SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

[turty11]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Yeah, if the sim engine was better, we likely wouldn't even be having a discussion over power ratings.

dont worry i got that figured out

now its about the real fune tining

[Pacalon]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Just started my As franny so I'll post issues as I see them for ya.

First thing I noticed is coco crisp. He's a lot slower than id expect, as he's one of our faster guys behind burns and gentry. Also coco and sogard need their stealing upped. Gentry leads the team with 18 steals and has only been caught once. Coco is in 2nd with 16 steals, caught 4 times, and sogard is in 3rd with 10 steals and caught twice. Coco specifically had these SB numbers the last 4 years: 32, 49, 39, 21. A bit of a drop off this year and last due to DL trips, but he should prob be higher than 78 spd and 79 steal. Sogard also only has 72 steal and could use a slight bump, but he may be pretty close to right.

Also another thing I noticed is josh reddick. His arm looks pretty good, his contact seems a bit low (61, 55) as he's been performing way better since he came back off the DL. His batting average is about the same as moss (who you have at 78, 79 contact) albeit without as many hrs. Reddick also only has 47 br aggression. But he leads the As in triples even though he's only played 75 games.

On a similar note Donaldson and lowrie could use a br aggression bump. They're 1 and 2 on the as for doubles and have 11 and 9 br agression respectively.

Il keep lookin as I go. Lookin good so far though!

[ryebread284]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Shouldn't Brett Gardner have more speed?

[detroitskills]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

i wouldnt call this a mistake,(because i fully trust thecalculations) just curious, why is rajai davis' speed AND stealing kinda low, is it for sim stats?

other than that, jd martinez needs number 28, only mistake ive really stumbled upon, good stuff

[turty11]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

as of now i have the sim engine spitting at highs for complete games @ 3 to 5 and the occasional 7 if someone has a cy season (only seen with pitchers like wainwright/felix)

Hr's are down to mid-high 30's very low 40's at best

----but this all hinges on a complete re-look and fix of positions so poor person who has to do that lol!


as for rajai, he probly needs a 5 bump to steal...hes only succesfull 77% of the time, so id stick him at a 77 :P speed is about right, maybe could go up to 85

[bravesfan1984]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

mizzou, i went through and found a couple guys not in the roster that are on the 40 man roster:

Hagens for ARZ
Jon Edwards TEX
Leesman CWS (just dfa'd though)


also for the braves, jr graham should be RP and salcedo primary should be RF with 3B secondary.

[ShowTyme15]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Cubs Dan Straily #19

[FamousJamie]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

O's Dariel Alvarez should have stronger arm. Showalter says its strongest in organization

[turty11]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

someones gonna hate me, but im going to post a giant list of suggested position changes

[gman2774]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

someones gonna hate me, but im going to post a giant list of suggested position changes

turty....I'm confused and hoping you can help. Roster version 1 is complete and in the vault. However, they do not include equipment edits, correct? Equipment edits are being worked on by a host of participants and once complete will be re-posted?

[MikeMick21]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Correct, they are not included in this version.. They are however being done now.

[Cavicchi]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

The only things that bother me with these rosters is the potentials and overalls... I am an orioles fan and no way should Gausman be a 95 potential. Carlos Martinez was up there too if I remember correctly. I think anything that high should be for Trout, Kershaw, Jose Fernandez, Sale, Machado and Puig type players. The overalls I don't really look at for each player so I am not complaining about that its just that there are 80 or so players I think rated 90 and above which just seems so high to me and not really separating the elite from the above average and so on.

Gausman is a 95 potential and Chris Sale is a 93, very interesting. Carlos Martinez is way up there, walks?

