[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by SageInfinite

You must've hated Madden's commentary until they they got Gaudin and Davis then, lol. That's the one thing I can say Madden does well imo. I really enjoy the commentary, it's flawed and waaay off at times, but mostly I'm impressed with their consistency to update it and the way the game is called. Don't get me wrong, there are definitely things I enjoy about Madden, I wouldn't be here if I didn't, but I also have to be honest and discuss the problems as well. On topic though, I couldn't stick with 2k5 this whole time. I think Madden 17 and 18 are worth retiring it, lol. APF is a different story.

Even though it's outdated, I used to like Michaels/Summerall and Madden and some Jim Brown in the studio when EA had some presentation elements, but otherwise, you nailed it. Collingsworth, Johnson, Sims and Tony Bruno didn't move the needle on my end, ugh.

I have my issues, which are well documented with Madden, too.

There are areas of improvement needed all around.

If the OP is still reading the thread, if they have xbox and EA Access, download and try it for free.