[Devaster]

I'll make sure to record footage of the next time it happens. It happens to me all the time though on post/corner routes when facing man coverage and my receiver beats the man. Instead of continuing to run and catch the ball they stop, jump, and attempt the catch. And it is usually a well thrown ball.

edit: Do you have to tap or hold the button to designate the type of catch? Also do you have to switch to the receiver and tap or hold the button to make the designated type of catch? I find myself a lot of times just holding down the possession button because I commit so many drops.