As a guy who relies on sound a lot (sound is my graphics, being visually impaired) Wow, that sounded cool! Anyway, here's my take: Matty V is amazing on tv yes, and there is know reason why he cannot do the same when recording his lines. I can sit here and say the exact same lines he does, but with so much more excitement, it would blow your mind. I don't know why he can't "get into it," maybe I can do it so well, because being visually impaired, I don't need the "live game" in front of me to do pbp. The only thing I can think of that holds him back is he's not a good voice actor, in other words, he can't do it on command, he needs to have a live game in front of him. I'm the type of person who can do voice impressions of any baseball broadcaster, the first time I hear them, so maybe that's why I can do exciting pbp on command. Jon Miller is an amazing voice actor, which is why he was so good in 2k. That's my take! btw, here's a sample of my favorite baseball broadcast impression I do, this is a call to mlb xm some years ago, impression at the end. Enjoy guys!
http://yourlisten.com/manuel.aguero....live-on-xm-mlb