I thought that was the case also, but there are other aspects which weigh into that.
I also only play on cpu vs cpu. It allows me to get a PURE set, minus human corruption.
I'll have to look up my settings from last night when I achieved just about the best game we can on Madden until the unnecessarily high pass catching is fixed. The accuracy isn't the problem as much as the receivers and backs catch just about EVERYTHING.
Begin thinking of the sliders with different labels when possible.
Another thing, I noticed that quarterbacks have plenty of incompletions when you apply the proper pressure. Aaron Rodgers started out 1-8 last night in my game. The Chiefs pass rush had him on the run from the jump.