Well, I mean, I wont deny there are aspects of Madden's gameplay that are better, but lets be real here....the animation and physics in 2K are still better than anything Madden has ever been, and that directly translates to superior gameplay in many ways.....and beyond gameplay, youll see hings happen in 2K that youll never see happen in Madden.
I could list a ton of examples, but Ill just leave it at this...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngG0v5Lt2us
I know some people on here dont care for him, but this video is spot on. Ive been complaining about fade routes in Madden forever.