[turty11]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

going to use this as my post to update with recomended position fixes

bal

Spoiler

steve pearce LF, 1B
ryan flaherty 3B, 2B/SS
david lough LF, CF
nick markakis RF
delmon young LF
chris davis 1B
manny machado 3B
adam jons CF
nick markakis RF

bos

Spoiler

kelly johnson 1B, 3B
mookie betts Cf, RF
Brock Holt 3B, 2B/SS
Xander Bogaerts SS
Cespedes RF, OF
Allen Craig LF, 1B
Jackie Bradley Jr CF
shane victorino LF, OF
daniel nava LF, RF

nyy

Spoiler

brendan ryan 2B, SS
martin prado RF, 3B
brett gardner LF, CF
jacoby ellsbury CF
carlos betran RF
francisco cervelli C

tampa

Spoiler

jose molina C
ben zobrist 2B, SS
logan forsythe 2B
sean rodriguez 2B, LF
yunel sescobar SS
brandon guyer LF
david dejesus LF
desmond jennings CF
will myers RF
kevin kiermaier RF, CF

toronto

Spoiler

edwin encarnacion 1B
adam lind 1B
brett lawrie 3B, 2B
steve tolleson 2B, 3B
jaun francisco 3B, 1B
danny valencia 3B
melky cabrera LF
jose bautista RF, CF
nolan reimold RF

chi sox

Spoiler

tyler flowers C
adam dunn 1B
gordon beckham 2B
leury garcia 3B, 2B/SS
alexei ramirez SS
marcus semien 3B, 2B
de aza LF, RF
adam eaton CF
jordan danks CF, RF
dayan viciedo RF, LF
moises sierra RF

cleveland

Spoiler

yan gomes C
nick swisher 1B, RF
mike aviles 3B, 2B/SS
michael brantley LF, CF
chris dickerson LF, CF
michael bourn CF
david murphy RF
ryan raburn RF, LF

detroit

Spoiler

alex avila C
migel cabrera 1B
victor martinez 1B
ian kinsler 2B
nick castellanos 3B
eugenio saurez 3B, SS
JD martinez LF, RF
ezequiel carera CF
torii hunter RF

kansas city

Spoiler

eric hosmer 1B
omar infante 2B
christian colon 3B, 2B/SS
raul ibanez LF, RF
josh willingham LF
lorenzo cain CF, RF
jarrod dyson CF
nori aoki RF

minny

Spoiler

eric fryer C
chris parmelee LF, 1B
trevor plouffe 3B
eduardo nunez 3B, LF
jordan schafer LF
oswaldo arcia RF

LAA

Spoiler

chris iannetta C
albert pujols 1B
elfren navarro LF, 1B
howie kendrick 2B
josh hamilton LF
jb shuck LF
mike trout CF
kole calhoun RF

oakland

Spoiler

john jaso C
eric sogard 2B, SS
josh donaldson 3B
nick punto 2B, SS
jed lowrie SS
coco crisp CF
sam fuld CF, LF
josh reddick RF

seattle

Spoiler

willie bloomquist LF, IF
dustin ackley LF
austin jackson CF
james jones CF
endy chavez RF, OF
michael saunders RF
chris denoforia RF
corey hart RF

texas

Spoiler

mitch morland 1B, LF
JP arencebia C, 1B
kevin kouzmanoff 3B
shin soo choo LF, RF
jake smolinski LF
jim adduci LF, RF
leonys martin CF
alex rios RF

houston

Spoiler

carlos corporan C
chris carter 1B
jesus guzman 1B, LF
marwin gonzalez 3B, 2B/SS
dexter fowler CF

[Mizzou24]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Gausman is a 95 potential and Chris Sale is a 93, very interesting. Carlos Martinez is way up there, walks?

Didn't touch pro potentials unless they were off or having break out years just prospects .. Martinez was sent down to triple A to work on his issues which are shown in the game.. Sale would be one that was missed. Walks has nothing to do with martinez's grade as a future player.

[FamousJamie]

Re: SBFM OS V1 roster mistakes

Turty for Orioles Chris Davis should have 3B as secondary position. Played there last week when Flaherty was at SS and earlier in year before Manny came back