[SolidSquid]

Quote: Originally Posted by ajra21

this comes back to madden trying to be realistic. we want first round busts but we also want an effective scouting system. in a computer game, it's hard to have both. for me, the best way is to do these things: 1. OVR are not disclosed until after they complete their rookie season. 2. during the first first, rookie skills widely fluctuate allowing for guys to go from looking really good to looking bad.

Give me old school scouting. Compare the guys to current/legendary players, show me their combine results, show me college stats.