Ouch. Great question. The answer... is pretty ugly.
McManus has the worst... 57%
Zeurlein is at 58%
My kicker is 60%
Gb's kicker is 60%
Jax... 61%
Succop.. 63%...
Long story short.. 25 kickers have a PAT % less than 77% through 8 weeks. 10 of those 25 are below 70%. 7 of the 25 are between 70-75%
Vinatieri leads the league at 90. Santos is 85. Hopkins is at 84.
There's 3 guys at 80%.
I think 5 between 76-79.
Clearly, IMO, something is wrong with the sim engine when it comes to PAT's.
Can a mod please change the thread title? It's not just tied to supersim/play the moment, it's apparently the sim engine in general.