I was advised to change them)
Lower Ortiz speed
Brock holt speed eval
Ped speed eval
Bradley jr arm strength and arm accuracy change

Dodgers
- Puig accuracy eval

Yankees
- Team colors on edits need fixed.
- possibly find a way to get tanakas name pronounced..( more than likely will have to import scea current tanaka and redo the face.)

-Mason Williams(NYY) should be
Bat : L

Throw : L

Giants

- Gary Brown (SF) should be
Bat : R

Throw : R

Arizona
- Brandin Hagins missing from Arizona.

- Randall Delgado needs to be a RP.

- Jimmie Sherfy has an extra space in his name after his first name that needs to get deleted.

Stros


- Chris Epps(LF?) was released at the beginning of May.

- Jake Rodriguez (C) shouldn't be there. Roberto Pena or Jacob Nottingham should have that spot.

- Ross Seaton(P) was an unexpected name on the roster. Kent Emanuel should have that spot.

Rays
Matt Moore k/9 slight boost

[ilstu24]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Check Alex Claudio's Pitch Speeds. Don't know if you can replicate his change up, but velocities on all pitches needs to drop.

[turty11]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

boston:

kelly johnson should be 3b, LF
mookie betts should be CF, RF
tom layne RP instead of CP
daniel nava should be LF , RF

i want to say cespedes should be LF, and victorino should be CF assuming thats how theyd lineup if craig/vic were healthy but this is just assuming farrell gets his head out of...ill edit this after i go through more stuff

my opinions on some quick ratings (since ive wtched litterally 95% of redsox games the past 3 years)

i think ortiz should have a 0 for speed, 5 max..to replicate his jog it off to 1st play since everyone goes max effort in this game

brock holt should have a speed of mid-upper 70's
pedy speed about a 65-70
pedy holt and bradley need a power re-rate badly (had some sims holt/pedy hit 30+ homers lol)
jackie bradley SHOULD have a 99 arm strength, and 90's for reaction/fielding/arm accuracy (hes the best defensive CF, possibly OF in baseball right now)

[Mizzou24]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

boston:

kelly johnson should be 3b, LF
mookie betts should be CF, RF
will middlebrooks should be 3b, 1b


i want to say cespedes should be LF, and victorino should be CF assuming thats how theyd lineup if craig/vic were healthy but this is just assuming farrell gets his head out of...ill edit this after i go through more stuff

I believe I had most of this set up thst way but I was told but one of my roster advisors that they needed to move.

[rjackson]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Some of these can be difficult though. Betts is established as a 2B and that was his primary position for years, right? He is just playing OF to get him onto the field was my impression. Not a Red Sox follower so maybe I'm wrong about the playing time but if his primary position is that of 2B...

[turty11]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

hes officially been converted to a full time OF now. (i think his agent may have even requested a positional change after the pedy contract)

he should be CF , OF or CF , 2B

i can go through every team's positions quickly if wanted

[DTX3]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Matt Kemp plays RF now and I think Dee Gordon's base stealing should be higher as he's currently at 79 I believe. He leads MLB with 54 stolen bases. Miguel Rojas is a way better fielder than Hanley. Just my 2 cents.

[turty11]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

dee gordon is 54/67 which is 80% so that 79s perfect imo

if your issue is with how many he gets during the sim season its 100% due to hard caps placed into the sim engine

[Mizzou24]

SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Matt Kemp plays RF now and I think Dee Gordon's base stealing should be higher as he's currently at 79 I believe. He leads MLB with 54 stolen bases. Miguel Rojas is a way better fielder than Hanley. Just my 2 cents.

Gordon is gtg. I can't enforce anymore steal frequencies it just doesn't produce em.. Even at 100 aggressiveness.

[Mizzou24]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Btw guys pleae don't list guys who should be in MLB they are in the mlb because of injuries.. If a player wasn't in the 60 day DL then their replacement isn't in the majors.

[Cavicchi]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

I assume potential was not changed, Strasburg and Harper still at 98.

Puig is with same arm accuracy as Matt Kemp, which is contrary to what I've seen watching Dodger games. Puig has a highly accurate arm.

Stanton and Posey with higher contact ratings than Jose Abreu is not in line with reality. Abreu is around .300 and the others--check it out.

Stanton has a bit more power rating but per at bats, Abreu has hit more home runs.

I didn't look any further than those above and Lucroy, which was nice to see his fielding rating more accurately reproduced.

[ryebread284]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Derek jeter has color edits wrong. Don't know if it's team colors that are wrong or what, has the right gear just wrong colors

[Warehouse]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

I assume potential was not changed, Strasburg and Harper still at 98.

Puig is with same arm accuracy as Matt Kemp, which is contrary to what I've seen watching Dodger games. Puig has a highly accurate arm.

Stanton and Posey with higher contact ratings than Jose Abreu is not in line with reality. Abreu is around .300 and the others--check it out.

Stanton has a bit more power rating but per at bats, Abreu has hit more home runs.

I didn't look any further than those above and Lucroy, which was nice to see his fielding rating more accurately reproduced.

it's important to remember that ratings were done based on a formula inspired by Steamer's projections. Stanton's prior seasons' track record probably explains his higher power than Abreu, despite this year's home run numbers.

[Mizzou24]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

I assume potential was not changed, Strasburg and Harper still at 98.



Puig is with same arm accuracy as Matt Kemp, which is contrary to what I've seen watching Dodger games. Puig has a highly accurate arm.



Stanton and Posey with higher contact ratings than Jose Abreu is not in line with reality. Abreu is around .300 and the others--check it out.



Stanton has a bit more power rating but per at bats, Abreu has hit more home runs.



I didn't look any further than those above and Lucroy, which was nice to see his fielding rating more accurately reproduced.

More to look at with Stanton and posey.. Check Stanton's vision vs abreu. Also this was weighed with projections as well.. Abreu is still a terror just didn't want to overly power him based on his one year. He's got room to grow.

[ryebread284]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Actually looks like it's the whole Yankee squad with wrong colors